Tantalus
Tantalus stands in a pool of water, chin-deep, beneath boughs heavy with fruit. Every time he reaches upward, the branches pull away. Every time he bends to drink, the water drains beneath him. This image, drawn from the Odyssey, the oldest surviving text to mention him, is so vivid that it gave the English language the word "tantalize." But the story behind that image is far stranger, far more contested, and far older than most people know. Who was Tantalus, and what had he actually done to deserve an eternity of thirst? As it turns out, the ancient Greeks themselves could not entirely agree.
There may have been a real Tantalus. The geographer Strabo recorded that his wealth came from the mines of Phrygia and Mount Sipylus. Pausanias noted that a port bore his name and that his sepulcher was "by no means obscure" in that same region. Near Mount Yamanlar in what is now Izmir, the lake called Karagol has been known since antiquity as Lake Tantalus. On Mount Sipylus itself stands a structure Pausanias called the tholos tomb of Tantalus, later adopted by Christians as the tomb of Saint Charalambos. A rock carving on the same mountain, conjecturally identified as a "throne of Pelops," ties the site to his son as well.
Ancient sources called him "King of Phrygia," though Strabo and others placed his city at the western edge of Anatolia, in the territory where Lydia later rose as a state before the first millennium BCE. References to his son Pelops as "Pelops the Lydian" led some scholars to argue that Tantalus belonged to a primordial royal house of Lydia. His mortal mountain-fathers, in variants where his father is Tmolus rather than Zeus, are consistently associated with Lydian geography. His grave-sanctuary stood on Sipylus, but honors were paid to him at Argos as well, where local tradition claimed to hold his bones. On the island of Lesbos, a hero-shrine in the settlement of Polion and a mountain both bore his name.
Odysseus encounters Tantalus in Hades, watching him reach endlessly for fruit and water in a pool up to his chin. Homer offers no explanation for why he is there. The earliest account that does name a crime is preserved in a fragment of the lost Nostoi, quoted in the Deipnosophistae of Athenaeus. In that version, Zeus swore an oath to give Tantalus anything he asked, and Tantalus asked to live as the gods do. Bound by his oath, Zeus granted it, but punished him by placing a giant rock above his head. Tantalus had access to divine banquets but could never enjoy them for fear of the boulder falling.
This version, featuring the hanging rock, was actually the more popular variant in early Greek sources. Fragments of Archilochus, Alcman, Alcaeus, and Pherecydes all mention the rock. Pausanias, writing around 110-180 CE, visited the Knidian lesche at Delphi, a building full of paintings by Polygnotus, and saw Tantalus depicted there enduring both punishments simultaneously: the receding food and drink from Homer and the rock above his head. Pausanias was unsure whether Archilochus originated the rock variant or was following an older source.
Later writers added further crimes. Diodorus Siculus, writing in the first century BCE, said Tantalus had shared the intimate conversations of the gods with mortals. Ovid repeated this in the Ars Amatoria. Apollodorus combined the theft of ambrosia and the sharing of divine secrets as twin offenses. Horace, writing between 65 BCE and 8 CE, mentioned the receding water in his first Satire. Lucretius described Tantalus's terror of a boulder suspended in the air. Vergil, in the Aeneid, placed a crag hanging over him.
Pindar, writing around 518-438 BCE, is the key witness to the variant most widely known today. In his first Olympian Ode, he acknowledges the story in which Tantalus killed his son Pelops, served him at a feast to the gods, and one goddess ate part of him. But Pindar then explicitly rejects this version. He calls it a lie and says it is better to speak well of the gods.
In Pindar's preferred account, Tantalus had invited the gods to a meal to repay their hospitality to him. Nothing went wrong. But Poseidon, seeing Pelops, was seized with desire and carried him away in his chariot. The disappearance of Pelops led envious neighbors to spread the rumor that he had been killed and eaten. The scholar Douglas Gerber suggests Pindar may have implied the gods were involved in this gruesome rumor precisely to make it seem too monstrous to be true.
