Scene (subculture)

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Scene subculture arrived in the United States in the early 2000s, born from the emo scene that had come before it, and within a few years it had taken over the wardrobes of teenagers across the country. At its peak, from the mid-2000s to the early 2010s, it was the defining youth movement of a generation raised on MySpace, Warped Tour, and straightening irons.

  What made someone "scene"? There was a look: skinny jeans, bright-colored clothing, hair dyed blond or pink or green or blue, ironed flat and swept in long bangs across the forehead. There were bands: Bring Me the Horizon, Asking Alexandria, Pierce the Veil, Metro Station. And there was an attitude built around pushing against the perceived rigidity of hardcore punk.

  By the mid-2010s the subculture had faded. Then, beginning in 2019, it started coming back. The questions worth asking are how a movement this specific got started, why it spread so fast, and what it left behind when the MySpace era ended.

• 2. Hardcore Roots

  ›

  During the 1990s, participants in the hardcore punk scene began pushing back against what they described as toxic masculinity in their genre. The result was a wave of androgynous fashion coming out of bands like AFI, Poison the Well, and American Nightmare. Those experiments planted seeds that would eventually grow into scene.

  Two distinct micro-movements fed directly into what came next. One was called sass, which developed from an early emo offshoot known as Spock rock. Sass pushed toward the flamboyant, drawing from gothic rock and post-punk fashion. Johnny Whitney, the lead vocalist of the Blood Brothers, was particularly cited as an influence on the emerging scene aesthetic. Sass occupied a brief cultural window where the terms "hipster" and "scene" were, by some accounts, actually synonymous.

  The other feeding stream was fashioncore, a style that originated with an Orange County metalcore band called Eighteen Visions. Fashioncore brought together eyeliner, tight jeans, collared shirts, straightened hair, and white belts. It mapped out much of the visual grammar scene would later adopt at a much larger scale.

• 3. The Haircut That Started It

  ›

  According to MetalSucks writer Finn McKenty, the quintessential scene haircut was invented by Eighteen Visions bassist Javier Van Huss. The origin story is specific: Van Huss was inspired by a poster of the band Orgy. Ryan Downey, writing in the book Louder Than Hell by Katherine Turman and John Wiederhorn, described Van Huss as someone who "really led the charge with crazy hairstyles and pink and blond and blue chunks in their hair."

  From that single musician's experimentation, a look spread across the country. Eighteen Visions, alongside Atreyu and Avenged Sevenfold, helped popularize the style in the early 2000s. Then came a 2003 tour by A Static Lullaby, which brought straightened hair and skinny jeans to Long Island's From Autumn to Ashes and New Jersey's Senses Fail.

  From Autumn to Ashes coined the word that would name the whole aesthetic. They printed "fashioncore" on merchandise. Critics immediately picked it up as a term of mockery. OC Weekly called it a subgenre of metalcore. Loudwire later argued that the label had been "coined as an insult to hardcore kids who started caring more about how they dyed their hair than the actual music." The term stuck anyway, even if the ridicule never quite landed.

  The name "scene" itself arrived around 2002 through the phrase "scene queen," which older hardcore musicians originally used as a derogatory label for young women they perceived as being involved in the subculture for social rather than musical reasons. It was the New Jersey scene that ultimately pushed the whole thing into mainstream visibility.

• 4. MySpace and Scene Queens

  ›

  MySpace gave the scene subculture something no previous youth movement had enjoyed: a real-time national distribution system for its aesthetic. Members of the subculture quickly moved onto the platform, and as MySpace's user base grew, so did the visibility of its most photogenic participants. These were the internet's first celebrities in anything like the modern sense, and they were called scene queens.

  Audrey Kitching, Jeffree Star, and the members of the Millionaires were among the most prominent. Their look traveled far and fast. Bands that built followings on MySpace went on to commercial success, though by 2011 the original platform-driven scene no longer existed in its peak form.

  The website also shaped the music. Cobra Starship vocalist Gabe Saporta was credited by PopMatters writer Ethan Stewart with helping introduce a sub-style that merged scene with brightly colored party fashion, drawing from rave culture and Harajuku street fashion. Other offshoots emerged around the fashion of 1980s glam metal, visible in acts like Black Veil Brides, Escape the Fate, and Falling in Reverse, a style attributed to Blessed by a Broken Heart.

