X Article

• 1. Stalin's 1946 Speech Context

  ›

  On the evening of the 9th of February 1946, Joseph Stalin stood before a packed audience at Moscow's Bolshoi Theatre. He spoke for nearly two hours about industrial expansion and Marxist-Leninist theory. The speech did not mention foreign policy directly, yet it sent shockwaves through Washington. Time magazine later described the address as "the most warlike pronouncement uttered by any top-rank statesman since V-J Day." American officials found themselves confused by the Soviet leader's sudden shift in tone. Harry Truman struggled to understand why the Soviets alternated between belligerence and self-restraint. Elbridge Durbrow recalled that Stalin had effectively declared, "to hell with the rest of the world." This rhetoric alarmed US diplomats who had just witnessed the rejection of Bretton Woods agreements. Evidence of atomic espionage in Canada and the United States added fuel to the fire. W. Averell Harriman returned from his ambassadorship convinced that existing strategies were failing. James F. Byrnes drafted a message on February 13 asking Kennan for an analysis. The State Department needed answers to explain what appeared to be a new threat.

  16

• 2. The Long Telegram Origins

  ›

  George Kennan spent late nights dictating a final version of his analysis to secretary Dorothy Hessman. He finished the document on the 22nd of February 1946, then walked to the Mokhovaya code room in Moscow. There he transmitted the message back to Washington under the official number 511. It became known immediately as the long telegram because it stretched over 5,000 words. No other dispatch in State Department history had ever been so lengthy. Kennan divided the text into five sections covering Soviet background, current features, future prospects, and implications for America. He argued that Russian rulers relied on a traditional sense of insecurity to justify their power. Previous leaders maintained authority through fragile psychological foundations unable to withstand Western contact. Marxism-Leninism provided the ideological cover for this internal weakness. Stalin used external threats to excuse cruelties and sacrifices demanded by the regime. Kennan concluded that the Soviets would never expect reconciliation with the West. He advised American officials to maintain courage and self-confidence when dealing with them. Managing the threat required thorough planning comparable to major strategic problems in war. Unlike Nazi Germany, the Soviet Union was patient and often risk-averse. Their economy remained rudimentary while leadership lacked orderly succession procedures.

  57

• 3. State Department Reception

  ›

  H. Freeman Matthews sent a cable praising the telegram as magnificent just days after its arrival. James F. Byrnes read it with greatest interest and called it a splendid analysis. W. Averell Harriman found the document fairly long and slow reading in spots but still forwarded copies to Secretary of the Navy James Forrestal. Forrestal became largely responsible for spreading the message across Washington. He distributed copies to ambassador Henry Norweb, British diplomat Frank Roberts, General George C. Marshall, and President Truman. The classified document gained wider readership than typical State Department communications. Policymakers quickly accepted Kennan's explanation of Soviet behavior as the best available interpretation. John Lewis Gaddis later wrote that the telegram became the basis for United States strategy throughout the Cold War. Wilson D. Miscamble conceded that Kennan's cable exercised a catalytic effect on departmental thinking. Louis Halle noted the timing arrived right when the Department floundered looking for new intellectual moorings. Matthews pointed out that administration policy had already moved toward not catering to Soviet interests before the telegram circulated. Joint Chiefs of Staff resolved in February 1946 that collaboration should stop short of expanding Russian influence. Melvyn P. Leffler argued that the telegram served primarily as rationale for subsequent actions rather than originator of policy.

