Free to follow every thread. No paywall, no dead ends.
Property tax: the story on HearLore | HearLore
Property tax
The first ever tax records, dating from about six thousand years before the common era, were found in the city-state of Lagash, now located within the territory of modern Iraq. These ancient soil tablets reveal a system called bala, which operated on a rotating schedule where a specific area of the city was taxed each month to distribute the administrative burden. This early form of taxation did not rely on monetary value but rather on the physical area of the land and the crops it produced. In Ancient Egypt, the system evolved to include levies on grain, cattle, oil, beer, and land itself. Only one person out of every hundred was literate at that time, and these few tax assessors were highly respected figures who kept detailed records of landowners and calculated annual data by checking crop yields and cattle numbers. If a taxpayer failed to pay, they were brought before a court, establishing a legal framework for property obligations that would echo through millennia.
The Conqueror And The King
In the 11th century, the taxes on land in England were paid by peasants who rented that land from its owner, with the rent amount determined by the productivity of the soil. During the 1070s, William the Conqueror established an early form of land taxation that required cities to keep records of property owners and measure every parcel. After 1215, King John was limited in his power to raise revenue, meaning taxes could be collected only with the permission of his barons. By 1290, normal people began paying this type of tax based on the location of their property, with higher rates for those in cities and lower rates for rural residents. In the 16th century, even the King's own land was taxed, and his power of taxation became even weaker after 1689 when a new law was introduced preventing him from taxing without Parliament's permission. This historical struggle between the monarchy and the governed laid the groundwork for the modern concept that property ownership carries a permanent financial obligation to the state.
The Pilgrims And The Puritans
Arriving in the New World, the Pilgrims landed at Plymouth and started building their city in 1620, forming a pact to protect themselves and set laws including taxation and assessments. All people were allocated an equal proportion of land from which they had to pay tax, creating a system where the community shared the burden equally. In Boston, a property tax was implemented by Puritans to pay for the expenses of the church and religious education, and every person paid this property tax regardless of their religion. This particular system lasted for more than one hundred years, with the sheriff serving as the assessor of the tax. The system of evidence was similar to England, where assessors kept records of personal estate, but the situation of the citizen was taken into account as far as the property tax was concerned. A widow with children was not only forgiven property tax but also guaranteed to receive a certain amount of money monthly, while people who destroyed public property had to pay the cost of repairs with property tax.
When were the first property tax records found in Lagash?
The first property tax records were found in the city-state of Lagash, dating from about six thousand years before the common era. These ancient soil tablets reveal a system called bala which operated on a rotating schedule to distribute the administrative burden. This early form of taxation relied on the physical area of the land and the crops it produced rather than monetary value.
How did William the Conqueror change property tax in England during the 1070s?
William the Conqueror established an early form of land taxation in the 1070s that required cities to keep records of property owners and measure every parcel. This system required peasants who rented land to pay taxes based on the productivity of the soil. The records kept by assessors helped calculate annual data by checking crop yields and cattle numbers.
What is the current property tax situation in the United Kingdom compared to other OECD countries?
The ownership of residential property or freehold land in the United Kingdom is not taxed, a situation almost unique in the OECD. Instead, the Council Tax is usually paid by the resident of a property and only in the case of unoccupied property does the owner become liable to pay it. The Valuation Office Agency carries out valuation under the auspices of HMRC to allocate properties to Council Tax bands.
How is property tax collected in the United States by different levels of government?
Property tax on real estate in the United States is usually levied by the local government as the national government levies no real estate tax. State governments levy 3% of the total property tax collected while the other 97% is collected by counties, municipalities, schools, and other special-purpose governmental agencies. Rates vary across the states between about 0% and 4% of the home value.
What happened to a resident of Southfield, Michigan regarding property tax arrears?
A resident of Southfield, Michigan was evicted from her home for missing a 900 dollar property tax payment. The town refused to accept her late payment and instead confiscated and sold her nearly 300,000 dollar home. Critics note that instances like this are a fairly frequent occurrence and demonstrate a threat to property rights and the rule of law.
