Clan Donald
Clan Donald is one of the largest Scottish clans, and for centuries its chiefs carried a title no other Scottish noble could claim: Lord of the Isles. That title gave the MacDonalds dominion over a vast arc of sea and island territory stretching from the Hebrides toward Ireland, a power base so formidable that the armies of the MacDonald Lords were, for a time, the only magnate forces in Scotland capable of defeating the Crown in open battle. Then, in 1493, the Crown stripped that lordship away. What happened next shaped the Highlands for generations. How did a clan trace its roots to both Norse kings and the ancient High Kings of Ireland? What did it mean to hold the right wing of the Scottish army as a royal privilege? And why did the fall of the Lordship of the Isles leave a wound that refused to heal, reaching all the way to a winter massacre in Glencoe in 1692?
Dòmhnall Mac Raghnuill, who died around 1250, is the founding ancestor from whom the entire clan takes its name. His grandfather Somerled was styled "King of the Hebrides" and was killed campaigning against Malcolm IV of Scotland at the Battle of Renfrew in 1164. Somerled's descendants split into two great dynasties: the MacDonalds, descending from his younger line, and the MacDougalls, tracing their line from his elder son Dugall mac Somhairle. Together they are called the Clann Somhairle, a name that marks their shared origin in one warrior ancestor.
Somerled's wife, Ragnhildis Olafsdottir, was the daughter of Olaf I Godredsson, King of Mann and the Isles. Through her mother, Ingeborg Haakonsdottir, the family was also connected to the Earls of Orkney. This maternal network wound Norse royal blood deep into the clan's lineage, even as their bards insisted on a pure Gaelic heritage. The medieval seanchaidhean, the Gaelic historians, traced Somerled's male line back through the High Kings of Ireland to Colla Uais and Conn of the Hundred Battles. From this, the MacDonalds called themselves Clann Cholla and Siol Chuinn: Children of Colla and Seed of Conn.
A 2005 DNA study tested the Y-chromosome of men bearing the surnames MacDonald, MacDougall, MacAlister, and their variants. A substantial proportion shared the same Y-DNA and a direct paternal ancestor. The distinct haplotype found, R1a1, is regarded as often indicating Norse descent in Britain and Ireland. The Gaelic genealogies were political as much as historical, and the DNA evidence points toward the Norse side of the family's tangled heritage. A poem composed for John of Islay, who lived from 1434 to 1503, still proclaimed: "The Headship of the Gael to the family of Colla, it is right to proclaim it."
Aonghus Og of Islay, grandson of the first Aonghas Mor who had been a vassal of Haakon IV of Norway, chose his loyalties carefully at the Battle of Bannockburn in 1314. He supported Robert the Bruce, and the king rewarded the entire clan with a lasting honour: Clan Donald would always hold the position of right wing in the Scottish army, the post of greatest prestige in Highland battle formation.
Donald of Islay, Lord of the Isles, pressed that prestige into territorial ambition in the early 15th century. He married Mariota, Countess of Ross, the heiress of the Leslie Earls of Ross, and through that marriage he staked a claim to the Earldom of Ross. In 1411, his forces seized Dingwall Castle, the principal seat of that earldom. The move triggered the Battle of Harlaw on the 24th of July 1411, where Donald's army, believed to number 10,000 men, met the forces of Robert Stewart, Duke of Albany, led by Alexander Stewart, Earl of Mar. Donald inflicted a decisive victory but turned his army back to the Western Highlands without pressing south to Aberdeen.
The MacDonald grip on Ross proved durable but not permanent. Donald's son Alexander became both Lord of the Isles and Earl of Ross, his position confirmed by a charter dated September 1437, shortly after the assassination of James I of Scotland in February of that year. Alexander's own son, John of Islay, Earl of Ross, surrendered the earldom in 1475 to King James III. The royal forfeiture of the MacDonald Earldom of Ross in 1475 was a turning point; the Books of Clanranald described what followed as a "great struggle for power among the Gael." The Lordship of the Isles itself was not formally forfeited until 1493, but in practical terms the writing was already on the wall.
After 1493, the various branches of Clan Donald found themselves navigating a political landscape shaped by their own former enemies. The ultimate victors in the struggle to fill the power vacuum left by the fallen lordship were Alexander Gordon, 3rd Earl of Huntly, chief of Clan Gordon; Archibald Campbell, 2nd Earl of Argyll, chief of Clan Campbell; and John MacIain of Ardnamurchan. The Crown's strategy was deliberate: by issuing individual charters to the separate MacDonald branches, recognising each as the holder of its own lands, the royal government kept the clan divided. A divided Clan Donald posed far less danger to central authority than a united one.
