Ganesha
Ganesha holds a title found in almost no other deity's portfolio: Pratham Pujya, the god to be worshipped before any other god. Across every Hindu denomination, before a wedding begins, before a business opens, before a dancer takes a single step, Ganesha is invoked first. He is the son of Parvati and Shiva, the brother of Kartikeya, the god of war, and he carries an elephant's head on a human body with a large, protruding belly. He is worshipped not only by Hindus but also by Jains and Buddhists, and his image has traveled as far as China, Japan, and Thailand. Yet scholars cannot say with certainty where he came from or even when he first appeared. The historian Narain put it plainly: there is no convincing evidence of this divinity prior to the fifth century. How a deity with no clear Vedic past became perhaps the most recognized figure in the Hindu world is the question this documentary sets out to answer.
The word Ganesha is a Sanskrit compound: gana, meaning a group, multitude, or categorical system, and isha, meaning lord or master. When paired with his name, gana is often understood to refer to the ganas, the semi-divine troop that forms the retinue of Shiva. The title therefore carries the sense of Lord of Hosts or Lord of created categories.
The Amarakosha, an early Sanskrit lexicon, lists eight synonyms for Ganesha, each illuminating a different facet of his character. Ekadanta means one who has one tusk. Lambodara means one who has a hanging belly. Gajanana means one having the face of an elephant. The name Vinayaka, common in both Hindu texts and Buddhist Tantras, is reflected in the Ashtavinayak, the eight famous Ganesha temples of Maharashtra.
In the Tamil language, scholar A. K. Narain distinguishes between pillai, meaning a child, and pillaiyar, meaning a noble child. Narain also notes that the words pallu, pella, and pell in Dravidian languages signify tooth or tusk. Anita Raina Thapan adds that the root word pille in Pillaiyar may originally have meant the young of the elephant, since the Pali word pillaka means a young elephant.
Those layers of meaning extend across other languages. In Thailand, Ganesha is widely known as Khanet, with the more formal title of Phra Phi Khanet. In Burma he is Maha Peinne, derived from the Pali Mahavinayaka. These names carry the weight of centuries of cultural exchange, and they point toward the remarkable journey a local Indian deity made across much of Asia.
Ganesha has been represented with an elephant's head since the early stages of his appearance in Indian art, but the Puranic myths offer competing explanations for how he came to wear it. The most recurrent story holds that Parvati created Ganesha from clay to serve as her protector. When Shiva returned and Ganesha blocked his path, Shiva beheaded him. Shiva then replaced the original head with that of an elephant. A different story says Shiva created Ganesha directly through laughter, and then gave him the elephant head and a protruding belly because he considered the form too alluring in its original shape.
Ganesha's earliest name was Ekadanta, meaning One Tusked, referring to his single whole tusk. Some of the earliest images show him holding the broken tusk. The Mudgala Purana, one of the principal texts on Ganesha, names his second incarnation Ekadanta, emphasizing how central this feature was to his identity.
His protruding belly appears as a distinctive attribute in the earliest statuary, dating to the Gupta period between the 4th and 6th centuries. The Mudgala Purana names two different incarnations after the belly alone: Lambodara, meaning Pot Belly, and Mahodara, meaning Great Belly. The Brahmanda Purana offers a cosmic reading of this feature, saying Ganesha bears the name Lambodara because all the universes of the past, present, and future are present within him.
The number of his arms has varied across traditions. His earliest images had two. Many standard depictions have four, with one upper hand holding an axe or goad and another holding a noose. Forms with fourteen and twenty arms appeared in central India during the 9th and 10th centuries. Serpents appear throughout his iconography, used as a sacred thread, a belt, a throne, coiled at the ankles, or in the case of the Ganesha Purana, wrapped around his neck as Vasuki.
