Ytterbium

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Ytterbium takes its name from a village in Sweden called Ytterby, a place so rich in rare-earth elements that it lent its name to four separate entries on the periodic table: yttrium, terbium, erbium, and ytterbium itself. That small geographical footnote points to something larger. Ytterbium, element number 70, sits near the end of the lanthanide series and behaves in ways its neighbors do not. Its density, melting point, and boiling point are all significantly lower than the lanthanides flanking it. It switches between magnetic states depending on which physical form it takes. And a pair of atomic clocks built around it once set a record for stability so extreme that the clocks would remain accurate within a single second across a span comparable to the age of the universe. How did a soft, quietly tarnishing metal end up at the frontier of timekeeping, laser physics, and quantum computing? That question begins in 1878, with a Swiss chemist working through a sample of earth called erbia.

• 2. Discovery and Dispute

  ›

  Jean Charles Galissard de Marignac was examining samples of gadolinite in 1878 when he found something unexpected inside the rare earth known as erbia: a distinct new component he had not seen before. He named it ytterbia, after Ytterby, the Swedish village near where the original erbium source had been found. Marignac believed ytterbia was a compound of a genuinely new element, which he called ytterbium, though he could not fully separate and confirm it in his lifetime.

  Nearly three decades later, in 1907, the French chemist Georges Urbain returned to Marignac's ytterbia and split it into two distinct earths: neoytterbia and lutecia. Lutecia would eventually become lutetium. Working independently and at roughly the same time, the Austrian chemist Carl Auer von Welsbach reached the same separation but assigned different names: aldebaranium, after the star Aldebaran, and cassiopeium. The American chemist Charles James also isolated the pair independently.

  What followed was a priority dispute. Urbain and Welsbach accused each other of publishing conclusions drawn from the other's work. The Commission on Atomic Mass, made up of Frank Wigglesworth Clarke, Wilhelm Ostwald, and Georges Urbain, resolved the conflict in 1909 by ruling in Urbain's favor. His names were adopted as official, on the grounds that the separation of lutetium from Marignac's ytterbium had first been described in print by Urbain. After the ruling, neoytterbium reverted to the simpler name Marignac had originally proposed: ytterbium. Metallic ytterbium was first produced by Wilhelm Klemm and Heinrich Bommer in 1936, but its chemical and physical properties could not be determined with any precision until 1953, when the first nearly pure sample of the metal was made using ion-exchange processes.

• 3. An Unusual Physical Character

  ›

  Ytterbium is soft, malleable, and ductile. When freshly prepared, it is less golden in color than cesium. It tarnishes slowly in air, taking on a golden or brown hue. In powdered form, however, it self-ignites.

  The element exists in three distinct structural forms, called allotropes, labeled alpha, beta, and gamma. At room temperature the beta allotrope dominates, with a density of 6.966 grams per cubic centimeter and a face-centered cubic crystal structure. The alpha allotrope, stable at low temperatures, has a hexagonal crystal structure. The gamma allotrope, which appears at high temperatures, carries a body-centered cubic structure and a lower density of 6.57 grams per cubic centimeter. The transformation between allotropes occurs at -13 degrees Celsius and 795 degrees Celsius, though the precise transition point depends on pressure and mechanical stress.

  Pressure transforms the beta allotrope's behavior in striking ways. At ordinary atmospheric pressure it conducts electricity like a metal. At roughly 16,000 atmospheres it becomes a semiconductor. Compressing it further to 39,000 atmospheres increases its electrical resistivity tenfold. Push to about 40,000 atmospheres and the resistivity drops to roughly ten percent of what it was at room temperature. This pressure-sensitivity has a direct practical use: ytterbium metal is placed in stress gauges to monitor ground deformations caused by earthquakes and explosions.

