Free to follow every thread. No paywall, no dead ends.
Symbol: the story on HearLore | HearLore
Symbol
In the ancient world, a broken piece of ceramic held the power to verify truth itself. When a message needed to be sent across great distances, the sender would take a clay pot, break it into two halves, and keep one half while giving the other to the recipient. Years later, when the messenger arrived with the news, the two halves would be pressed together. If they fit perfectly, the receiver knew the message was genuine and had not been tampered with by a third party. This ancient practice of breaking and rejoining pottery gave rise to the very concept of a symbol, evolving from a physical token of verification into the abstract idea of a mark that signifies something else. The word symbol itself traces its lineage back to this physical act of connection, deriving from the Latin verb meaning to put together or compare. By the mid-16th century, during the Renaissance, the meaning had shifted from a physical token to a natural fact or object that evokes an association of ideas with something abstract or absent. This transformation is evident in the works of François Rabelais, who used the term in 1552 to describe how external signs could point to deeper truths. The concept traveled through late Middle French theological contexts, where it signified a formula used in the Roman Catholic Church as a synonym for the credo, before eventually settling into its modern secular meaning of something which stands for something else, a definition first recorded in English in 1590 within Edmund Spenser's Faerie Queene.
The Architecture of Meaning
Symbols are not merely decorative marks but the fundamental architecture upon which human understanding is built. They serve as the basis for all human knowledge, allowing people to go beyond what is immediately known or seen by creating linkages between otherwise different concepts and experiences. Without symbols, complex communication would be impossible, as every interaction relies on the use of signs to convey meaning. A red octagon on a road is not just a shape; it is a universal command to stop, understood without the need for words. On a map, blue lines do not represent water in a literal sense but serve as a visual shorthand for rivers, allowing a traveler to navigate terrain they have never seen. In the realm of mathematics, numerals are symbols for numbers, and letters of an alphabet are symbols for specific sounds, or phonemes. Even personal names function as symbols representing specific individuals, allowing society to identify and interact with one another. This system of communication allows cultures to express specific ideologies and social structures, carrying meanings that depend entirely upon one's cultural background. The meaning of a symbol is not inherent in the object itself but is culturally learned, meaning that a red rose might symbolize love and compassion in one context while carrying a different weight in another. These symbols facilitate understanding of the world, serving as the grounds upon which people make judgments and cooperate in society through what is known as constitutive rhetoric.
The word symbol traces its lineage back to the Latin verb meaning to put together or compare. This origin derives from the ancient practice of breaking and rejoining pottery to verify the truth of a message.
When was the modern secular meaning of symbol first recorded in English?
The modern secular meaning of symbol was first recorded in English in 1590 within Edmund Spenser's Faerie Queene. This definition describes something which stands for something else.
Who proposed the distinction between signs and symbols in psychology?
The Swiss psychoanalyst Carl Jung proposed the distinction between signs and symbols. Jung argued that symbols are essential for accessing the depths of the human psyche and point to something unknown.
What are the three primary forms of value that symbols carry?
Symbols carry value in three primary forms: ideological, comparative, and isomorphic. Ideological symbols convey complex beliefs, comparative symbols establish hierarchies, and isomorphic symbols enable individuals to conform to their surroundings.
How do cartographers categorize symbols on a map?
Cartographers categorize map symbols into pictorial, functional, conceptual, conventional, and abstract or geometric types. These categories determine how a graphic mark connects to a particular feature of the real world.
What is the difference between a sign and a symbol according to Carl Jung?
A sign stands for something known and can be invented or forgotten, while a symbol points to something unknown and carries a living power. Symbols reveal transcendent or religious realities that are otherwise inaccessible to the conscious mind.
