— Ch. 1 · Foundations And History —
Ecological economics.
~5 min read · Ch. 1 of 5
The first organized meetings of ecological economists occurred in 1982 at a gathering held in Sweden. Lois Banner instigated this event, bringing together Robert Costanza, Herman Daly, Charles Hall, Bruce Hannon, H.T. Odum, and David Pimentel. Most attendees were ecosystem ecologists or mainstream environmental economists with the exception of Herman Daly. This meeting marked the beginning of a formal discipline that would distinguish itself from traditional resource economics. The field traces its intellectual roots back to the Romantics of the nineteenth century and Enlightenment political economists like Thomas Malthus. Malthus expressed concerns over population growth while John Stuart Mill predicted the desirability of a stationary state economy. Karl Marxian economist Sergei Podolinsky attempted to theorize a labor theory of value based on embodied energy in 1880. His work was read and critiqued by both Marx and Engels. Otto Neurath developed an ecological approach based on natural economy while employed by the Bavarian Soviet Republic in 1919. He argued that market systems failed to account for future generations needs. A socialist economy required calculation in kind rather than synthesizing materials into money as a general equivalent. Neo-liberal economists such as Ludwig von Mises and Friedrich Hayek criticized his ideas during what became known as the socialist calculation debate.
Core Schools Of Thought
Various competing schools of thought exist within the field ranging from mainstream resource economists to radical social-ecological degrowth movements. Clive Spash has argued for classifying the movement into three main categories: new resource economists, new environmental pragmatists, and more radical social ecological economists. International survey work comparing these categories shows clear divisions between environmental and ecological economists. A growing field of radical social-ecological theory is degrowth economics which addresses biophysical limits and global inequality. Degrowth prioritizes grassroots initiatives in progressive socio-ecological goals while adhering to ecological limits by shrinking the human ecological footprint. It involves an equitable downscale in production and consumption of resources to respect physical boundaries. Some degrowth theorists call for an exit of the economy entirely. Critics include new resource economists who point to gaining momentum of sustainable development. These critics highlight positive aspects of green economies including equitable access to renewable energy. Examples of heterodox experiments include the Catalan Integral Cooperative and Solidarity Economy Networks in Italy. Both use communitarian based economies and consciously reduce their ecological footprint through regenerative agriculture. E.F. Schumacher introduced non-western economic ideas in his book Small Is Beautiful where he addressed neoliberal economics through Buddhist natural harmony.