City State of the Invincible Overlord

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  City State of the Invincible Overlord made its debut in a parking lot. At Gen Con IX in 1976, Bob Bledsaw and Bill Owen arrived without vendor registration. A card table and a handmade banner were all they had on the convention floor. Convention rules barred unregistered sellers from displaying merchandise. Whenever a customer wanted a map, one of the two men walked the buyer outside and over to the car. The maps were stored in the trunk. At the same event, Bledsaw and Owen also sold subscriptions to packets of city information. That improvised beginning launched what became the first published city setting in fantasy role-playing history. The questions worth pursuing are these: what made this city different from anything that had come before? How did a supplement sold from a car trunk shape the larger hobby? And what do the critics, from the 1970s through 2023, reveal about the enduring difficulty of designing a believable fantasy city?

  13

• 2. Inside Thunderhold

  ›

  Thirty-four inches by forty-four inches: that was the full size of the map at the heart of City State of the Invincible Overlord. Spread across four pages, it depicted a settlement called Thunderhold. Thunderhold had begun as a city inspired by Bob Bledsaw's personal campaign, developed and expanded for commercial publication. The design treated it as a hub for two distinct kinds of play. A gamemaster could use it as a base of operations for adventures in the wider world. Equally, the city itself could generate its own stories. The book filled out the setting with descriptions of Thunderhold's notable inhabitants and a table of random encounters. A list of rumors gave the gamemaster ready material to plant in any session. A companion product called Wraith Overlord extended Thunderhold downward. It mapped the city's subterranean cellars, sewers, and catacombs, giving gamemasters an entire hidden layer beneath the streets.

  1310

• 3. From Map to Company

  ›

  By late 1977, the accumulated city materials had been gathered into a single package. That volume carried the full title City State of the Invincible Overlord for the first time in print. Cumulative sales records show that by 1981 the supplement had moved over 40,000 units. That performance established Judges Guild as a going concern in the young hobby-game industry. The supplement also anchored something larger. It became the centerpiece of Wilderlands of High Fantasy, the first licensed and officially published campaign setting for Dungeons & Dragons. Three publishers and a span of nearly thirty years of further printings lay ahead for the supplement.

  135

• 4. Seven Editions, Three Publishers

  ›

  The 1976 edition of City State of the Invincible Overlord was a 16-page booklet. By 1977, a revised version had grown to 56 pages. The printings from 1978 through 1980 expanded the book to 80 pages, with three separate printings issued during that period. A further revised edition from 1981 to 1983 pushed the page count to 96 pages across three more printings. The 1983 printing quietly dropped the phrase 'Approved for use with D&D' from its cover. That change reflected a shift in the supplement's relationship with the Dungeons & Dragons license. The Mayfair Games edition of 1987 took a radically different form. It arrived as a boxed set rather than a book. The box contained an 80-page Map and Population volume and a 32-page Background and Encounter book. A full-color map showed the city on its front side and an island campaign setting on its reverse. The set also included a Players' Map and a 16-page adventure book. Four 8-page Race Guides and two plastic overlay sheets for tracing city and wilderness routes completed the package. Mayfair issued a companion supplement called the Calandia Guidebook in 1989. Bob Bledsaw led Judges Guild back to the internet in early 1999. He sold long-warehoused products, including a new printing of the 1981-83 edition. Judges Guild announced a partnership with Necromancer Games in June 2002. Necromancer began releasing Judges Guild products in 2003. The following year they published a 288-page hardcover collectors' edition of City State, a reprint of the 1983 edition with an updated booty list. A large collectors' edition of Wilderlands of High Fantasy followed in 2005.

  135

• 5. What the Critics Heard

  ›

  Issue three of White Dwarf, published in late 1977, carried one of the earliest recorded responses to the City State supplement. Reviewer Don Turnbull praised the 1977 Judges Guild edition as 'something of a triumph.' He called it 'a labour of love' and said it 'should be welcome in any fantasy gamer's collection.' Patrick Amory, reviewing the supplement for Different Worlds magazine, wrote that the City State 'generally deserves the praise it gets and is well-worth the money.' That appreciation held for roughly a decade. Then the Mayfair edition arrived, and the critical response divided. Jim Bambra reviewed the new release for issue 136 of Dragon, published in August 1988. He found the production values impressive but the contents disappointing. Bambra wrote that 'gone are the winding alleys and jumbled buildings, now replaced by a pretty but unconvincing suburban playground.' He called the city 'a town-planner's dream' that was 'hardly the stuff of a bustling fantasy city.' Bambra did single out the Background and Encounter Book as 'vibrant and exciting.' His overall verdict was firm. He called the release 'a good example of how not to go about designing a city.' Ian Marsh, writing in the October 1988 issue of Games International, shared the concern. He found the Mayfair version offered 'very little that is new, but without having the same character as the original.' Marsh argued that genuine city adventure requires players to be drawn into the workings of urban life. 'Characters in a city need adventures that embroil them in the running of that city,' he wrote. He concluded that the referee-facing material was unhelpful and would need significant adaptation for most campaigns. Rick Swan offered a calmer view in his 1990 book The Complete Guide to Role-Playing Games. He noted that adapting a generic supplement to a specific campaign always demands extra effort from the referee. Continuity problems were an inherent limitation of the format. Even so, he called City State of the Invincible Overlord 'a great buy' for referees in the market for that kind of material. The most recent assessment came from RPG historian Stu Horvath in his 2023 book Monsters, Aliens, and Holes in the Ground. Horvath observed that 'plausibility is never a consideration' in the City State. He argued that this was 'the source of much of the charm.' 'The intricate presentation of the city,' Horvath concluded, 'is unprecedented for the time.'

  45679