Élie Metchnikoff

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Élie Metchnikoff inserted tiny citrus thorns into the larvae of starfish and then waited. What he saw in 1882 would alter the course of medicine. Unusual cells had gathered around the thorns, surrounding them, as if mounting a defence. Metchnikoff was working in a private laboratory he had set up in Messina, Sicily, and in that moment he glimpsed the immune system doing something no scientist had named before. The process he had just witnessed would eventually be called phagocytosis. The cell responsible would be called a phagocyte, specifically a macrophage. These discoveries would earn him a Nobel Prize, the title "father of innate immunity," and a second title no less grand: "father of gerontology." Yet his path to those honours ran through personal catastrophe, political exile, two suicide attempts, and decades of fierce scepticism from some of the most powerful scientists in the world. The questions that follow are not just about a man or a prize. They are about how an idea that challenges orthodoxy survives long enough to be proved right.

• 2. Roots and Early Formation

  ›

  Metchnikoff was born in the village of Ivanovka, in Kharkov Governorate, in the Russian Empire, in a territory that is now Kupiansk Raion, Kharkiv Oblast in Ukraine. He was the youngest of five children. His father, Ilya Ivanovich Mechnikov, was an officer of the Imperial Guard. His mother, Emilia Lvovna, was the daughter of the writer Leo Nevakhovich, and the Nevakhovich family was Jewish. Despite this heritage, Metchnikoff was baptized Russian Orthodox; he later became an atheist. The family name itself carried history. It was a translation from Romanian, tracing back to the Chancellor Yuri Stefanovich, the grandson of Nicolae Milescu Spatarul, a title meaning Sword-bearer. Yuri Stefanovich had fled to Russia together with Dimitrie Cantemir in 1711, following the failed campaign of Peter I on the Danubian Principalities. For roughly two and a half centuries, the Mechnikov family had lived in Saint Petersburg, growing connected by family ties with many Russian princely families. His elder brother Lev became a prominent geographer and sociologist.

  In 1856, the young Metchnikoff entered the Kharkov Lycee and began developing what would become a lifelong absorption in biology. His mother persuaded him to study natural sciences rather than medicine. He tried in 1862 to begin at the University of Wurzburg in Germany, but the German academic session would not begin before year's end. He enrolled instead at Kharkov Imperial University and completed a four-year degree in two years. In 1864, he traveled to the North Sea island of Heligoland to study marine fauna, where the botanist Ferdinand Cohn advised him to work with Rudolf Leuckart at the University of Giessen. At Leuckart's laboratory he made his first discovery: alternation of generations, both sexual and asexual, in nematodes of the order Chaetosomatida. The following year, still at Giessen, he observed intracellular digestion in flatworms, a finding that would shape his later thinking. A cholera epidemic in autumn 1865 sent him briefly to the University of Gottingen, where he worked with W. M. Keferstein and Jakob Henle. In 1867 he returned to Russia and received his doctorate from the University of Saint Petersburg together with Alexander Kovalevsky, the two of them winning the Karl Ernst von Baer prize for their theses on germ-layer development in invertebrate embryos.

• 3. The Discovery of Phagocytosis

  ›

  Carl Friedrich Wilhelm Claus, Professor of Zoology at the University of Vienna, supplied the word. Metchnikoff had already seen the process; it was Claus who, when Metchnikoff described how certain cells could surround and kill pathogens, suggested calling such a cell a "phagocyte." Metchnikoff delivered his findings formally at Odessa University in 1883, one year after his observations in Messina. He had realised that in animals with blood, white blood cells gather at sites of inflammation. His hypothesis was that these cells attacked and killed bacteria rather than simply spreading them. The idea was direct and logical, but it contradicted the dominant view held by leading bacteriologists of the time, who believed white blood cells ingested pathogens only to carry them further into the body.

  The scepticism he faced was formidable. Louis Pasteur, Emil von Behring, and others were among those unconvinced. His most significant supporter was Rudolf Virchow, who published Metchnikoff's research in his journal, then known as the Archiv fur pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und fur klinische Medicin and now called the Virchows Archiv. In 1887, Metchnikoff observed that leukocytes isolated from the blood of various animals were drawn toward certain bacteria. Later research by Joseph Denys and Joseph Leclef, followed by Leon Marchand and Mennes between 1895 and 1898, built on the phenomenon he had identified. Almroth E. Wright was the first to measure it precisely and argued forcefully for its potential in treatment. Some 85 years after Metchnikoff's original observation, laboratory work confirmed that the attracting elements were low-molecular-weight N-formylated oligopeptides, including N-formylmethionine-leucyl-phenylalanine, produced by replicating gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria. That chain of enquiry, stretching across nearly a century, began in Messina with a citrus thorn and a starfish larva.