Paul Courtright writes that Ganesha's dharma and his raison d'etre is to create and remove obstacles. That double function distinguishes him from simpler protective deities. He is popularly known as a remover of obstacles, but he traditionally places obstacles in the path of those who need to be checked. The scholar Dhavalikar traces his rapid rise in the Hindu pantheon specifically to the shift in emphasis from obstacle-creator to obstacle-averter.
The mouse is the vehicle most associated with Ganesha, known by the names meaning mouse-mount and rat-banner in the Ganesha Sahasranama. Martin-Dubost observes that the rat began appearing as Ganesha's principal vehicle in sculptures of central and western India during the 7th century, always placed close to his feet. The mouse first appears in written sources in the Matsya Purana and later in the Brahmananda Purana and Ganesha Purana.
Interpretations of the mouse divide scholars. John Grimes notes that many interpreters read the mouse negatively, as a symbol of desire. Michael Wilcockson says it represents those who wish to overcome selfish desire. Krishan notes that the rat is destructive and a menace to crops, and that the Sanskrit word for mouse derives from a root meaning stealing or robbing. On this reading, Ganesha subduing the rat demonstrates his mastery over a vighna, an impediment, which supports a theory that he originated as a folk village deity who later rose to wider prominence. Martin-Dubost also records the view that the rat, which penetrates even the most secret places, mirrors Ganesha's own pervasive reach.
Ganesha is also identified with the Hindu mantra Om. The Ganapati Atharvashirsa attests to this connection, and Chinmayananda's translation of that text has Ganesha addressed as all the Trimurti, all the elements, all three worlds, and Om itself. According to Kundalini yoga, Ganesha resides in the first chakra, Muladhara, a word combining mula, meaning original or main, and adhara, meaning base or foundation. Courtright's translation of the Ganapati Atharvashirsa has Ganesha described as dwelling continually in the sacral plexus at the base of the spine.
Ganesha is mentioned in Hindu texts dated between the 1st century BCE and the 2nd century CE, but a few documented images from the 4th and 5th centuries CE represent his first clear appearance as a recognizable deity. The earliest terracotta images, small figures with an elephant head and two arms, were found at Ter, Pal, Verrapuram, and Chandraketugarh, and are from the 1st century CE. The earliest stone icons were carved in Mathura during Kushan times, in the 2nd to 3rd centuries CE.
His classic form with well-defined iconographic attributes emerged in the early 4th to 5th centuries. Among the earliest known Ganesha images are two found in eastern Afghanistan. One was discovered in ruins north of Kabul alongside images of Surya and Shiva, dated to the 4th century. A second, found in Gardez and known as the Gardez Ganesha, carries an inscription on its pedestal that has helped date it to the 5th century. A Ganesha sculpture is also embedded in the walls of Cave 6 of the Udayagiri Caves in Madhya Pradesh, also dated to the 5th century. A Bhumara Temple image from Madhya Pradesh, showing Ganesha with an elephant head, a bowl of sweets, and a goddess in his lap, is similarly dated to the 5th-century Gupta period.
Narain's assessment of this sudden emergence is candid: the appearance of Ganesha on the historical scene is inscrutable, his antecedents are not clear, and there is no convincing evidence in ancient Brahmanic literature of this divinity prior to the fifth century. Narain suggests the evidence for an older Ganesha may reside outside Brahmanic or Sanskritic traditions, or beyond the geocultural boundaries of India altogether.
One theory traces Ganesha's origin to the four Vinyakas, troublesome demons from the Yajurveda who created obstacles and were easily propitiated. Krishan accepts this lineage directly, stating that Ganesha is a non-Vedic god whose origin traces to the four evil spirits of the Manavagrhyasutra, a text dated to the 7th through 4th centuries BCE. By the 9th century, whatever his origins, Ganesha was formally included among the five primary deities of Smartism, when Adi Shankara popularised the Panchayatana puja, a worship system invoking Ganesha, Vishnu, Shiva, Devi, and Surya together on equal footing.