After the establishment of the United States in 1776, taxes were raised in most regions, mostly through property, but the central Government soon found out that this system did not work as far more was spent than received from this measure. At the end of the 18th century, a fierce dispute arose between Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson regarding the future of taxation. The camp of Hamilton was for raising taxes, mainly property tax, centrally in order to increase the capacity of the budget and the power of the Government. The camp of Jefferson was for raising revenue locally as it sounded more like a concept of democracy. Hamilton had a strong head for finance and helped to establish the capitalist system that exists today, but the financial strategy mentioned above, which relied on high property tax, was a disaster for him. Higher taxes, especially property taxes, were finally established during the concerns whether the war with France would happen or not, and a national property tax was enacted by Congress apportioned by population. There were many protests until the tax was finally repealed, but the trend of raising the local property tax continued as local governments were able to raise their revenue by this measure.
The Great Depression And The Shift
At the beginning of the 20th century, it was found out that the tax system in the United States could not equitably tax the complicated economy, and many reforms were implemented trying to reduce reliance on property taxes. The most important one concerned a new narrow personal property tax established especially for homeowners and intangible assets. Many US presidents have tried to push for lower property tax and for the implementation of income tax. By the time of the Great Depression, the property tax collection rates dropped as people's income decreased steeply. The Governments mostly cut property tax and implemented sales taxes to cope with the economic crisis. After the Great Depression, many movements were formed for addressing claims on the Government with real tax reforms. Many of these reforms were approved and remain the current law, shifting the focus from a purely property-based system to a more diversified approach that included income and sales taxes to ensure stability during economic downturns.
The Unique British Exception
In the United Kingdom, the ownership of residential property or freehold land is not taxed, a situation almost unique in the OECD. Instead, the Council Tax is usually paid by the resident of a property, and only in the case of unoccupied property does the owner become liable to pay it, although owners can often obtain a discount or an exemption for empty properties. HM Revenue and Customs guidelines state that Council Tax is a tax on property, but in principle, it may be an allowable deduction in those instances where other property-based expenses are deductible. The Valuation Tribunal Service states that the tax is a mix of a property tax and a personal tax. Generally, where two or more persons reside in a dwelling, the full tax is payable, but if one person resides in the dwelling, then 75% is payable. An empty dwelling attracts only a 50% charge unless the billing authority has made a determination otherwise. The Council Tax depends on the value of the property, but is not calculated as a simple percentage. Instead, the property is allocated to a Council Tax band, with 9 bands in England and 8 in Scotland and Wales, and valuation is carried out by the Valuation Office Agency under the auspices of HMRC.
The American Local Dominance
In the United States, property tax on real estate is usually levied by the local government, as the national government levies no real estate tax, nor property tax. State governments levy 3% of the total property tax collected, while the other 97% is collected by counties, municipalities, schools, community colleges, and many other special-purpose governmental agencies such as libraries, museums, parks, and bridge authorities. Rates vary across the states, between about 0% and 4% of the home value. The assessment comprises two components: the improvement or building value and the land or site value. The property tax is the main tax supporting local education, police, fire protection, government, roads, and most infrastructure such as sewers, bridges, and street lights. Many state and local jurisdictions add personal property taxes, creating a complex web of obligations that fund the daily operations of communities. In Alaska, only a small portion of the land mass is subject to a property tax, with only 24 municipalities in Alaska either cities or boroughs levying a property tax, yet the vast majority of revenue for local governments comes from property taxes.
The Eviction And The Critique
Critics of property taxes note that this type of tax demonstrates that so-called property owners are renters of their land and that the government is regarded as the final owner since the property owners can be evicted at any time for failure to pay this tax. For example, a resident of Southfield, Michigan, was evicted from her home for missing a 900 dollar property tax payment. The town refused to accept her late payment and instead confiscated and sold her nearly 300,000 dollar home. Critics note that instances like this are a fairly frequent occurrence and demonstrate a threat to property rights, due process, and the rule of law. In places without property tax, such as China where the government owns all lands and does not tax homeowners, or in American Samoa and the Territory of Palmyra Island, the dynamic is entirely different. The debate continues over whether the property tax is a necessary tool for funding public services or an unjust burden that threatens the security of homeownership, with some jurisdictions like France successfully reducing vacancy rates through taxes on vacant properties while others struggle with the social consequences of tax arrears.