  43

• 4. Foreign Affairs Publication Process

  ›

  Kennan spoke at the Council on Foreign Relations based at the Harold Pratt House in New York City on the 7th of January 1947. His theme was Soviet foreign relations presented to a small group designated not for attribution. International banker R. Gordon Wasson attended the discussion and suggested publishing the talk in Foreign Affairs magazine. Editor Hamilton Fish Armstrong requested Kennan revise his speech into an article by January 10. Kennan replied on February 4 stating he could not write under his own name due to government restrictions. He offered instead to publish anonymously or under a pen name. Armstrong agreed on March 7 despite acknowledging the disadvantage of anonymity. Kennan worked as lecturer at National War College while searching for previous work to repurpose. He found an analysis titled Psychological Background of Soviet Foreign Policy written in late January 1946. Forrestal had described this earlier piece as extremely well-done before sending it to General Marshall. Kennan scratched out his name from the document and wrote X in its place. Armstrong published the final version under the title The Sources of Soviet Conduct removing all authorship notes. The July 1947 issue carried just over 19,000 subscribers at $1.25 per copy.

  6

• 5. Public Revelation and Containment Theory

  ›

  Journalist Arthur Krock drew attention to the anonymous article in a New York Times column on the 8th of July 1947. He suggested the main thrust matched American government policy after appeasement proved failure. Krock concluded the author's views closely resembled those marked Top Secret in official Washington files. Forrestal had allowed Krock to see the draft containing Kennan's actual name at the end. Rumors spread quickly among diplomats who suspected Kennan due to distinct prose style and quoting Edward Gibbon. The Daily Worker broke the story on July 9 with headline X Bared as State Dep't Aid calling for overthrow of Soviet Government. Newsweek explained in its July 21 issue that the article provided rationale for both Truman Doctrine and Marshall Plan. George Marshall spoke privately with Kennan concerned by amount of attention drawn. Kennan explained the piece cleared publication by competent official committee satisfied Marshall though he remained astonished. Henry Kissinger later called it diplomatic doctrine of the era reflecting widespread adoption of containment term. Gaddis wrote that some misinterpreted Kennan's views placing undue emphasis on conspicuous but misleading X article. Kennan reassessed his perimeter defense concept shifting toward strongpoint defense focusing on particular areas.

  24

• 6. Walter Lippmann Critique

  ›

  Political commentator Walter Lippmann responded across fourteen columns published in New York Herald Tribune starting the 2nd of September 1947. His analysis collected into book Cold War became widely read throughout America. Lippmann critiqued the article as presenting strategic monstrosity giving Soviets initiative in any conflict. He claimed United States depended on coalition of disorganized nations tribes and factions. Lippmann incorrectly concluded Kennan inspired Truman Doctrine which appeared the 12th of March 1947 before article completion. Gaddis noted no evidence influenced drafting address despite abundant proof Kennan sought removing language Lippmann objected to. Kennan regretted some views expressed within due to rushed writing process yet did not revise final draft sent April 11. State Department position made him hesitant offering public clarification until first memoir volume published 1967. Thomas Borstelmann wrote Kennan detested people Africa Asia Middle East Latin America lumping them together as impulsive fanatical ignorant lazy unhappy prone mental disorders biological deficiencies. In 1942 lecture Kennan explained Bolshevik Revolution revealed Russians not westernized but 17th century semi-Asiatic people. Perspectives on race common in contemporary American policymaking circles.

  45

• 7. Historical Legacy and Reassessment

  ›

  The Sources of Soviet Conduct widely introduced term containment to diplomatic vocabulary. Henry Kissinger reflected in 1979 memoir that George Kennan came close authoring diplomatic doctrine era. John Lewis Gaddis wrote silence facing Lippmann critiques resulted idea becoming synonymous with Truman's doctrine. Some historians misinterpreted Kennan placing undue emphasis on conspicuous but misleading X article. Kennan admitted using counterforce rather than counter-pressure led confusion for readers. He shifted from perimeter defense concept to strongpoint defense focusing particular areas after publication. Thomas Borstelmann noted few experiences outside Europe contributed detestation people Africa Asia Middle East Latin America. Kennan linked Soviet despotism to leaders attitude Oriental secretiveness conspiracy in first memoir 1967. His perspectives on race common in contemporary American policymaking circles despite later criticism. The document remains central understanding Cold War strategy though modern interpretations vary significantly regarding its actual influence versus retrospective mythmaking.

  89101112