An annual festival honours Ganesha for ten days, beginning on Ganesh Chaturthi, which typically falls in late August or early September. Clay idols of Ganesha are brought into homes and public spaces at the start, symbolising his arrival. On the day of Ananta Chaturdashi the idols are immersed in the nearest body of water. Some families follow a tradition of immersion on the 2nd, 3rd, 5th, or 7th day.
In 1893, Lokmanya Tilak transformed this private family observance into a grand public event. His stated reason was to bridge the gap between Brahmins and non-Brahmins and to build a new grassroots unity in his nationalistic effort against the British in Maharashtra. Because of Ganesha's wide appeal as what Tilak called the god for Everyman, Tilak chose him as a rallying point for Indian protest. Tilak was the first to install large public Ganesha images in pavilions and to establish the practice of submerging all public images on the tenth day. Today the festival is most popular in Maharashtra and assumes a particularly large scale in Mumbai, Pune, and the belt of the Ashtavinayak temples.
The Ashtavinayak, eight shrines dedicated to particular forms of Ganapati, are all located within a 100-kilometer radius of Pune. The eight are Morgaon, Siddhatek, Pali, Mahad, Theur, Lenyadri, Ozar, and Ranjangaon, each with its own attendant lore. T. A. Gopinatha observes that every village, however small, has its own image of Vigneshvara, with or without a temple to house it, found at entrances, below sacred fig trees, in niches, and in temples of both Vishnu and Shiva. Ganesha temples have also been built outside India, including four Vinayaka shrines in the Kathmandu Valley of Nepal.
Traders and merchants who traveled out of India carried Ganesha with them. From approximately the 10th century onward, new commercial networks formed, including trade guilds and renewed money circulation. The earliest inscription invoking Ganesha before any other deity is associated with the merchant community, linking his role as obstacle-remover directly to commercial enterprise.
Hindus who migrated to Maritime Southeast Asia brought the worship of Ganesha into Burma, Cambodia, Thailand, the Philippines, Java, Bali, and Borneo, each showing distinct regional influences. The earliest images and mentions of Ganesha as a major deity in present-day Indonesia, Thailand, Cambodia, and Vietnam date to the 7th and 8th centuries, mirroring Indian examples from the 5th century or earlier. In Indochina, where Hinduism and Buddhism were practised alongside each other, this produced visible cross-influences in Ganesha's iconography.
In Thailand, the belief that Ganesha is the god of arts and academics was formally promoted by King Vajiravudh of the Chakri dynasty, who built a Ganesha shrine at his personal palace, Sanam Chandra Palace in Nakhon Pathom Province. His personal devotion shaped policy: Ganesha is depicted in the seal of Thailand's Fine Arts Department and in the founding imagery of Silpakorn University, the country's first prominent fine arts academy.
Indonesia is the only country to have featured Ganesha on its banknotes, the 20-thousand denomination issued between 1998 and 2008. In that country, where Islam predominates, Ganesha is not worshipped but is understood as a symbol of knowledge, wisdom, and education. Three local governments, including Blitar, Salatiga City, and Kediri Regency, include Ganesha in their official seals. The earliest known stone statue of Ganesha in northern China carries an inscription dated to 531. In Japan, where he is known as Kangiten, the Ganesha cult was first mentioned in 806.
Continue browsing
Updated
Common questions
Who is Ganesha in Hinduism?
Ganesha is one of the most widely worshipped deities in the Hindu pantheon and holds the title of Pratham Pujya, the god to be worshipped before any other deity. He is the son of Parvati and Shiva and is recognized by his elephant head, four arms, and protruding belly. He serves as the remover of obstacles, patron of arts and sciences, and deva of logic, intellect, and wisdom.
Why does Ganesha have an elephant head?
Hindu Puranic myths offer several explanations. The most common holds that Parvati created Ganesha from clay, Shiva beheaded him in a confrontation, and then replaced his original head with that of an elephant. Another story says Shiva created Ganesha through laughter and gave him the elephant head and protruding belly because he found the original form too alluring.