The first surviving source to actually name Demeter as the goddess who ate part of Pelops is the Alexandra of Lycophron, written around 300 BCE. Lycophron names only that she ate the shoulder of Pelops, without explaining how or why. The Fabulae fills in more: Tantalus dismembered Pelops at a feast, Ceres, the Roman counterpart of Demeter, ate part of his arm, and the gods restored him, with Ceres replacing the missing shoulder with ivory. A scholium on Lycophron offers the explanation that Demeter was distracted by grief over the loss of her daughter Persephone and failed to notice what she was eating.
Why Tantalus would do this at all is addressed only by late sources. Servius, writing in the early fifth century CE, said Tantalus's motive was to test whether the gods were truly omniscient. The first Vatican Mythographer read Demeter's role allegorically: as goddess of earth, she consumes the bodies of the dead but spares the bones. The second and third Vatican Mythographers added that Mercury, as god of intelligence, was the one who restored Pelops to life.
A separate tradition wove Tantalus into a story involving a mechanical golden dog. Antoninus Liberalis recorded that a man named Pandareus stole a golden dog that Rhea had placed to guard the goat that nursed the infant Zeus, hidden in a cave on Crete to protect him from Cronus. After the theft, Pandareus gave the dog to Tantalus for safekeeping. When Pandareus returned and asked for it back, Tantalus swore an oath that he had never received it. Zeus turned Pandareus to stone for the theft, and punished Tantalus for the false oath by striking him with a thunderbolt and placing Mount Sipylus on top of him.
Variants appear in scholia on the Odyssey. In one, Zeus sent Hermes to retrieve the dog from Tantalus. Tantalus lied to Hermes, but Hermes found the dog and took it back regardless. Another variant has Tantalus himself as the original thief. One version describes the dog as a mechanical creation crafted by Hephaestus to guard a temple of Zeus. Scholars generally assume that several lost ancient plays about Tantalus drew on this story rather than on the cannibal feast.
Tantalus appeared in a lost play by Aeschylus called Niobe. The surviving fragments show him arriving at Thebes after Artemis and Apollo had slaughtered all of Niobe's children in revenge for her boasting. Tantalus arrived unknowing, and was shown in the fragments boasting of his own lands in bliss, before learning what had happened and trying to comfort his daughter, and finally escorting the inconsolable Niobe back home to Lydia.
The Roman author Seneca included the ghost of Tantalus in his tragedy Thyestes. A Fury drags him up from the Underworld and commands him to spread wickedness between his grandsons Atreus and Thyestes, who had already been exiled by their father Pelops for killing their half-brother Chrysippus and fighting over rulership of their kingdom. The old men of Mycenae and Argos who form the chorus declare they will prevent the coming crimes and speak of Tantalus's original offenses.
In visual art, all known ancient depictions of Tantalus date from the fifth century BCE onward. He appears on the name vase of the Underworld Painter, an Apulian red-figure volute-krater showing the palace of Hades and Persephone with scenes of the underworld. In the lower right corner, Tantalus is shown pointing to a rock hanging above him, from which he flees. This vase and the painting by Polygnotus described by Pausanias are the only two known artistic depictions of the rock punishment. The Velletri Sarcophagus shows him on its back lower register, naked, standing in water reaching to his knees, hands cupped as though lifting water to his mouth.
The ancient Greeks used the phrase "Tantalean punishment" to describe a person who possesses desirable things but cannot enjoy them. Pindar and Archilochus both used the expression "the rock of Tantalus" as a proverbial phrase, comparable to the Sword of Damocles, to mean that attempting to enjoy something places a person in a state of perpetual imminent danger.
Plato, in the Cratylus, connected the name Tantalus to the Greek word talantatos, meaning "he who has to bear much," derived from talas, meaning "wretched." The Third Vatican Mythographer offered a different reading: "wishing for a vision." Martin Litchfield West proposed a connection to the names of two Hittite kings named Hantili, suggesting the name itself may predate Greek myth. The scholar R. S. P. Beekes rejected an Indo-European root for the underlying word. None of these interpretations has closed the question.