  Magnetically, ytterbium breaks from its lanthanide neighbors. Most rare-earth metals become antiferromagnetic or ferromagnetic at low temperatures. Ytterbium, by contrast, is paramagnetic at temperatures above 1.0 kelvin. Its alpha allotrope, however, is diamagnetic. Its melting point is 824 degrees Celsius and its boiling point is 1196 degrees Celsius, giving ytterbium the smallest liquid range of any metal.

• 4. Chemistry of Two Oxidation States

  ›

  Ytterbium's standard oxidation state is +3, the same as the rest of the lanthanides. Its salts in that state are nearly colorless, and the ytterbium(III) ion absorbs light in the near-infrared range but not in the visible spectrum, which is why ytterbium oxide is white and its salts appear colorless in solution.

  What makes ytterbium unusual is its readiness to form divalent, or +2, compounds. Almost all lanthanides hold to +3 almost exclusively. Ytterbium slips into the +2 state because a fully filled f-shell, with all fourteen electrons present, confers extra stability. Samarium and thulium behave similarly, though the europium(II) ion is stable in water while the yellow-green ytterbium(II) ion is not. Ytterbium(II) is such a strong reducing agent that it decomposes water, releasing hydrogen gas, so only the +3 ion survives in aqueous solution. Ytterbium metal also dissolves in ammonia, forming blue electride salts, a behavior it shares with europium and the alkaline earth metals.

  Ytterbium's halide chemistry reflects this duality. It forms both dihalides and trihalides with fluorine, chlorine, bromine, and iodine. The dihalides are unstable at room temperature and disproportionate at high temperature into trihalides and metallic ytterbium. Some of these halides have practical uses in synthesis. Ytterbium(III) chloride acts as a Lewis acid catalyst in the Aldol and Diels-Alder reactions. Ytterbium(II) iodide serves as a reducing agent for coupling reactions, in the same role as samarium(II) iodide. Ytterbium(III) fluoride has a different application entirely: it is used as an inert, non-toxic tooth filling material because it continuously releases fluoride ions and also functions as an X-ray contrast agent.

• 5. Isotopes and Radiation

  ›

  Natural ytterbium is a blend of seven stable isotopes: 168Yb, 170Yb, 171Yb, 172Yb, 173Yb, 174Yb, and 176Yb. Of these, 174Yb is the most abundant, making up 31.90 percent of natural ytterbium. Thirty-two synthetic radioisotopes have been identified. The most stable of these is 169Yb, with a half-life of 32.014 days, followed by 175Yb at 4.185 days and 166Yb at 56.7 hours. Most of the remaining radioactive isotopes decay in under two hours, and the majority in under twenty minutes.

  The 169Yb isotope has a specific practical application as a radiation source. It is created, along with the shorter-lived 175Yb, by neutron activation when ytterbium is irradiated inside nuclear reactors. The gamma rays it emits pass through soft body tissue but are blocked by bone and dense materials, in the same manner as X-rays. Small samples of 169Yb therefore function as compact gamma-ray sources for portable radiography. Experiments have shown that radiographs taken with a 169Yb source are roughly equivalent to those taken with X-rays in the energy range of 250 to 350 keV. The isotope also finds use in nuclear medicine.

  For isotopes lighter than the most abundant stable form, 174Yb, the primary decay path is electron capture, which produces thulium isotopes. For those heavier than 174Yb, beta emission produces lutetium isotopes. Ytterbium also has 18 meta states; the most stable is 169mYb, with a half-life of 46 seconds.

• 6. Atomic Clocks and Quantum Uses

  ›

  In 2013, physicists at the National Institute of Standards and Technology reported that a pair of experimental atomic clocks based on ytterbium atoms had set a record for stability. The clocks' ticks were stable to within less than two parts in one quintillion, a number the researchers described as 1 followed by 18 zeros. That figure represented roughly ten times the stability of the previous best published results for any atomic clock. The accuracy was so high that the clocks would not gain or lose a second over a period comparable to the age of the universe.