When did Ganesha first appear in Indian history?
The earliest terracotta images of Ganesha date to the 1st century CE and were found at Ter, Pal, Verrapuram, and Chandraketugarh. His classic form with well-defined iconographic attributes appeared in the early 4th to 5th centuries CE. The historian Narain concluded there is no convincing evidence of Ganesha in ancient Brahmanic literature prior to the fifth century.
What is the significance of Ganesha's mouse vehicle?
The mouse, or rat, began appearing as Ganesha's principal vehicle in sculpture of central and western India during the 7th century. Interpretations vary: some scholars read the mouse as a symbol of desire, while others see Ganesha's mastery over the rat, a destructive pest, as evidence of his role as Lord of Obstacles. Martin-Dubost also records the view that the rat, which penetrates secret places, symbolizes Ganesha's pervasive reach.
Who transformed Ganesh Chaturthi into a public festival?
In 1893, Lokmanya Tilak transformed the annual Ganesha festival from private family celebrations into a grand public event in Maharashtra. He did so to bridge the gap between Brahmins and non-Brahmins and to build unity against British rule. Tilak was the first to install large public images of Ganesha in pavilions and established the practice of immersing all public images on the tenth day.
How is Ganesha worshipped outside India and Hinduism?
Ganesha is worshipped or venerated across Southeast Asia, China, Japan, Nepal, and beyond. In Thailand, the cult was formally promoted by King Vajiravudh of the Chakri dynasty, and Ganesha appears in the seal of the Fine Arts Department and at Silpakorn University. Indonesia is the only country to have featured Ganesha on its banknotes, the 20-thousand denomination issued between 1998 and 2008. In Japan he is known as Kangiten, with the cult first mentioned in 806.
All sources
165 references cited across the entry
- 1"Ganesha getting ready to throw his lotus. Basohli miniature, circa 1730. National Museum, New Delhi. In the (VII, 70), in order to kill the demon of egotism () who had attacked him, throws his lotus
- 3is often said to be the most worshipped god in India." ", Lord of the , although among the latest deities to be admitted to the Brahmanic pantheon, was, and still is, the most universally adored of al
- 4Chapter XVII, "The Travels Abroad", in: . For a review of Ganesha's geographic spread and popularity outside of India. , For discussion of the spread of Ganesha worship to Nepal, Chinese Turkestan, Ti
- 5Martin-Dubost, p. 2.
- 6Saraswati (2004) p. 80Saraswati — 2004
- 7BookIndia - Mahabharata. Fulbright-Hays Summer Seminar Abroad 1994 (India)Carole DeVito et al. — United States Educational Foundation in India — 1994
- 8Vigna means "obstacles", while Nasha means "destroy". These ideas are so common that Courtright uses them in the title of his book, Ganesha: Lord of Obstacles, Lord of Beginnings.
- 9Brown (1991) p. 27Brown — 1991
- 10BookAn Introduction to HinduismGavin D. — Cambridge University Press — 1996
- 11BookHinduismVasudha — The Rosen Publishing Group — 2009
- 12BookThe Religions of IndiaMira Publishing House — 1950
- 14Narain, A. K. ": A Protohistory of the Idea and the Icon". . .
- 15For the derivation of the name and relationship with the , see:
- 16Śāstri Khiste (1991) p. 7–8Śāstri Khiste — 1991
- 18Oka (1913) p. 8Oka — 1913
- 19Y. Krishan, : Unravelling an Enigma, 1999, p. 6): "Pārvati who created an image of out of her bodily impurities but which became endowed with life after immersion in the sacred waters of the Gangā. Th
- 20For the history of the sites and a description of pilgrimage practices related to them, see:
- 21Courtright (1985) p. 156, 213Courtright — 1985
- 22For Krishan's views on Ganesha's dual nature see his quote: " has a dual nature; as Vināyaka, as a , he is , and as he is , a ." ()
- 23Narain, A. K. ": The Idea and the Icon".
