Revolutionary Government of the Republic of Indonesia

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Revolutionary Government of the Republic of Indonesia, known by its Indonesian initials PRRI, was proclaimed on the 15th of February 1958 in the city of Bukittinggi, Sumatra. Its first act was to demand that President Sukarno step back from politics and return to a purely constitutional role. What followed was one of the most violent internal conflicts in Indonesia's short life as an independent nation, a rebellion that drew in the CIA, the Soviet Union, and tens of thousands of soldiers on both sides.

  How did a handful of regional army commanders in the outer islands of Indonesia reach the point of declaring a rival government? What drove them to break with Jakarta so openly, when they had to have known their odds were slim? And what did the aftermath do to the people of Sumatra, especially the Minangkabau, long before the world took notice? Those questions run through every chapter of this story.

• 2. The Councils Rebel

  ›

  Lieutenant Colonel Ahmad Husein was the commander of the 4th regiment of the Territorial Army in Sumatra, and on the 20th of December 1956, he led his Banteng Council in taking over the local government of Central Sumatra. That same day, Colonel Maludin Simbolon, Supreme Commander of the Territorial Army in Sumatra, moved his Elephant Council to seize East Sumatra and cut all ties with Jakarta. Within weeks, Lieutenant Colonel Barlian's Garuda Council had done the same in South Sumatra, and Lieutenant Colonel Ventje Sumual had taken North Sulawesi for the Manguni Council.

  These were not hot-headed mutinies. They were the product of months of growing frustration. Army commanders in the outer islands felt that the Central Government in Jakarta was disconnected from ordinary Indonesian life, that economic development was faltering, and that their regions were being left behind. Some commands had already turned to covert smuggling of copra and contraband goods just to keep their units financially afloat, well before they made any political demands.

  Governor Roeslan, who had yielded his powers to Husein, tried to frame the takeover carefully. He said publicly that the Banteng Council and the people of Central Sumatra had no wish to build a state within a state, and that normal relations would return once a cabinet appeared that could eliminate the confusion, tension, and dissatisfaction threatening Indonesian security. The words were conciliatory in tone, but the action behind them was not.

• 3. An Ultimatum Expires

  ›

  By early 1958, the regional councils had moved from seizing local governments to issuing a direct challenge to Sukarno himself. On the 15th of February 1958, following the expiration of a five-day ultimatum, Lieutenant Colonel Ahmad Husein formally proclaimed the PRRI. The ultimatum had three demands: the Djuanda Cabinet must return its mandate, Mohammad Hatta and the Sultan of Yogyakarta, Hamengkubuwono IX, must form a new cabinet to serve until future elections, and Sukarno must return to his constitutional role.

  Jakarta's response was immediate and cold. Government officials dispatched to negotiate with the Banteng Council in Bukittinggi were detained, among them Minister of Agriculture Eny Karim. Cabinet positions in the new rebel government were quickly announced. Sjafruddin Prawiranegara was named both prime minister and finance minister. Maludin Simbolon took foreign affairs, Dahlan Djambek held defence and telecommunications jointly, and Sumitro Djojohadikusumo covered both communications and trade.

  Not everyone who had seemed sympathetic to regional grievances was willing to follow the PRRI into open rebellion. Lieutenant Colonel Barlian's Garuda Council, despite having seized South Sumatra the previous year, refused to join. Even within Husein's own Banteng Council, key leaders opposed the formal break. Without real popular traction on the ground, the PRRI found itself exposed almost immediately.

• 4. CIA and the Pope Incident

  ›

  The United States government, and specifically the CIA, covertly supported the PRRI from the start of the rebellion in 1958. That support was not unanimous inside the agency; Desmond Fitzgerald was among those who dissented. American officials had calculated that Indonesia might break apart and that a communist government was a likely outcome, and they preferred to back the rebels over Sukarno.

  The Indonesian central government, having approached Washington for arms and been refused, turned to the Soviet Union instead. Moscow agreed to supply weapons, allowing Indonesia to modernise its military into one of the strongest forces in Southeast Asia, a development that would later have direct consequences in the West New Guinea dispute.

  General Nasution, leading the central government's forces, launched surprise amphibious assaults on rebel cities in Sumatra during March 1958. The campaign moved fast. Government forces prevented PRRI fighters from destroying the Caltex oil fields and refinery at Pekanbaru, and the large quantity of US-made equipment the rebels abandoned in retreat made American involvement impossible to deny. The episode known as the Pope incident, on the 18th of May 1958, finished the CIA program. With the military balance swinging sharply toward Jakarta in the period from March to May 1958, and with Husein forced into guerrilla warfare in the jungle, there was no longer any plausible public path for Washington to recognise the PRRI. The United States shifted its backing to Sukarno.

• 5. Violence and Closure

  ›

  The military operations that Jakarta launched had names: Operation Tegas, Operation 17 Agustus, Operation Sadar. Their effects reached far beyond soldiers. As APRI forces, the central army, moved through West Sumatra, thousands of people suspected of sympathising with the PRRI were arrested without any formal process. Mass killings occurred in several locations. At the Jam Gadang clock tower, APRI soldiers shot around 187 people; only 17 of that number were PRRI fighters. The remaining dead were civilians, and their bodies were laid out in the tower's courtyard.

  From mid-April 1958 through 1960, all junior and senior high schools in the area were closed. Andalas University, which had been operating for only two years, shut down because nearly all its lecturers and students had joined the PRRI. By the end of 1960, APRI controlled the whole of West Sumatra.

  General Abdul Haris Nasution later counted 7,146 deaths across both sides of the conflict. Of those, 6,115 were recorded as dying on the PRRI side. Saafroedin Bahar observed that the toll from the PRRI conflict was greater than the casualties Indonesia had suffered fighting the Netherlands during the independence revolution.

  At the end of 1960, Nasution launched Operasi Pemanggilan Kembali, Operation Call Back, targeting internal rifts within the PRRI. Small surrenders began in April 1961. Ahmad Husein formally surrendered on the 29th of May 1961, accompanied by around 24,500 followers. The government issued amnesty under Presidential Decree No. 322 of 1961, dated the 22nd of June 1961. In practice, as the source notes, the amnesty was rhetoric; the PRRI's civilian and military leadership was quarantined for years. The last to surrender was Mohammad Natsir, on the 28th of September 1961.

• 6. The Minangkabau and Memory

  ›

  The Minangkabau people of Sumatra carried the defeat in ways that went beyond physical destruction. The PRRI conflict triggered a large exodus of Minangkabau from Sumatra to other parts of Indonesia, and those who stayed carried the stigma of having lived in rebel territory, despite the fact that the Minangkabau had a long history of resisting Dutch colonialism and that many of the leaders of Indonesian nationalism before independence had come from Sumatra.

  Harun Zaid, in an interview, put the human weight of the aftermath plainly. He said: "What had an impact on me was the sadness in the eyes of the students. In 1961, the faces were dull as if they did not have any future." That image of young people in 1961 with faces dull and futures seemingly closed off stands as the clearest single record of what the defeat cost at the level of ordinary life.

  The violence during and after the conflict, the humiliation of defeat, and the years of quarantine that followed combined to damage the self-esteem and dignity of the Minangkabau as a community. The psychological weight of that damage persisted long after Ahmad Husein's formal surrender and long after Mohammad Natsir walked out of the jungle in September 1961.