Confederate Heartland Offensive

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Confederate Heartland Offensive lasted from the 14th of August to the 10th of October, 1862, and it posed a question that General Braxton Bragg believed Kentucky itself would answer: would the border state throw its weight behind the Confederacy? He marched north with rifles to spare, enough to arm tens of thousands of recruits he expected to flood his ranks. What he got was closer to two thousand men, and roughly half of those soon deserted. The campaign would pit two Confederate generals, Bragg and Edmund Kirby Smith, against Union Major General Don Carlos Buell across some of the most contested ground in North America. It would produce a tactical victory at Perryville, the inauguration of a provisional Confederate governor on Kentucky soil, and a mountain of captured supplies. It would also end with a Confederate army retreating through the Cumberland Gap and a Union general losing his command for failing to finish the job. The questions worth sitting with are: why did Bragg invade in the first place, what went wrong on both sides, and what did the whole enterprise actually cost?

• 2. A State Nobody Could Claim

  ›

  Kentucky declared neutrality at the start of the war, but that posture did not hold for long. Confederate General Leonidas Polk made a decisive misstep when he chose to occupy Columbus in 1861. That move pushed the Kentucky legislature to petition the Union Army for help, going over the state governor's objections. After early 1862, the Union largely controlled the state, yet Kentucky still carried a star on the Confederate flag and held seats in the Confederate Congress. The contradiction ran deep. About 35,000 Kentuckians served as Confederate soldiers while an estimated 125,000 served in the Union armies. Nearly sixty infantry regiments fought for the Union versus just nine for the Confederacy, though a sizeable number of cavalry outfits joined the Confederate side. The divided loyalties were personal at the highest levels of American politics. Abraham Lincoln was born in Kentucky and lived there until age seven before growing up in Illinois. Most of Mary Todd Lincoln's relatives from the Lexington area were Confederate officers. John C. Breckinridge, one of the Confederacy's prominent leaders, came from Kentucky as well. The state produced cotton in its western portions, tobacco on large plantations with slave labor, and was also the primary supplier of hemp for rope used in the cotton industry. Louisville stood as a major center of the slave trade. This was the prize Bragg intended to pull into the Confederate orbit.

• 3. The Strategic Calculus

  ›

  By the summer of 1862, Union forces had made serious inroads across the West. The Tennessee and Cumberland Rivers had been opened to the U.S. Navy after victories at Fort Henry and Fort Donelson. Confederate forces had evacuated the railroad hub at Corinth, surrendering most of West Tennessee. Admiral David Farragut had captured New Orleans, which was the Confederacy's largest city at that time. With Confederate territory squeezed to what one observer described as "the single line of road running east from Vicksburg," protecting that Mississippi River stronghold became a top Confederate priority. Bragg's response was an invasion meant to pull Union attention away from both Vicksburg and Chattanooga, Tennessee, where Buell's large Union force was applying pressure. He transported all his infantry by railroad from Tupelo, Mississippi, to Chattanooga, while cavalry and artillery moved overland. The move to Chattanooga let him challenge Buell's advance directly. The logic of the campaign was not purely defensive. Bragg hoped that a march through Kentucky would ignite a popular uprising, drawing Southern sympathizers into Confederate ranks. Delegates from 68 Kentucky counties had already voted to join the Confederacy earlier in the war. Bragg saw that political opening as something a military campaign might rekindle.

• 4. Into Kentucky

  ›

  Once his forces assembled in Chattanooga, Bragg coordinated with Lieutenant General Edmund Kirby Smith, who commanded a separate force operating out of Knoxville, Tennessee. The two-pronged advance moved north through the late summer. Bragg captured more than 4,000 Union soldiers at Munfordville, then shifted his army to Bardstown. On the 4th of October, he took part in the inauguration of Richard Hawes as the provisional Confederate governor of Kentucky, a ceremony designed to signal that Confederate authority on Kentucky soil was real and lasting. The wing of Bragg's army under Major General Leonidas Polk met Buell's force at Perryville on the 8th of October and won a tactical victory. Kirby Smith urged Bragg to press the advantage. "For God's sake, General, let us fight Buell here," Smith pleaded. Bragg replied that he would, but then, in the words of one observer, displayed "a perplexity and vacillation which had now become simply appalling to Smith, to Hardee, and to Polk." He ordered retreat. Bragg framed the withdrawal as the successful culmination of a giant raid, but the judgment of those around him was harsher. His decision to move his army away from Munfordville and out of Buell's path earlier in the campaign drew particular criticism, since Munfordville offered a position well suited to a battle on Confederate terms.

• 5. Bragg's Reasons for Retreat

  ›

  Bad news arrived from multiple directions as Bragg weighed his options. Earl Van Dorn and Sterling Price had failed at Corinth in North Mississippi. Robert E. Lee's Maryland Campaign had also come to grief. Writing to his wife, Bragg explained his thinking directly: "With the whole southwest thus in the enemy's possession, my crime would have been unpardonable had I kept my noble little army to be ice-bound in the northern clime, without tents or shoes, and obliged to forage daily for bread." He saw the arithmetic plainly: a further isolated victory offered little, while a defeat could cost not only the supplies his army had gathered but the army itself. He referred to the retreat as a withdrawal, not a failure, and he had numbers to support a version of success. Confederate General Joseph Wheeler later claimed the campaign recovered Cumberland Gap and redeemed Middle Tennessee and North Alabama. Wheeler put the Federal losses at 26,530 killed, wounded, and captured. He listed captured materiel that included 35 cannons, 16,000 stand of arms, 1,700 mules, 300 loaded wagons, and 2,000 horses. Confederate war clerk J.B. Jones recorded that Bragg departed with 8,000 beef cattle, 50,000 barrels of pork, and a million yards of Kentucky cloth, amounts Jones described as the largest provisions ever obtained by an army. Bragg called the retreat through the Cumberland Gap to Knoxville a return on his terms.

• 6. Blame, Command, and Consequences

  ›

  Confederate President Jefferson Davis kept Bragg in command of the Army of Tennessee despite the open criticism from some newspapers and private complaints from Generals Polk and William J. Hardee. The failure was distributed widely enough that no single figure absorbed all the responsibility. Polk drew specific blame for not following Bragg's instructions on the day before and the day of Perryville. The armies of Bragg and Kirby Smith suffered throughout from a lack of unified command, a structural problem that shaped every major decision of the campaign. Bragg himself placed the blame squarely on Kentucky's civilians. He had carried 20,000 extra rifles to arm expected recruits. In a letter to his wife, he wrote: "In seven weeks occupation, with twenty thousand guns and ammunition burdening our train, we only succeeded in getting about two thousand men to join us and at least half of them have now deserted." The campaign's strategic failure did force Union forces out of Northern Alabama and most of Middle Tennessee, and it would take Union commanders a full year to regain that ground. On the Union side, the reckoning was equally sharp. Buell had driven Bragg out of Kentucky, but President Lincoln removed him from command of the Army of the Ohio for being too cautious in pursuing the retreating Confederates. He was replaced by Major General William Rosecrans, investigated by a military commission, and though acquitted of misconduct, he never received another command before mustering out of service in May 1864.