• 4. Aging, Yogurt, and Probiotics

  ›

  Bulgarian peasants provided Metchnikoff with a living argument. He attributed their longevity to their consumption of yogurt containing what he called the Bulgarian bacteria, now classified as Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus. From this observation he built a theory: aging was caused by toxic bacteria in the gut, and lactic acid could prolong life. He drank sour milk every day throughout his own life as a form of self-experimentation. His conclusions appeared in two books, The Nature of Man: Studies in Optimistic Philosophy, published in 1903, and more fully in The Prolongation of Life: Optimistic Studies, published in 1907. He called the broader concept "orthobiosis." The idea was influential during his lifetime and then was largely set aside until the mid-1990s, when experimental evidence began to revive it under the label probiotics.

  He is also credited with coining the term gerontology in 1903 for the emerging study of aging and longevity, earning him the informal title "father of gerontology," though as he himself acknowledged, such titles in science are rarely undisputed. His self-experimentation was not limited to sour milk. During the 1892 cholera epidemic in France, he noticed that some people fell ill and others did not, even when equally exposed. To probe this, he drank a sample of cholera and did not become sick. Two volunteers participated in further trials; one was unaffected while the other nearly died. From this he proposed that differences in susceptibility were linked to differences in intestinal microbes. He had also discovered earlier, in 1879, that fungal infections could kill insects, and together with his student Isaak Krasilschik he explored biological control of insect pests in agricultural fields, making use of green muscardine.

• 5. A Life Under Pressure

  ›

  Metchnikoff married his first wife, Ludmila Feodorovitch, in 1869. She died from tuberculosis on the 20th of April 1873. Her death, alongside other difficulties he faced at the time, led him to attempt suicide by taking a large dose of opium. He survived, and in 1875 he married his student Olga Belokopytova. In 1880, Olga fell severely ill with typhoid. This triggered his second suicide attempt: he injected himself with the spirochete of relapsing fever. He also survived this. Olga herself lived until 1944, dying in Paris from typhoid.

  Political pressures shaped his career just as powerfully as personal grief. He resigned from Odessa University in 1882 following the political turmoil that erupted after the assassination of Tsar Alexander II. He went to Sicily to build his own laboratory, free of institutional constraints. He then returned to Odessa as director of an institute working with Louis Pasteur's rabies vaccine, but difficulties there drove him out again in 1888. He went to Paris to seek Pasteur's counsel directly. Pasteur gave him a position at the Pasteur Institute, and Metchnikoff remained there for the rest of his life. He had been appointed a docent at the newly established Imperial Novorossiya University at just twenty-two years of age, younger than his own students. He had transferred from there to the University of Saint Petersburg in 1868 after a conflict with a senior colleague over attending scientific meetings, only to find a worse professional environment waiting for him. The Pasteur Institute, by contrast, gave him the stability to complete the work that would define his reputation. He also collaborated there with Emile Roux on the use of calomel, a mercurous chloride ointment, in attempts to prevent people from contracting syphilis.

• 6. The Nobel and Its Legacy

  ›

  The 1908 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine was awarded jointly to Metchnikoff and Paul Ehrlich "in recognition of their work on immunity." The pairing was fitting. Metchnikoff had established what became the concept of cell-mediated immunity through his work on phagocytes. Ehrlich had established the concept of humoral immunity. Together their frameworks were regarded as founding the science of immunology. The two lines of thinking had been treated as competing; the resolution, showing how each operated in distinct contexts, came through work by Almroth Wright after 1903 on opsonins, molecules that enhance phagocytic killing in the presence of specific antiserum. Metchnikoff himself had acknowledged the stimulatory effect of immunosensitized serum on phagocytic function in acquired immunity.

  Beyond the Nobel, Metchnikoff received the Copley Medal of the Royal Society in 1906, an honorary degree from the University of Cambridge, and honorary memberships of both the Academy of Medicine in Paris and the Academy of Sciences and Medicine in Saint Petersburg. He died in 1916 in Paris from heart failure. Following the instructions in his will, his body was used for medical research and then cremated at Pere Lachaise Cemetery. His cinerary urn was placed in the library of the Pasteur Institute, the institution that had sheltered the most productive decades of his life. Supporters of life extension have since designated the 15th of May as Metchnikoff Day, using the date to organise activities in his memory.