Descartes Highlands

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Descartes Highlands sits in the lunar near side, a rugged stretch of ancient terrain that, before early 1972, had never been touched by human hands. Apollo 16 changed that, delivering astronauts John Young and Charles Duke to a landscape unlike anything any previous mission had encountered. Every earlier Apollo landing had sampled the flat, dark plains of the lunar maria. The Descartes Highlands represented something older, higher, and far less understood. Scientists were convinced they knew what was there: ancient volcanic rock, evidence of a Moon that had once erupted with thick, viscous lavas. That conviction turned out to be wrong. What Young and Duke actually found reshaped the understanding of how the Moon's highlands came to look the way they do. How did a region believed to be volcanic turn out to be almost entirely the product of bombardment? And why did the floor of at least one crater look, to the commander of Apollo 16, like dried mud?

• 2. Two Formations

  ›

  Two major geological formations define the Descartes Highlands: the Cayley Formation and the Descartes Formation. The Descartes Formation is composed primarily of highland plateau material, and geologists suspected before the mission that it originated as debris thrown out by a large impact event, specifically the one that created Mare Nectaris. The Cayley Formation sits alongside it, and the boundary between the two is not always clean. North Ray and South Ray craters, both prominent landmarks in the immediate landing area, exposed a layering sequence in their walls that may represent an overlap between the two formations. North Ray crater was sampled directly by the Apollo 16 crew during one of their surface excursions. The undulating landscape around the landing site is covered with craters of varying ages, some old and worn, others newer with sharp, distinct rims. The floors of some of those craters held a surprise: glass, comparable in character to glass found at Taurus-Littrow, the site where Apollo 17 would later land.

• 3. What Young Saw

  ›

  John Young, the commander of Apollo 16, described the arrangement of that crater-floor glass as resembling dried mud. The comparison is a useful one for understanding the texture and distribution of the material. Glass on the lunar surface typically forms when an impact generates enough heat to melt rock, and the resulting material freezes quickly in the vacuum. At Taurus-Littrow, a comparable glassy layer had been documented, giving scientists a reference point. The Descartes Highlands offered a second data set from a geologically distinct region, which made the parallel significant. The landscape itself is characterized by an undulating surface, shaped by layer upon layer of old impact events rather than by any smooth volcanic resurfacing. That distinction mattered enormously to the geologists who had spent years arguing about what the highlands were made of.

• 4. The Volcanic Hypothesis Falls

  ›

  Before Apollo 16 landed, the scientific consensus held that the Descartes region would yield volcanic rock in abundance. Visual study of the area had suggested that the formations there were produced by lavas more viscous than those that created the lunar maria. The maria themselves are dark, relatively flat, and clearly volcanic; the highlands look different, rougher, more complex, and researchers interpreted that difference as evidence of a distinct volcanic process. Sample analysis demolished that interpretation. The rocks Young and Duke brought back turned out to be breccias, fragments from multiple lunar impacts fused together by heat and pressure. There was no volcanic origin. The topography of the region, it became clear, was shaped entirely by meteor impacts. To prepare for that possibility, Young and Duke had traveled to Sudbury in Ontario, Canada, in July 1971. Sudbury is the site of a major ancient meteor impact, and it displays clear examples of shatter cone geology; the two astronauts went there to study shatter cones firsthand before encountering anything similar on the Moon.

• 5. Why Descartes Was Chosen

  ›

  The selection of the Descartes Highlands as an Apollo landing site came down to a specific scientific priority: sampling the lunar highlands, not just the maria. Every preceding Apollo mission had returned mare material, whether by landing directly on a mare or by collecting ejecta thrown onto the landing site from nearby mare regions. A highlands site was the next logical step. Two candidates were seriously considered: the Descartes site and the crater Alphonsus. Descartes won the evaluation. Part of the reason was the concentration of both the Descartes and Cayley formations in a relatively small area, giving the crew a chance to sample two widespread geological units in a single mission. Those two formations together cover much of the near side of the Moon, making samples from them scientifically valuable far beyond the local landing zone. The mission planners also specifically wanted rocks older than the Imbrium impact, the colossal collision that reshaped a significant portion of the lunar near side. Material predating Imbrium would provide a window into the Moon's earliest geological history, and the Descartes Highlands was thought to offer exactly that.