- 24Myanmar-English DictionaryDunwoody Press — 1993
- 25BookThe Lovelorn Ghost and the Magical Monk: Practicing Buddhism in Modern ThailandJustin Thomas McDaniel — Columbia University Press — 2013
- 26A Note on the Recently Discovered Gaṇeśa Image from Palembang, SumatraRobert L. Brown — 1987
- 27BookBuddha in the Crown : Avalokitesvara in the Buddhist Traditions of Sri Lanka: Avalokitesvara in the Buddhist Traditions of Sri LankaJohn Clifford Holt — Oxford University Press — 1991
- 28Krishan (1999) p. 87–100Krishan — 1999
- 29, p. 213. In the upper right corner, the statue is dated as (973–1200).
- 30Pal, p. vi. The picture on this page depicts a stone statue in the Los Angeles County Museum of Art that is dated as c. 12th century. Pal shows an example of this form dated c. 13th century on p. viii
- 31See photograph 2, "Large Ganesh", in:
- 33NewsVinayaka in unique form10 October 2003
- 34Catlin, Amy; "Vātāpi Gaṇapatim": Sculptural, Poetic, and Musical Texts in the Hymn to Gaṇeśa" in
- 35In: photograph 9, "Ganesh images being taken for immersion", in: . For an example of a large image of this type being carried in a festival procession. , For two similar statues about to be immersed.
- 36In: . For many examples of Ganesha dancing. For the popularity of the dancing form.
- 37Four-armed . Miniature of Nurpur school, circa 1810. Museum of Chandigarh. For this image see: Martin-Dubost (1997), p. 64, which describes it as follows: "On a terrace leaning against a thick white b
- 38For creation of Ganesha from Shiva's laughter and subsequent curse by Shiva, see Varaha Purana 23.17 as cited in .
- 39Granoff, Phyllis. " as Metaphor".
- 40"Ganesha in Indian Plastic Art" and Passim.
- 41For translation of Udara as "belly" see:
- 42Br. P. 2.3.42.34 , For a description of how a variant of this story is used in the Mudgala Purana 2.56.38–9
- 43For an iconographic chart showing number of arms and attributes classified by source and named form, see: Appendix I.
- 44Krishan (1999) p. 89Krishan — 1999
- 45Krishan (1999) p. 50–53Krishan — 1999
- 46Krishan (1999) p. 51–52Krishan — 1999
- 47. For the text of a stone inscription dated 1470 identifying Ganesha's sacred thread as the serpent . . For the snake as a common type of for Ganesha.
- 48. tilaka with three horizontal lines. the in: Sharma (1993 edition of Ganesha Purana) I.46.1. For Ganesa visualized as (having three eyes).
- 49. For a citation to Ganesha Purana I.14.21–25 and For a citation to Padma Purana as prescribing the crescent for decoration of the forehead of Ganesha . For the translation of Ganesha Purana I.14, whi
- 50For Bhālacandra as a distinct form worshipped. Sharma (1993 edition of Ganesha Purana) I.46.15. For the name Bhālacandra appearing in the Ganesha Sahasranama
- 51BookSri Ganesha PuranaAkilā Civarāman̲ — Giri Trading Agency — 2014
- 52BookGaṇeśa, the Enchanter of the Three WorldsPaul Martin-Dubost — Franco-Indian Research — 1997
- 53. For the Ganesha Purana story of with the peacock mount (GP I.84.2–3) Maruti Nandan Tiwari and Kamal Giri, "Images of In Jainism", in: .
- 54. Preface. .
- 55See note on figure 43 in: .
- 56Citations to Matsya Purana 260.54, Brahmananda Purana Lalitamahatmya XXVII, and Ganesha Purana 2.134–136 are provided by: .
