The Orator

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Orator has worn several names since it was cast in bronze. Etruscans called the figure Aule Meteli. Romans called him Aulus Metellus. Italian sources call the sculpture L'Arringatore. He depicts a senator of the Roman republic who came from Perugia or Cortona. The bronze itself dates to the late second or early first century BC. In 1566, someone found the statue in or near Lake Trasimeno, in the province of Perugia, on the border between Umbria and Tuscany. The exact spot is still disputed, though it lies some 177 kilometers, or 110 miles, from Rome. Today the statue stands in the National Archaeological Museum of Florence. Carved into its surface is an inscription in the Etruscan language. It names a god and a family, and it raises a question historians still argue over. Was this bronze figure a gift to a god, or a monument built to honor a living man in front of his neighbors? And was the family behind it wealthy, or ordinary? Both debates turn out to hinge on the same handful of physical details cast into the bronze itself.

• 2. A Senator's Likeness

  ›

  At 179 centimeters tall, the statue wears a toga exigua, a short sleeved tunic beneath a close fitting toga. The garment is slung over the left arm and shoulder, leaving the right arm free to move. The hem cuts from over the right ankle diagonally up to a point above the left calf. On his feet are calceus senatorius, red leather boots that marked the wearer as a senator or high ranking magistrate. He stands in contrapposto, weight settled onto one leg.

  Aulus Metellus reaches his right arm outward, bent at the elbow, with the palm open and the fingers spread. His left hand rests at his side, raised slightly and half open. His hair is cut short and combed to the left. On his left ring finger sits a ring, believed to be a scarab ring. Cast in seven separate pieces, the bronze still shows its seams where the sections were joined. Among those seven sections, cut into the metal itself, is a message the sculptor's craftsmanship alone does not explain.

• 3. An Etruscan Inscription

  ›

  "Auleśi meteliś veluś vesial clenśi, cen flereś tece sanśl tenine, tu θineś χisvlicś" is carved into the bronze in the Etruscan language. Historians translate it as: "To (or from) Auli Meteli, the son of Vel and Vesi, Tenine (?), set up this statue as a votive offering to Sans, by deliberation of the people." The god named in that dedication is Sans. The person credited with commissioning the statue is someone called Tenine, though that reading carries a question mark among scholars who study the text. The phrase "by deliberation of the people" reaches beyond a single household, hinting that more than family was involved in putting the statue up.

• 4. Offering or Honor

  ›

  Spivey and other sources argue the family that commissioned Aulus Metellus was wealthy, citing the bronze and the statue's craftsmanship as proof. Shiell disagrees, arguing the same statue could have come from a fairly ordinary Roman family. Both scholars are responding to a deeper, unresolved question. Was the statue a votive offering, a gift given to a god in thanks for an answered prayer? Or was it an honorary statue, one meant to be seen by the public? A votive offering, by definition, could be anything from a simple handmade effigy to, for a wealthy giver, an expensive commissioned statue. An honorary statue served a different purpose. It was not just decoration for a public space; it carried real political and social weight. No consensus exists on which reading is correct. The sources say so directly: the debate over Aulus Metellus's family and the statue's true purpose remains open.