Domhnall Dubh, illegitimate son of Aonghas Og, made repeated attempts to restore the lordship. He rebelled against James IV of Scotland, formed an alliance with Henry VIII of England, and kept resistance alive into the 16th century. By 1545 all those attempts had failed. Domhnall Dubh himself died in that year. Across the water, the MacDonnells of Antrim, a branch of the MacDonalds of Dunnyveg, had been migrating to the Glens and to Rathlin Island in increasing numbers from the early 16th century, having rejected overtures from an increasingly powerful James IV.
The loss of a single coherent territorial block left the MacDonalds holding lands on either side of the Irish Sea with no unified administration. Their repeated efforts to recover ground destabilised Western Scotland for generations. To address the endemic feuding this produced, the charge of "slaughter under trust" was introduced in Scots law in 1587. It applied to murder committed after articles of surrender had been agreed, or after hospitality had been accepted. The first recorded use of this charge came in 1588, in the prosecution of Lachlan Maclean, whose hostility to his stepfather John MacDonald had resulted in the killing of 18 members of a MacDonald wedding party.
In 1644, Alasdair Mac Colla landed in Scotland with 1,500 Irish troops. He came from Clan Donald of Dunnyveg, the branch that had historically held territory in the western Scottish islands and North-East Ireland. His objective was to recover MacDonald lands in the Western Highlands; the campaign that followed, fought alongside the Royalist commander Montrose, was among the most successful of the Wars of the Three Kingdoms. Victory at the Battle of Inverlochy left Montrose in effective control of Scotland.
The Inverlochy campaign has often been framed as a straight fight between Campbells and MacDonalds, and there is truth in that framing. Montrose used it as a deliberate recruiting tool, and the memory persisted in Gaelic folklore. But many other parties were involved, and the alliance was built on incompatible goals. Mac Colla wanted to hold ground in the west; Montrose wanted to march south in support of Charles I. The two men split. Mac Colla's ravaging of Campbell lands was still recalled with deep bitterness 300 years later.
The worst single event came in February 1692. In the Massacre of Glencoe, 38 unarmed MacDonalds from the Clan MacDonald of Glencoe were murdered. The chief, MacIain, had been late in signing an oath of allegiance to William III of England, and an initiative to suppress Jacobitism became entangled in long-running feuding. The legal charge used to pursue accountability was the same "slaughter under trust" provision that had first appeared in 1587. The event would later serve as part of the inspiration for "The Red Wedding" as featured in books and the television series Game of Thrones, a measure of how deeply that breach of hospitality and trust struck something universal.
Through the 18th century, most branches of Clan Donald cast their lot with the Stuart cause. At the Battle of Sheriffmuir on the 13th of November 1715, men of Clan MacDonald of Keppoch and the Clan Macdonald of Clanranald fought for the Jacobites; their chief, Allan MacDonald of Clanranald, was killed in that engagement. The Clan MacDonald of Glencoe also fought at Sheriffmuir.
Thirty years later, in the Jacobite rising of 1745, the commitment was even broader. The Clan MacDonell of Glengarry, the Clan MacDonald of Keppoch, and the MacDonalds of Glencoe all fought at the Battle of Prestonpans on the 21st of September 1745. The same groups, joined by the Clan MacDonald of Clanranald, were at the Battle of Falkirk Muir on the 17th of January 1746. At Culloden in April 1746, four MacDonald branches fought for Prince Charles Edward Stuart; the chief of Clan MacDonald of Keppoch, Alexander MacDonald of Keppoch, was killed there.
The exception was the Clan MacDonald of Sleat. Though they had fought for the Jacobites in 1715, Sleat formed two battalions of Independent Highland Companies in support of the British Government in 1745, and as a result their landholdings survived intact. According to the historians A and A MacDonald, however, those two companies were more of a hindrance than a help to the government side, because the officers and men were in entire sympathy with Prince Charles. It is a detail that captures the ambiguity of clan politics: loyalty measured in land preserved rather than convictions held.
In 1947, the Lord Lyon King of Arms granted the undifferenced arms of Macdonald to Alexander Godfrey Macdonald, 7th Lord Macdonald, formally recognising him as the first High Chief of Clan Donald. After his death in 1970, his son Godfrey James Macdonald of Macdonald, 8th Lord Macdonald, succeeded him. The Macdonald estates were sold in 1972 to pay death duties. Lord Macdonald lives at Kinloch Lodge on Skye with his wife Claire Macdonald, the food writer, whom he married in 1969.
The physical record of the clan's centuries of power is scattered across a long sweep of Scottish and Irish coast. Finlaggan Castle, on an island in Loch Finlaggan on the Isle of Islay, was the seat of the Lords of the Isles; Castle Tioram on Loch Moidart served the Clanranald branch; Invergarry Castle, built on the Rock of the Raven, belonged to Clan MacDonnell of Glengarry; and Dunluce Castle in Ireland was the seat of the MacDonnell Earls of Antrim.