While a sign stands for something known, a symbol points to something unknown and cannot be made clear or precise. This distinction was proposed by the Swiss psychoanalyst Carl Jung, who argued that symbols are essential for accessing the depths of the human psyche. In Jungian archetypes, a symbol like Christ serves as a representation of the archetype called the self, revealing hidden levels of meaning that are otherwise inaccessible to the conscious mind. Unlike signs, which are invented and can be forgotten, symbols are born and die, carrying a living power that reveals transcendent or religious realities. When a symbol becomes identified with the deeper reality to which it refers, it risks becoming idolatrous, as the symbol itself is taken for the reality it intends to convey. This dynamic is further explored by Kenneth Burke, who described humans as symbol-using, symbol-making, and symbol-misusing animals. Burke illustrated this with a story of a man who, upon learning that a food item was whale blubber, could barely keep from throwing it up, even though it was actually just a dumpling. The man's reaction was a direct consequence of the symbol of blubber representing something inedible in his mind, demonstrating how symbols are created through learning and can be misused to alter perception. Jean Dalby Clift expanded on this by suggesting that people create personal symbols, or core images, that represent their own understanding of their lives, which can be as useful in counseling as working with dream symbols.
The Three Faces of Value
Symbols carry value in three primary forms that shape how societies function and how individuals interact with the world. Ideological symbols, such as religious and state symbols, convey complex sets of beliefs and ideas that indicate the right thing to do, often serving as moral compasses for a community. Comparative symbols, including prestigious office addresses, fine art, and prominent awards, indicate answers to questions of better or worse and superior or inferior, establishing hierarchies within a culture. Isomorphic symbols blend in with the surrounding cultural environment, enabling individuals and organizations to conform to their surroundings and evade social and political scrutiny. Examples of isomorphic value include wearing a professional dress during business meetings, shaking hands to greet others in the West, or bowing to greet others in the East. A single symbol can carry multiple distinct meanings, providing multiple types of symbolic value simultaneously. This complexity allows symbols to evolve as the individual or culture evolves, changing their significance over time. When a symbol loses its meaning and power for an individual or culture, it becomes a dead symbol, no longer capable of revealing the hidden levels of meaning that once defined it. The history of a symbol is one of many factors in determining its apparent meaning, and symbols with emotive power often carry problems analogous to false etymologies, where the origin of the symbol is misunderstood or lost to time.
The Map and the Star
In the field of cartography, symbols form an organized collection known as a legend, allowing map users to read the world through a system of visual variables. These variables include size, shape, orientation, texture, and pattern, all of which provide meaning to the symbol. Map symbols are categorized by how they suggest a connection between a graphic mark on the map and a particular feature of the real world. Pictorial symbols appear as the real-world feature, often in a generalized manner, such as a tree icon representing a forest or green denoting vegetation. Functional symbols directly represent the activity that takes place at the represented feature, like a picture of a skier to represent a ski resort or a tent to represent a campground. Conceptual symbols directly represent a concept related to the represented feature, such as a dollar sign to represent an ATM or a Star of David to represent a Jewish synagogue. Conventional symbols do not have any intuitive relationship but are so commonly used that map readers eventually learn to recognize them, such as a red line to represent a highway or a cross to represent a hospital. Abstract or geometric symbols are arbitrary shapes chosen by the cartographer to represent a certain feature. The meaning of a symbol in this context may be modified by various factors including popular usage, history, and contextual intent. A similar five-pointed star might signify a law enforcement officer or a member of the armed services, depending upon the uniform, demonstrating how context can completely alter the interpretation of a visual mark.
The Action of the Symbol
A symbolic action is an action that symbolizes or signals what the actor wants or believes, conveying meaning to the viewers without the need for spoken words. These actions may overlap with symbolic speech, such as the use of flag burning to express hostility or saluting the flag to express patriotism. In response to intense public criticism, businesses, organizations, and governments may take symbolic actions rather than, or in addition to, directly addressing the identified problems. This phenomenon is often observed when a company releases a statement of support for a social cause without changing its underlying business practices, using the action to signal alignment with public sentiment. The study of these actions falls under the broader umbrella of semiotics, which focuses on the relationship of the signifier and the signified, taking into account the interpretation of visual cues, body language, sound, and other contextual clues. Semioticians study what a symbol implies, how it got its meaning, and how it functions to make meaning in society. For example, symbols can cause confusion in translation when the same symbol means different things in the source and target languages. A potential error documented in survey translation is the symbol of x used to denote yes when marking a response in the English language surveys, but x usually means no in the Chinese convention. This highlights the critical role of context in symbolism, where the same mark can carry opposing meanings depending on the cultural framework of the observer.