The Return of the King (1980 film)

• 1. Production History And Development

  ›

  The special aired on ABC on Sunday, the 11th of May 1980. This animated musical fantasy television film emerged from Rankin/Bass Productions in New York City under the supervision of Arthur Rankin Jr. and Jules Bass. Its original working title was Frodo, The Hobbit II before it became known as The Return of the King: A Story of the Hobbits. Writer Romeo Muller crafted the script while Rankin handled character designs and storyboards. Animation production took place in Japan at Topcraft under the supervision of Toru Hara, Tsuguyuki Kubo, and Kazuyuki Kobayashi.

  A legal threat loomed over the project when the Tolkien Estate and Fantasy Films filed a lawsuit. They claimed Rankin/Bass had not secured U.S. and Canadian television rights to J.R.R. Tolkien's book. The dispute settled amicably, allowing the film to proceed with its scheduled May 1980 release. Without this resolution, the broadcast might never have happened.

  1

• 2. Voice Cast And Musical Composition

  ›

  Orson Bean voiced both Bilbo Baggins and Frodo Baggins in the final installment. John Huston returned as Gandalf the White alongside Roddy McDowall as Samwise Gamgee. Theodore Bikel provided the voice for Aragorn while William Conrad played Denethor. Casey Kasem appeared as Merry Brandybuck and Sonny Melendrez as Pippin Took. Nellie Bellflower portrayed Éowyn and Glenn Yarbrough served as the Minstrel of Gondor.

  Maury Laws composed the background music while Jules Bass wrote all songs and lyrics. Thurl Ravenscroft contributed to the chorus work. Paul Frees replaced Cyril Ritchard as Elrond after the original actor passed away. Brother Theodore voiced Gollum under his own name. The musical score featured folk-ballad elements that critics later described as overbearing compared to Tolkien's poetry.

  3456

• 3. Narrative Adaptation Choices

  ›

  Gandalf briefly narrates the background before the story begins at Bilbo Baggins's 129th birthday party in Rivendell. His nephew Frodo explains why he is missing a finger from his hand while the Minstrel of Gondor sings a ballad about destroying the One Ring. Samwise Gamgee bears the Ring in Frodo's absence as he ventures to rescue him from the Orc fortress of Cirith Ungol.

  Frodo and Samwise head toward Mount Doom while eluding Ringwraiths and infiltrating an Orc battalion. They face Gollum, who bites off Frodo's finger during their struggle for the Ring. Meanwhile, Théoden King dies fighting the Witch-king of Angmar at the Battle of Pelennor Fields. Éowyn kills the Witch-king with help from Merry Brandybuck. Aragorn arrives with the black fleet from the west to confront Sauron at the Black Gate. The film condenses these events into two hours while skipping earlier plot points entirely.

  89

• 4. Critical Reception And Legacy

  ›

  Both critics and fans gave The Return of the King an indifferent reception upon its initial broadcast. Charles Cassidy of Common Sense Media awarded it a score of 3/5, calling it darker and more complex than other series entries. Steven D. Greydanus of Decent Films Guide assigned it a C grade, noting that the overbearing folk-ballad soundtrack failed to match Tolkien's poetry. Director Arthur Rankin Jr. later admitted the project was not very good due to the difficulty of fitting so much material into two hours.

  Rankin reflected on why he chose only to make this final volume instead of the entire trilogy. He stated he did not know audiences would sit still for such content and admitted being wrong about viewer patience. Modern comparisons often place this version below Peter Jackson's live-action films in terms of execution and scope.

  79

• 5. Home Media Distribution And Marketing

  ›

  The Return of the King first appeared on CED videodisc by RCA in 1979 before VHS releases began in 1991 through Warner Home Video. A second release occurred as part of the Warner Bros. Classic Tales video collection in 1996. DVD availability started in 2001 both individually and within a boxed trilogy pairing it with Rankin/Bass's The Hobbit and Bakshi's The Lord of the Rings.

  Warner Bros. marketed the film alongside Ralph Bakshi's animated work after acquiring rights following Rankin/Bass's defunct status in 1987. This false promotion created rumors that Rankin/Bass originally planned their sequel upon hearing Bakshi's follow-up had been cancelled. In reality, Rankin/Bass always intended to produce The Return of the King as a direct follow-up to their own production of The Hobbit before Bakshi's film ever released.

  8