The English word "tantalize" is derived directly from his name and punishment, carrying forward a myth that began in the Odyssey and accumulated centuries of variants, contradictions, and allegorical readings before settling into the image the English language borrowed: a fruit just out of reach, water that will not be drunk.
Continue Browsing
Common questions
What is Tantalus famous for in Greek mythology?
Tantalus is most famous for his punishment in Tartarus, where he stood in a pool of water beneath a fruit tree, unable to eat or drink because the fruit and water always receded from his reach. His name is the origin of the English word "tantalize."
What crime did Tantalus commit according to ancient Greek sources?
Ancient sources disagree. The Nostoi fragment says he asked Zeus to let him live as the gods do. Diodorus Siculus and Ovid say he shared divine secrets with mortals. Apollodorus names both the theft of ambrosia and the sharing of secrets. The story of feeding his son Pelops to the gods, though best known today, appears comparatively late in surviving texts.
What was the punishment of Tantalus in early Greek sources?
In early Greek sources, the more common punishment was a giant rock suspended above Tantalus's head, which he perpetually fled. The rock variant appears in fragments of Archilochus, Alcman, Alcaeus, and Pherecydes, and is the punishment depicted in the Nostoi. The receding water and fruit, familiar from Homer's Odyssey, became the dominant image later.
What is the connection between Tantalus and the House of Atreus?
Tantalus was the father of Pelops, who became the father of Atreus, after whom the House of Atreus was named. The house was marked by persistent misfortune and became the subject of many Greek tragedies, including Seneca's Thyestes, in which the ghost of Tantalus is summoned to sow enmity between Atreus and his brother Thyestes.
Where was Tantalus believed to have ruled in the ancient world?
Tantalus was sometimes called King of Phrygia, but ancient sources generally placed his city at the western edge of Anatolia, in territory associated with Lydia. The geographer Strabo said his wealth came from the mines of Phrygia and Mount Sipylus. Pausanias recorded a port and a sepulcher bearing his name in that region, and Lake Karagol near modern Izmir has been called Lake Tantalus since antiquity.
How did Pindar treat the story of Tantalus feeding his son to the gods?
In his first Olympian Ode, written around 518-438 BCE, Pindar explicitly rejected the cannibal feast story, calling it a lie and stating it was better to speak well of the gods. He offered an alternative account in which the gods dined with Tantalus without incident, and Poseidon carried off Pelops out of desire, with envious neighbors inventing the rumor that Pelops had been eaten.
All sources
42 references cited across the entry
- 1BookEarly Greek Mythography Vol.2Robert Fowler — Oxford University Press — 2013
- 7BookThe East Face of Helicon: West Asiatic Elements in Greek Poetry and MythM. L. West — Oxford University Press — 1999
- 8BookHistory of Art in Phrygia, Lydia, Caria And LyciaGeorge Perrot — Marton Press — 2007
- 9BookBulfinch's MythologyThomas Bulfinch — Kessinger Publishing Company — June 2004
- 10BookEarly Greek myth : a guide to literary and artistic sourcesTimothy Gantz — Johns Hopkins University Press — 1993
- 26BookPindar's 'Olympian One' - A CommentaryDouglas Gerber — University of Toronto Press — 1982
- 27BookA commentary on Euripides' Iphigenia in TaurisPoulheria Kyriakou — W. de Gruyter — 2006
- 28BookEuripides - HelenPeter Burian — Aris & Phillips Classicas Texts, Oxbow Books — 2007
- 31BookOvid, Ars amatoria: Buch 2 KommentarMarkus Janka — C. Winter — 1997
- 41BookAeschylus: FragmentsAlan H. Sommerstein — Harvard University Press — 2009
- 42BookThe Ten Tragedies of SenecaWatson Bradshaw — S. Sonnenschein & Co. — 1903