- 57For see v. 6. For Ākhuketana see v. 67. In: . (, 1991). Source text with a commentary by in Sanskrit.
- 58For a review of different interpretations, and quotation, see: .
- 59A Student's Guide to AS Religious Studies for the OCR Specification, by Michael Wilcockson, p. 117
- 60Rocher, Ludo. "'s Rise to Prominence in Sanskrit Literature", in: . For mention of the interpretation that "the rat is 'the animal that finds its way to every place,'"
- 61"Lord of Removal of Obstacles", a common name, appears in the title of Courtright's : Lord of Obstacles, Lord of Beginnings. For equivalent Sanskrit names Vighneśvara and Vighnarāja, see:
- 62Ganesha: The Remover of Obstacles31 May 2016
- 63Brown (1991) p. 49Brown — 1991
- 64Ganesha Purana I.46, v. 5 of the Ganesha Sahasranama section in GP-1993, Sharma edition. It appears in verse 10 of the version as given in the Bhaskararaya commentary.
- 65Sharma edition, GP-1993 I.46, verses 204–206. The Bailey edition uses a variant text, and where Sharma reads Buddhipriya, Bailey translates Granter-of-lakhs.
- 66Practical Sanskrit Dictionary By Arthur Anthony McDonell; p. 187 (priya); Published 2004; Motilal Banarsidass Publ;
- 67p. discusses Ganesha as "Buddhi's Husband".
- 68Grimes, p. 77.
- 69For examples of both, see:
- 70Tantra Unveiled: Seducing the Forces of Matter & Spirit By Rajmani Tigunait; Contributor Deborah Willoughby; Published 1999; Himalayan Institute Press; p. 83;
- 71This work is reproduced and described in Martin-Dubost (1997), p. 51, which describes it as follows: "This square shaped miniature shows us in a Himalayan landscape the god sweetly pouring water from
- 72In: . For a summary of Puranic variants of birth stories. . Chapter 2, "Stories of Birth According to the ".
- 73Shiva Purana IV. 17.47–57. Matsya Purana 154.547.
- 74Linga Purana
- 75Purana 23.18–59.
- 76For summary of Brahmavaivarta Purana, Ganesha Khanda, 10.8–37, see: .
- 77BookReligious Celebrations: An Encyclopedia of Holidays, Festivals, Solemn Observances, and Spiritual CommemorationsJ. Gordon Melton — ABC-CLIO — 13 September 2011
- 78For a summary of variant names for Skanda, see: .
- 79For a review, see: Cohen, Lawrence. "The Wives of ".
- 80Getty (1936) p. 33Getty — 1936
- 81Brown (1991) p. 126–129Brown — 1991
- 82Krishan (1999) p. 62Krishan — 1999
- 83Brown (1991) p. 115Brown — 1991
- 84Brown (1991) p. 131–132Brown — 1991
- 85Brown (1991) p. 132–135Brown — 1991
- 86Brown (1991) p. 124–125Brown — 1991
- 87Brown (1991) p. 130Brown — 1991
- 88In: Cohen, Lawrence. "The Wives of ". . , p. 15–16, 230, 239, 242, 251.
- 89K.N. Somayaji, Concept of Ganesha, p. 1 as quoted in
- 90Krishan, 1981–1982 p. 285Krishan, 1981–1982
- 91The term modaka applies to all regional varieties of cakes or sweets offered to Ganesha. .
- 92For the fourth waxing day in being dedicated to Ganesha () see: ., "Festivals and Sacred Days", in: Bhattacharyya, volume IV, p. 483.
- 93The Experience of Hinduism: Essays on Religion in Maharashtra; Edited By Eleanor Zelliot, Maxine Berntsen, pp. 76–94 ("The Ganesh Festival in Maharashtra: Some Observations" by Paul B. Courtright); 19
- 94In: . For Tilak's role in converting the private family festivals to a public event in support of Indian nationalism.