  Loudwire later noted that many of the bands associated with this era were grouped together not by sound but by shared audience: the scene kids of MySpace, along with goers of Warped Tour and Mayhem Fest. Publications including Stereogum, Kerrang!, and Metal Hammer used the term "Myspace bands" to describe them.

• 5. Sound of the Subculture

  ›

  Scene music pulled from metalcore, crunkcore, deathcore, electronic music, and pop punk. Alternative Press described it as an "all-encompassing" genre focused on showcasing the creativity of artists who chose to break from the norm. By the mid-2000s, the scene variants of punk and its offshoots had become, per the same publication, the dominant forms of those styles.

  Invisible Oranges described the characteristic compositional approach: many scene bands ignored conventional song structure and instead blasted through different genres at what one writer called a neck-breaking pace. A song might move from pop punk to a breakdown to dubstep within a few minutes. Music journalist Eli Enis pointed out that the growing availability of tools like GarageBand made it easier for young musicians to experiment with layering, for example by tracking screams over a dance beat.

  Crunkcore was one of the most extreme results of this fusion tendency: it combined crunk, screamo, pop, and electronic music, typically featuring screamed vocals, hip hop beats, and sexually provocative lyrics. Brokencyde, Hollywood Undead, 3OH!3, and Millionaires were notable acts in the genre. A 2005 article in Phoenix New Times described Job for a Cowboy, another early deathcore group popular with scene kids, as a band that "may look like scenesters with shaggy emo haircuts and tight pants."

  Blood on the Dance Floor gained particular popularity after Jayy Von Monroe joined as lead singer in 2009. The Warped Tour, which had run annually since 1995, served as a main gathering point for scene-adjacent acts throughout the 2000s.

  Another characteristic that united many scene bands had nothing to do with sound: their song titles. Alternative Press observed that some of these titles could barely fit on the back covers of CDs. The precise origin of that trend is unknown.

• 6. Critics and Platinum Records

  ›

  Critical reception was harsh in a fairly consistent way. Michael Siebert of Invisible Oranges articulated the central complaint: "The lesson nu-metal should have taught aspiring young musicians is that the combination of disparate genres can be a tricky thing to balance. What scene music did, though, was go further in a different direction. Songs blast through different genres at a neck-breaking pace. One moment, it's pop punk. The next, a breakdown; then, suddenly, dubstep. It rarely ever works, which is why it's quite difficult to find an album from that era that was met with true critical acclaim."

  Crunkcore drew particular hostility. The Boston Phoenix described criticism of the style by noting that "the idea that a handful of kids would remix lowest-common-denominator screamo with crunk beats, misappropriated gangsterisms, and the extreme garishness of emo fashion was sure to incite hate-filled diatribes." Deathcore faced pushback from the heavy metal community specifically over its use of breakdowns.

  The commercial record told a different story. Numerous albums considered scene achieved platinum-selling status. Bring Me the Horizon, Asking Alexandria, Pierce the Veil, and Metro Station all garnered mainstream attention and large audiences while remaining tied to the subculture. In the Guardian, a scene participant named Eve O'Brien described scene people simply as "happy emos."

• 7. Decline, Echo, Revival

  ›

  By around 2014, the subculture's momentum had slowed. Its aesthetic influence migrated onto Tumblr, which developed its own generation of scene queens, including Halsey. Warped Tour ran its final show in 2019, ending a streak that stretched back to 1995.

  The late 2010s brought something unexpected: musicians who had started in scene bands broke into the mainstream on their own terms. Lil Lotus, Blackbear, Post Malone, Mod Sun, and Lil Aaron were among them. Emo rap, a genre shaped partly by the scene lineage, achieved mainstream success during this period.

  Similar subcultures had also emerged internationally during the late 2000s, including the Shamate in China, the Floggers in Argentina, the Coloridos of Brazil, and the Pokemón in Chile. Like American scene kids, these groups wore brightly colored clothing, androgynous big hair, and eyeliner, and identified with emo pop, indie rock, hip hop, and EDM.

  The formal revival began in 2019. The hashtag #20ninescene circulated that year, and the phrase "Rawring 20s" became associated with the 2020s wave. Platforms like SpaceHey and FriendProject, designed to retain the visual design of early MySpace, attracted new teenage users. Scene fashion reappeared on Instagram and TikTok. The subculture fed into the development of the e-girls and e-boys aesthetic, and into hyperpop as a genre. In 2022, the When We Were Young festival returned scene music to a live stage.