Skip to content

Questions about Continuity thesis

Short answers, pulled from the story.

What is the continuity thesis regarding European intellectual history?

The continuity thesis posits that modern mechanics and physics proceeded from doctrines professed in medieval schools through an uninterrupted series of improvements. Pierre Duhem argued that the Roman Catholic Church fostered Western scientific development rather than hindering it.

Who supported the continuity thesis between 1884 and 1956?

George Sarton became a notable supporter of continuity arguments during his active years between 1884 and 1956. He stressed historical continuity across time periods and claimed science had to be introduced to Western culture twice.

When did Nicole Oresme invent graphs and perform calculations involving probability?

Nicole Oresme invented graphs and performed calculations involving probability during the twelfth century. This period represents the real renaissance according to James Franklin who challenged the idea of a European Renaissance as a myth.

Why did George Saliba expand on critiques of modern science in 1999?

George Saliba expanded on these critiques in 1999 when reviewing Toby E. Huff's work on Islam, China and the West. He questioned whether Ptolemy or Copernicus were closer to modern science than Chinese or Maya astronomers.

What factors created origins of modern science within medieval times according to Edward Grant?

Edward Grant identified four factors combining to create origins of modern science within medieval times. The plague of 1348, 1350 killed a third of people in Europe and contributed to decline in some branches of science between Oresme and Copernicus.