31st Annual Grammy Awards

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  On the 22nd of February 1989, the Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles became the stage for a Grammy ceremony that broke with decades of tradition in a single, charged moment. For the first time ever, the Recording Academy carved out a separate rap section, acknowledging a genre that had reshaped American music. But the night's biggest statement may have come not from the podium but from the audience, where Sinéad O'Connor had painted the logo of Public Enemy on her head as a pointed protest.

  The ceremony handed Album of the Year to George Michael for Faith and Song of the Year to Bobby McFerrin for "Don't Worry, Be Happy." Those two wins framed an evening full of surprises, from a metal award that shocked the rock world to a folk singer from Cleveland, Tennessee who walked away with multiple prizes.

  What made the 31st ceremony genuinely unusual was how many of its decisions defied expectation. The rap category, the hard rock award, and the choices made inside both of them would be debated long after the Shrine Auditorium emptied.

  13

• 2. The Rap Debut

  ›

  The Best Rap Performance category existed for the first time in 1989, and the nominees alone signaled how much ground hip-hop had covered. DJ Jazzy Jeff and The Fresh Prince took the award for "Parents Just Don't Understand," beating out J.J. Fad's "Supersonic," Kool Moe Dee's "Wild Wild West," LL Cool J's "Going Back to Cali," and Salt-N-Pepa's "Push It."

  The category's debut came with a significant asterisk. The Recording Academy chose to present the Best Rap Performance award off-screen, not during the televised broadcast. That decision drew open protest from Sinéad O'Connor, who painted the Public Enemy logo on her shaved head as a visible objection before the cameras.

  Kool Moe Dee was among the presenters at the ceremony that night, a detail that showed the Academy was eager to involve hip-hop artists even as it sidelined the genre's own award from the main telecast. The contradiction was not lost on observers at the time, and the off-screen presentation would remain a point of contention for years.

  3

• 3. The Metal Upset

  ›

  Best Hard Rock/Metal Performance was also a brand-new category at the 31st ceremony, and its outcome became one of the most-discussed decisions in Grammy history. Jethro Tull won for Crest of a Knave, defeating Metallica, who were widely considered the heavy favorite going in.

  Lita Ford and Alice Cooper presented the award that evening, giving the category a rock-credible pair of announcers. Metallica performed "One" during the broadcast, making their loss all the more vivid for viewers who had just watched the band on stage.

  The pairing of two new categories in a single night, rap and hard rock/metal, both of them carrying controversial outcomes, made the 31st ceremony an unusual referendum on how the Academy handled popular music at its harder edges.

  3

• 4. Bobby McFerrin's Sweep

  ›

  Bobby McFerrin left the 31st ceremony with three separate wins. He took Record of the Year with producer Linda Goldstein for "Don't Worry, Be Happy," Song of the Year as songwriter, and Best Pop Vocal Performance, Male for the same track. He also won Best Jazz Vocal Performance, Male for "Brothers."

  On stage, McFerrin performed alongside Billy Crystal in an a cappella and comedy segment, a pairing that captured something of his crossover appeal. His voice carried him across genre lines in a single evening, from pop to jazz, in a way few artists had managed at a Grammy ceremony.

  The Best Jazz Vocal Performance, Male award pointed toward a separate current in his career, one that Tracy Chapman's Best Jazz Vocal Performance, Female win for "Fast Car" interestingly paralleled. Chapman also claimed Best Pop Vocal Performance, Female and Best Contemporary Folk Recording for her debut album, making her the other multi-winner of the night alongside McFerrin.

  12

• 5. Classical and Ensemble Honors

  ›

  Robert Shaw and the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra appeared in multiple categories, ultimately winning Best Orchestral Recording for the Rorem program, Best Choral Performance for the Verdi Requiem, and Best Classical Album for the same Verdi recording. Robert Woods produced the winning classical album and also won Classical Producer of the Year.

  Vladimir Horowitz won Best Classical Performance for Instrumental Soloist with Orchestra, performing Mozart's Piano Concerto No. 23 with Carlo Maria Giulini conducting the La Scala Opera Orchestra. That performance was among Horowitz's final recordings.

  John Adams received Best Contemporary Composition for Nixon in China, conducted by Edo de Waart with the Orchestra of St. Luke's. The opera had premiered in 1987 and its Grammy recognition two years later reflected a growing institutional interest in American contemporary opera. The Best Opera Recording went to Georg Solti conducting the Vienna State Opera Orchestra for Wagner's Lohengrin, with a cast that included Plácido Domingo, Jessye Norman, and Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau.

  12

• 6. The Broader Field

  ›

  Tracy Chapman's self-titled debut album claimed Best Contemporary Folk Recording, connecting her Grammy haul across pop and folk categories simultaneously. The Best Traditional Folk Recording went to Folkways: A Vision Shared, a tribute album honoring Woody Guthrie and Leadbelly.

  In country, K.T. Oslin won both Best Country Vocal Performance Female and Best Country Song for "Hold Me," while Randy Travis took Best Country Vocal Performance Male for Old 8x10. The Judds won Best Country Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocal for "Give a Little Love," and k.d. lang and Roy Orbison took Best Country Vocal Collaboration for "Crying."

  U2 won Best Rock Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocal for "Desire" and also won Best Performance Music Video for "Where The Streets Have No Name," directed by Meiert Avis. Robin Williams won Best Comedy Recording for Good Morning Vietnam, and also appeared as co-winner on Best Recording for Children, Pecos Bill, produced with Ry Cooder and Mark Sottnick. The ceremony's performers included Leontyne Price singing from Puccini's Madama Butterfly, Metallica, and Itzhak Perlman joining Tracy Chapman for her performance of "Fast Car."

  1