- 95In: Momin, A.R., The Legacy of G.S. Ghurye: A Centennial Festschrift, p. 95. , p. 9. For Ganesha's appeal as "the god for Everyman" as a motivation for Tilak.
- 96For Tilak as the first to use large public images in (pavilions or tents) see: , p. 225.
- 97For Ganesh Chaturthi as the most popular festival in Maharashtra, see: , p. 226.
- 98" in a Regional Setting". , p. 202–247.
- 99NewsMajor Ganesha Temples around the world31 August 2022
- 100T.A. Gopinatha; Elements of Hindu Iconography, p. 47–48 as quoted in
- 102Brown (1991) p. 50, 63Brown — 1991
- 103A Note on Two Gaṇeśa Statues from AfghanistanM. K. Dhavalikar — 1971
- 104JournalOn the so-called earliest representation of GanesaOsmund Bopearachchi — 1993
- 105JournalA Unique Early Historic Terracotta Ganesa Image from Pal, District Aurangabad, MaharashtraAjit Kumar — 2007
- 106BookThe Living Elephants: Evolutionary Ecology, Behaviour, and ConservationRaman Sukumar — Oxford University Press — 2003
- 107In: Passim. . Rocher, Ludo. "Gaṇeśa's Rise to Prominence in Sanskrit Literature". , p. 70–72.
- 108Aitareya Brāhmana, I, 21.
- 109Bhandarkar. Vaisnavism, Saivism and other Minor Sects. p. 147–148.
- 110, p. vii.
- 111Krishan, 1981–1982 p. 287–290Krishan, 1981–1982
- 112Wilson, H. H. . Sanskrit text, English translation, notes, and index of verses. Parimal Sanskrit Series No. 45. Volume II: 2, 3, 4, 5. Second Revised Edition; Edited and Revised by Ravi Prakash Arya a
- 113Rocher, Ludo. "'s Rise to Prominence in Sanskrit Literature". , p. 69. is a variant name for Brahamanaspati.
- 114Rocher, Ludo. "'s Rise to Prominence in Sanskrit Literature". , p. 69–70.
- 115Wilson, H.H. . Sanskrit text, English translation, notes, and index of verses. Parimal Sanskrit Series No. 45. Volume IV: 9, 10. Second Revised Edition; Edited and Revised by Ravi Prakash Arya and K.L
- 116Brown (1991) p. 70Brown — 1991
- 117BookTamil Wisdom; Traditions Concerning Hindu Sages, and Selections from their writingsEdward Jewitt Robinson — Wesleyan Conference Office — 1873
- 118The verse : " | | ||"
- 119The verse: " | ||"
- 120JournalSugarcane GaṇapatiR.K.K. Rajarajan — 2001
- 121Taittiriya Aranyaka, X, 1, 5.
- 122Krishan, 1981–1982 p. 290Krishan, 1981–1982
- 123Brown (1991) p. 56–57Brown — 1991
- 124Rocher, Ludo "Ganesa's Rise to Prominence in Sanskrit Literature". Brown, pp. 71–72.
- 125Vol. 1 Part 2. Critical edition, p. 884.
- 126Krishan (1999) p. 31, note 4Krishan — 1999
- 127Brown, p. 4.
- 128Winternitz, Moriz. " in the ". Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland (1898:382). Citation provided by Rocher, Ludo. "'s Rise to Prominence in Sanskrit Literature". , p. 80.
- 129Krishan (1999) p. 29Krishan — 1999
- 130Rocher, Ludo. "'s Rise to Prominence in Sanskrit Literature". , p. 73.
- 131For Dating of the and its connection with Brahmins. Bhattacharyya, S., "Indian Hymnology", in: . Volume VI. For the "five" divinities () becoming "the major deities" in general, and their listing as S
- 132, pp. 196–197. Addresses the in the tradition and the relationship of the Ganesha Purana and the Mudgala Purana to it.
