When Marnie Was There (film)

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  When Marnie Was There, released in Japanese theaters on the 19th of July 2014, begins with a question most children have asked in some form: does anyone truly love me? Anna Sasaki is twelve years old, living with foster parents in Sapporo, and she carries a particular kind of loneliness that has no easy name. When a doctor recommends cleaner air for her asthma, she is sent to a rural seaside town between Kushiro and Nemuro, on the edge of the Hokkaido wetlands. There, across a salt marsh, she finds an abandoned mansion. And there, she finds Marnie.

  What follows is a psychological drama that Studio Ghibli built around one of the most intimate questions in animation: what does it mean to belong to someone? The film asks that question through two girls, a crumbling marsh house, and a secret that stretches across two generations. Director Hiromasa Yonebayashi would later call the story moving but difficult to visualize. The answers he found would earn the film a nomination for the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature.

• 2. A Director's Reluctance

  ›

  Hiromasa Yonebayashi did not want to make this film. When Ghibli producer Toshio Suzuki assigned him the project, Yonebayashi read Joan G. Robinson's 1967 novel and felt it would be "very difficult to visualize as a film." He initially turned down the role. The book had a long pedigree at Ghibli. Hayao Miyazaki had previously cited it as one of his favorite children's novels, which made Yonebayashi's reluctance all the more striking.

  His interest eventually returned, and with it came a set of creative decisions that reshaped Robinson's story. Suzuki had asked him to move the setting to Japan, which Yonebayashi agreed to do. But one element of the original stayed: Marnie's appearance. She remained blonde and blue-eyed, even as the world around her became Japanese countryside. Miyazaki himself opposed this decision, judging the use of Marnie's character as "plain outdated and cheesy." Producer Yoshiaki Nishimura clarified that drawing attention through her appearance had never been the intention.

  Yonebayashi's returned commitment brought with it a clear purpose. He intended the film as something encouraging for children in Japan who felt lonely and isolated. He hoped that when they saw Marnie, "maybe they could take a little step forward." To that end, Anna was given a new characteristic not present in the source novel: she was written as an artist, a detail Yonebayashi conceived to ground her interiority in something visible on screen.

• 3. The Marsh House

  ›

  Yohei Taneda designed the central location of the film, the Marsh House, with a particular instruction from Yonebayashi. He was asked "to draw the Marsh House as if it were another character who watches over Anna." Taneda traveled through Hokkaido to scout real buildings for reference, so the building that appears onscreen carries the grain of actual architecture.

  The production team placed key emphasis on highly detailed character movements and backgrounds, treating the texture of Anna's environment as essential to her experience rather than as backdrop. The salt marsh that separates Anna from the mansion becomes a physical expression of what she cannot yet reach. When the tide traps her on her first visit, it is an elderly fisherman named Toichi who finds her, grounding the supernatural atmosphere in something plainly human.

  The decision to make the Marsh House feel inhabited by its own presence shaped how the mystery of Marnie unfolds. Hisako, an older woman who paints in the area, recognizes Anna's sketches of Marnie as someone she actually knew when she was young. That detail anchors the film's central puzzle long before the answer arrives: the girl across the marsh is not a stranger.

• 4. Music and Theme Song

  ›

  Priscilla Ahn wrote and performed the film's theme song, "Fine on the Outside." On the 16th of July 2014, three days before the film opened in Japanese theaters, Ahn also released an accompanying album called Just Know That I Love You.

  The soundtrack itself was released the same day, both as a CD in Japan and as a digital download on the iTunes Store across 113 countries. The album is structured as two discs. The first disc, labeled an "Image Song" collection, presents music composed to express the personalities of characters and the feeling of specific places in the film. The second disc collects all the background music used in the picture. The two-disc structure reflects how seriously the production treated sound as a parallel to the visual work on character and setting.

• 5. Reception and Legacy

  ›

  Critics received the film warmly. On Rotten Tomatoes, it holds a 92% approval rating based on 100 reviews, with an average score of 7.5 out of 10. The critical consensus noted that the film was "blessed with enough visual and narrative beauty to recommend, even if it isn't quite as magical as Studio Ghibli's greatest works." On Metacritic, 22 critics gave it a score of 72 out of 100, indicating generally favorable reviews.

  Overseas, the film sold 114,679 tickets in France in 2015. In the United States and Canada combined, it grossed $561,085 in theaters and an additional $3,478,150 from Blu-ray and DVD sales. In the United Kingdom, it ranked as 2016's third best-selling foreign language film on home video, and returned the following year as 2017's eighth best-selling foreign language film, finishing as the year's fourth best-selling Japanese film behind Your Name, My Neighbor Totoro, and Yu-Gi-Oh! The Dark Side of Dimensions.

  The film's success pushed readers back to Robinson's novel. Her agent Caroline Sheldon sold rights to the book in 10 countries, including Japan, Italy, Spain, and China. HarperCollins Children's Books re-released the English edition as part of its classics range.

  At the Academy Awards, the film was nominated for Best Animated Feature. It was also nominated for the Japan Academy Prize for Animation of the Year, the Annie Award for Best Animated Feature in the independent category, and the Saturn Award for Best Animated Film. The Annie nomination for directing went to Yonebayashi; the writing nomination went to Keiko Niwa, Masashi Ando, and Yonebayashi. The nomination for the Academy Award listed Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura.

  The film also carries a personal weight in Ghibli's history. Animator Makiko Futaki, whose final work for the studio appears in this picture, died in May 2016. And for Yonebayashi, the man who almost refused the project, it was his last film at Ghibli. He left afterward to join Studio Ponoc.