The Battle of Evermore

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  "The Battle of Evermore" was born not from careful planning but from a borrowed instrument and a single spontaneous evening at Headley Grange. Jimmy Page picked up John Paul Jones's mandolin, having never played one before, and by the time the night was done, he and Robert Plant had written the entire song from scratch. That one sitting produced one of the most unusual tracks in the Led Zeppelin catalog: a folk rock piece laced with Tolkien's Middle-earth, featuring a guest vocalist who would receive her own cryptic symbol on one of rock's most mysterious album sleeves. How did a band known for electrified blues end up writing something that sounded, as Page put it, "like an old English instrumental first off"? And why is this the only song Led Zeppelin ever recorded with a guest singer?

• 2. Mandolin and Middle-earth

  ›

  Page's account of writing the song is strikingly casual given the result. He explained in 1977 that it was "made up on the spot" by Plant and himself, a chord structure arrived at without any prior experience on the instrument. Jones owned the mandolin; Page simply picked it up. The acoustic guitar followed, and the song took shape around both.

  Lyrically, Plant reached for the world J. R. R. Tolkien built in The Lord of the Rings, a source the band had drawn on before. "Ramble On" from Led Zeppelin II and "Misty Mountain Hop" from the same 1971 album both carry Tolkien references. "The Battle of Evermore" goes further. Line 4 carries "The Dark Lord rides in force tonight and time will tell us all." Line 18 names the Ringwraiths directly: "The drums will shake the castle wall, the Ringwraiths ride in black." Lines 13, 19, 20, and 24 bring in war, bows, magic runes, and "the dragon of darkness."

  The J. R. R. Tolkien Encyclopedia recognized these as direct references to Gollum, Mordor, the Ringwraiths, and events described in both The Lord of the Rings and The Silmarillion. Scholars writing in The Oxford Handbook of Music and Medievalism read the song as "fantasy medievalism", noting that the battle Plant describes has frequently been identified by fans as the Battle of the Pelennor Fields. The handbook also raised the possibility that the "Queen of Light" mentioned in the lyrics is the elf-queen Galadriel, though it stops short of confirming it.

• 3. Sandy Denny's Contribution

  ›

  Plant decided early on that this song could not be carried by one voice alone. He felt he needed another singer to tell the story properly, and the name that came to mind was Sandy Denny, a former member of Fairport Convention. The connection between the two camps ran back to 1970, when Led Zeppelin and Fairport Convention had shared a bill at the Bath Festival of Blues and Progressive Music.

  Page described how the arrangement developed: the song first sounded like a purely instrumental piece, then Plant added his vocals, and finally the band realized it called for a back-and-forth between two voices. Plant took the role of the narrator; Denny represented the town crier. Page framed it as "a question-and-answer-type thing."

  In a 1995 interview with Uncut magazine, Plant reflected on the recording with warmth. He acknowledged the song might have suffered from what he called "naivete and tweeness" and noted he was only 23 at the time. But he also said the collaboration made up for any shortcomings in "the cohesion of the voices and the playing." He described Richard Thompson, Denny's former bandmate, as a "superlative guitarist" and made clear that he and Denny were friends long before the session. Asking her to sing was, in his words, "the most obvious thing."

  The album credited her contribution in an unusual way. Each of the four members of Led Zeppelin chose a personal symbol for the untitled 1971 album's sleeve. To thank Denny, the band gave her a symbol of her own: three pyramids. No other guest on a Led Zeppelin record ever received that kind of acknowledgment, and no other guest vocalist ever appeared on a Led Zeppelin studio recording.

• 4. What the Scholars Heard

  ›

  The Oxford Handbook of Music and Medievalism paid close attention to how the song actually works on a listener. Its analysis pointed to Plant's use of nostalgia, drawn out through what it called "strain and desperation" in his "vocal cries." Those cries sit against what the handbook described as a "haunting, pastoral soundscape," and the tension between the two creates a specific emotional effect: a peaceful, idealized home set against a world being torn apart by war.

  That framing is not incidental to the song. Tolkien's fiction is built on exactly that opposition, the Shire against the darkness creeping in from Mordor. Plant and Page found an acoustic way into that feeling without ever making it literal or explanatory. The mandolin and acoustic guitar, played by two men whose strengths lay elsewhere, gave the song a roughness that polished studio production might have erased.

  The instrumental version recorded at Headley Grange on the 29th of January 1971 at the Rolling Stones Mobile, with engineer Andy Johns, preserves an early glimpse of what the song sounded like before the vocals arrived. It runs 4 minutes and 13 seconds, considerably shorter than the final version at 5 minutes and 51 seconds. That track eventually surfaced on the remastered deluxe two-disc edition of Led Zeppelin IV, titled The Battle of Evermore (Mandolin/Guitar Mix From Headley Grange).

• 5. Life Beyond the Studio

  ›

  "The Battle of Evermore" reached concert stages during Led Zeppelin's 1977 North American Tour, decades after its recording. Denny was not present for those shows, and the band worked around her absence. Jones sang her vocal part and played acoustic guitar while Page handled the mandolin. On some nights, John Bonham sang her lines alongside Jones.

  Plant returned to the song with a different partner in 2008. He and Alison Krauss performed it regularly during their spring and summer tour of the United States and Europe, a run of shows supporting their 2007 collaboration album Raising Sand. The pairing of Plant's voice against a woman's remained central to how the song was understood in performance.

  Fairport Convention brought Plant back to his old connection with that group's world on the 9th of August 2008, when Plant and Kristina Donahue joined them at Fairport's Cropredy Convention for a live rendition of the song.

  Page and Plant had also recorded a live version in 1994, released on their album No Quarter: Jimmy Page and Robert Plant Unledded, keeping the song in circulation through several different eras and configurations. Q magazine in the United Kingdom later listed it among its "150 Greatest Rock Lists Ever" at number four in the category of songs based on novels.