Armadale Castle on the Isle of Skye, begun in 1815, now houses the Clan Donald Centre and the Museum of the Isles, which remain open to the public. Dunaverty Castle, off the coast of Kintyre, carries the name Blood Rock from a massacre that took place there. From Finlaggan to Armadale, the castles trace the full arc of the clan's trajectory: from the seat of a power that defied Scottish kings to a public museum preserving the memory of what was lost.
Common questions
Who founded Clan Donald and where does the name come from?
Clan Donald takes its name from Dòmhnall Mac Raghnuill, who died around 1250. He was the grandson of Somerled, styled King of the Hebrides, and the clan's founding ancestor in the direct male line.
What was the Lordship of the Isles and when did Clan Donald lose it?
The Lordship of the Isles was a title held by the chiefs of Clan Donald, giving them dominion over a large arc of island and coastal territory in western Scotland. The Crown forfeited the MacDonald Earldom of Ross in 1475 and stripped the Lordship of the Isles itself in 1493.
Did a DNA study confirm Clan Donald's Norse or Gaelic origins?
A 2005 DNA study tested Y-chromosomes of men bearing the surnames MacDonald, MacDougall, MacAlister, and their variants. A substantial proportion shared the same Y-DNA, the R1a1 haplotype, which is regarded as often indicating Norse descent in Britain and Ireland, supporting Norse rather than purely Gaelic male-line origins.
How many MacDonalds were killed in the Massacre of Glencoe?
38 unarmed MacDonalds from the Clan MacDonald of Glencoe were murdered in February 1692. Their chief, MacIain, had been late in signing an oath of allegiance to William III of England, and an initiative to suppress Jacobitism became entangled in long-standing feuding.
Did Clan Donald fight at the Battle of Culloden in 1745?
Four branches of Clan Donald fought for Prince Charles Edward Stuart at the Battle of Culloden in April 1746: the Clan MacDonald of Glencoe, the Clan MacDonald of Clanranald, the Clan MacDonell of Glengarry, and the Clan MacDonald of Keppoch, whose chief Alexander MacDonald of Keppoch was killed there.
Who is the current High Chief of Clan Donald and where do they live?
Godfrey James Macdonald of Macdonald, 8th Lord Macdonald, is the current High Chief of Clan Donald. He succeeded his father in 1970 and lives at Kinloch Lodge on the Isle of Skye with his wife, the food writer Claire Macdonald.
All sources
47 references cited across the entry
- 1webAinmean PearsantaMac an Tàilleir, Iain
- 2bookThe Clans, Septs & Regiments of the Scottish HighlandsAdam, Frank et al. — Johnston and Bacon — 1970
- 3webThe Various Spellings of the Surname MacDonaldLarry McDonald
- 6newsDNA shows Celtic hero Somerled's Viking rootsApril 26, 2005
- 7bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 8bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 9bookOxford Companion to Scottish HistoryOxford University Press — 2011
- 10bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 11bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 12bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 13bookHistory of the House and Clan of MacKayRobert Mackay — 1829
- 14bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 15bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 16bookThe history of Great Britain: from the first invasion by the Romans under Julius Caesar. Written on a new planRobert Henry et al. — Cadell and Davies — 1814
- 17bookHighland PapersHugh MacDonald — 1914
- 18bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 19bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 20bookA Genealogical History of the Earldom of SutherlandRobert Gordon — Printed by George Ramsay and Co. for Archibald Constable and Company Edinburgh; and White, Cochrance and Co. London — 1813
- 21bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 22bookCollins Scottish Clan & Family EncyclopediaGeorge of Plean Way et al. — HarperCollins Publishers — 1994
- 23bookRebellion: Britain's First Stuart Kings, 1567–1642Tim Harris — OUP Oxford — 2015
- 24bookThe Massacre in History (War and Genocide)Berghahn Books — 1999
- 25bookCivil War: The Wars of the Three Kingdoms 1638–1660Royle — London: Abacus — 2004
- 27bookRebellion: Britain's First Stuart Kings, 1567-1642Tim Harris — OUP Oxford — 2015
- 28bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 30bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 31bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 32bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 33bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 34bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 35bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company — 1900
- 36bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 37bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 38bookThe Clan DonaldAngus Macdonald et al. — The Northern Counties Publishing Company, Ltd — 1900
- 40webLady Claire MacdonaldCoutts
- 41webLady Claire Macdonald: the red rose of Kinloch20 February 2013
- 43bookClan DonaldDonald J. Macdonald of Castleton — Macdonald Publishers Ltd — 1979
- 44bookCastles of the Clans: The Strongholds and Seats of 750 Scottish Families and ClansMartin Coventry — Goblinshead — 2008
- 47webInvergarry Castle