- 133For a review of major differences of opinions between scholars on dating, see: .
- 134Preston, Lawrence W., "Subregional Religious Centers in the History of Maharashtra: The Sites Sacred to ", in: N.K. Wagle, ed., Images of Maharashtra: A Regional Profile of India. p. 103.
- 135R.C. Hazra, "The ", Journal of the Ganganatha Jha Research Institute (1951); 79–99.
- 136Phyllis Granoff, " as Metaphor", in , note 2.
- 137Wayman, Alex (2006). Chanting the Names of Manjushri. Motilal Banarsidass Publishers: p. 76.
- 138Wilkinson, Christopher. "The Tantric Ganesa: Text Preserved in the Tibetan Canon." in Brown, Robert L. (editor) (1991) Studies of an Asian God, pp. 235-274. State University of New Ytrrk Pre'ss,Albany
- 139BookMyanmar-English DictionaryDepartment of the Myanmar Language Commission — 1993
- 141Journal"Counting to 37: Sir Richard Carnac Temple and the Thirty-Eighth Nat"Sally Bamford — 2019-01-01
- 142Journalพระคเณศไม่ใช่เทพศิลปะ รัชกาลที่ 6 ทรงทำให้เป็นเทพศิลปะกิตติ วัฒนะมหาตม์ — November 2011
- 143BookGanesh, the BenevolentPratapaditya Pal — Marg Publications — 1995
- 144BookThe Practical Sanskrit DictionaryVaman Shivram Apte — Motilal Banarsidass Publishers — 1965
- 145BookGaneśapurāna: Introduction, translation, notes and indexGreg Bailey — Harrassowitz — 1995
- 146BookThe Cultural Heritage of IndiaThe Ramakrishna Mission Institute of Culture — 1956
- 147Ganesh: Studies of an Asian GodRobert Brown — State University of New York — 1991
- 148Glory of GaneshaSwami Chinmayananda — Central Chinmaya Mission Trust — 1987
- 149: Lord of Obstacles, Lord of BeginningsPaul B. Courtright — Oxford University Press — 1985
- 150Social History of Early CeylonH Ellawala — Department of Cultural Affairs — 1969
- 151BookGaṇeśa: A Monograph on the Elephant-Faced GodAlice Getty — Clarendon Press — 1936
- 152Ganapati: Song of the SelfJohn A. Grimes — State University of New York Press — 1995
- 153The Problem of GanapatiH. Heras — Indological Book House — 1972
- 154Ganesha-KarttikeyaAshish Khokar et al. — Rupa and Co — 2005
- 155Artibus AsiaeYuvraj Krishan — Artibus Asiae Publishers — 1981–1982
- 156Gaṇeśa: Unravelling An EnigmaYuvraj Krishan — Motilal Banarsidass Publishers — 1999
- 157Mythical Animals in Indian ArtK. Krishna Murthy — Abhinav Publications — 1985
- 159Temples and Legends of MaharashtraM.S. Mate — Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan — 1962
- 160A Concise History of IndiaThomas R. Metcalf et al.
- 161BookThe Cult of VinayakaShanti Lal Nagar — Intellectual Publishing House — 1992
- 162The Nāmalingānuśāsana (Amarakosha) of Amarasimha: with the Commentary () of KshīrasvāminKrishnaji Govind Oka — Law Printing Press — 1913
- 163The Compendium on GaṇeśaS.K. Ramachandra Rao — Sri Satguru Publications — 1992
- 164Swami Tattvavidananda SaraswatiD.K. Printworld Ltd. — 2004
- 165Śāstri KhistePrācya Prakāśana — 1991
- 166with Hindi commentaryHargovinda Śāstri — Chowkhambā Sanskrit Series Office — 1978
- 167BookUnderstanding Gaṇapati: Insights into the Dynamics of a CultAnita Raina Thapan — Manohar Publishers — 1997