Skip to content

Questions about The Bonnie Blue Flag

Short answers, pulled from the story.

Who wrote The Bonnie Blue Flag and when was it first performed?

The Bonnie Blue Flag was written by entertainer Harry McCarthy, who premiered it during a concert in Jackson, Mississippi, in the spring of 1861. He performed it again in September of that same year at the New Orleans Academy of Music for the First Texas Volunteer Infantry regiment.

What is the melody of The Bonnie Blue Flag based on?

The melody of The Bonnie Blue Flag was taken from an existing Irish song called The Irish Jaunting Car. Harry McCarthy wrote new Confederate lyrics to fit that tune.

Why did Union General Benjamin Butler ban The Bonnie Blue Flag?

Major General Benjamin Butler allegedly banned the song after capturing New Orleans, having publisher A. E. Blackmar arrested and fined five hundred dollars, ordering all copies destroyed, and imposing a twenty-five-dollar fine on anyone caught whistling or singing it.

How many editions of The Bonnie Blue Flag did A. E. Blackmar publish?

The New Orleans music publishing house of A. E. Blackmar issued six editions of The Bonnie Blue Flag between 1861 and 1864, along with three additional arrangements. Eleven other editions with different lyrics were also published.

Does The Bonnie Blue Flag list the Confederate states in the correct secession order?

No. The third verse rearranges the secession order for meter. Alabama is placed second, after South Carolina, but in reality Mississippi seceded on the 9th of January, 1861, and Florida on the 10th before Alabama departed on the 11th of January.

What Union counter-versions of The Bonnie Blue Flag existed?

At least three Union adaptations circulated. J. L. Geddes, a British-born colonel, wrote The Bonnie Flag With the Stripes and Stars in 1863. Mrs. C. Sterett wrote a second version published by S. T. Gordon of 538 Broadway Street in New York. The same tune also served as the anthem of the 69th New York regiment of the Irish Brigade.