  The mechanism behind that precision is specific. About 10,000 ytterbium atoms are laser-cooled to 10 microkelvin, ten millionths of a degree above absolute zero, and trapped inside an optical lattice: a series of pancake-shaped wells formed by laser light. A separate laser ticking at 518 trillion times per second, or 518 terahertz, drives a transition between two energy levels in the trapped atoms. The large number of atoms working together is what produces the clock's extraordinary stability. Visible light oscillates faster than microwaves, so optical clocks of this kind can outperform caesium-based atomic clocks. The Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt has pursued a separate approach using a single ytterbium ion held in an ion trap, producing an optical clock accurate to 17 digits after the decimal point.

  A different isotope, 171Yb+, the singly charged ion of ytterbium-171, is used by multiple academic groups and companies as a trapped-ion qubit for quantum computing. Entangling gates, including the Molmer-Sorensen gate, have been demonstrated by addressing the ions with mode-locked pulse lasers.

• 7. Lasers, Steel, and Pyrotechnics

  ›

  Ytterbium reaches roughly 50 tonnes of annual world production, a figure that reflects its limited but specialized commercial footprint. Its primary roles are as a dopant in stainless steel and as an active component in laser systems.

  As a steel dopant, ytterbium improves grain refinement, strength, and other mechanical properties. Some ytterbium alloys have also seen rare use in dentistry. As a laser dopant, the trivalent Yb3+ ion is incorporated into solid-state lasers and double-clad fiber lasers. Ytterbium lasers are efficient, have long operational lifetimes, and can generate short pulses. They typically radiate in the 1.03-1.12 micrometer band and are pumped optically at wavelengths of 900 nanometers to 1 micrometer, depending on the host material. One notable variant is the Yb:YAG laser, a solid-state device in which ytterbium undergoes stimulated emission; microscopic traces of ytterbium serve as the dopant.

  At high concentrations, ytterbium-doped materials run into problems: glass fibers show photodarkening, while crystals and ceramics shift to broadband emission rather than efficient laser action. Progress in fiber design has pushed power levels above 1.5 to 2 kilowatts at around 1064 nanometers using large mode area fibers, which reduce the nonlinear effects that limit higher power.

  Ytterbium is also under investigation as a possible replacement for magnesium in high-density pyrotechnic payloads for kinematic infrared decoy flares. Ytterbium(III) oxide has a significantly higher emissivity in the infrared range than magnesium oxide, offering greater radiant intensity compared to the standard magnesium-Teflon-Viton formulations currently in use.

• 8. Mining and Rarity

  ›

  Ytterbium appears in the Earth's crust at an average concentration of about 3 milligrams per kilogram. It is recovered commercially from monazite sand, which contains roughly 0.03 percent ytterbium by weight, and also from the minerals euxenite and xenotime. The main mining regions are China, the United States, Brazil, India, Sri Lanka, and Australia. Global reserves are estimated at one million tonnes.

  Even though ytterbium is among the least abundant rare-earth elements, its position as an even-numbered lanthanide gives it a relative advantage. The Oddo-Harkins rule predicts that even-numbered elements are more abundant than their odd-numbered neighbors, and ytterbium follows that pattern: it is significantly more common than its immediate neighbors thulium and lutetium, both of which appear at roughly 0.5 percent of the concentration found in the same mineral deposits.

  Separating ytterbium from other lanthanides is technically demanding because the elements share similar chemical properties. Ion-exchange and solvent extraction techniques developed in the mid- to late 20th century simplified the process, but it remains multi-step. In one production method, a buffered acidic solution of trivalent rare earths is treated with a molten sodium-mercury alloy, which selectively reduces and dissolves the ytterbium. The alloy is then treated with hydrochloric acid, the ytterbium is extracted as an oxalate and converted to the oxide by heating, and the oxide is finally reduced to metal by heating with lanthanum, aluminium, cerium, or zirconium under high vacuum. The metal is purified by sublimation. The price of ytterbium remained relatively stable at about 1,000 US dollars per kilogram from 1953 through 1998, a long plateau that itself reflects how consistently niche the element's applications remained through most of the 20th century.