Presbyterianism

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Presbyterianism takes its name not from a creed or a charismatic founder, but from a word for an elder. Presbyter. The idea is almost startlingly democratic: that the congregation, not a bishop or a king, should govern itself through elected representatives assembled in councils. From that single structural premise, a tradition grew that today encompasses roughly 75 million people across every inhabited continent.

  The questions worth asking about Presbyterianism are not simple ones. Why did it catch fire in Scotland of all places, a kingdom of clans and Catholic monarchs? How did a theological argument about who governs a church end up triggering armed insurrection, reshaping the English Civil War, and surviving repeated attempts by Stuart kings to crush it? And how did a movement born in the cold parishes of 16th-century Scotland end up as the dominant Protestant tradition in South Korea, the largest denomination in the Pacific island nation of Vanuatu, and the faith of a former president of Taiwan?

• 2. Before the Reformation

  ›

  Saint Columba brought Christianity to Scotland through the Hiberno-Scottish mission of the 6th century, and the church that grew from that mission carried distinctly Celtic habits. The Culdees, monks who traced their apostolic line to Saint John, practiced a form of monasticism in which individual presbyters exercised authority within each institution, with no one institution commanding another. That structural independence echoed, centuries later, in Presbyterian polity.

  The Scottish church kept Easter on a date different from Rome and its monks wore a different style of tonsure. Those differences ended at the Synod of Whitby in 664, which ruled that Easter would be celebrated according to the Roman date, not the Celtic date. Roman practice eventually prevailed across Scotland. Yet certain Celtic strands persisted. The singing of metrical psalms set to old Celtic folk tunes remained a feature of Scottish worship and became, as the source notes, a distinctive part of Presbyterian practice long after the Reformation had arrived.

• 3. Geneva, Knox, and the Scottish Break

  ›

  John Calvin's Republic of Geneva was the theological engine of Presbyterianism. Calvin is credited with the development of what became known as Reformed theology, and it was in Geneva that the Scottish priest John Knox came to study under him directly. Knox returned to Scotland carrying those teachings, and what followed was not a quiet doctrinal debate.

  In August 1560, the Parliament of Scotland adopted the Scots Confession as the official creed of the Scottish kingdom. That December, Knox published the First Book of Discipline, which laid out not just doctrine but a blueprint for church governance: ten ecclesiastical districts with appointed superintendents that later became known as presbyteries. A Polish reformer named John a Lasco also shaped the early British movement; he founded a Stranger's Church in London modelled on Geneva's structures.

  Andrew Melville eventually organised the Church of Scotland along fully Presbyterian lines. Then King James VI began pushing the church back toward episcopal government, and his successor Charles I, alongside Archbishop of Canterbury William Laud, attempted in 1637 to force the Church of Scotland to use the Book of Common Prayer. What followed was armed insurrection. Scots signed the Solemn League and Covenant. The Covenanters governed Scotland for nearly a decade and sent military support to the Parliamentarians in the English Civil War from 1642 to 1651.

• 4. The Westminster Standards

  ›

  Between 1643 and 1649, the Westminster Assembly produced the set of documents that would define Presbyterian doctrine for centuries. The Westminster Confession of Faith, together with the larger and shorter catechisms, replaced the Scots Confession as the primary doctrinal standard. These texts are explicitly Calvinist in orientation.

  Different denominations handle those standards differently. The Presbyterian Church in Canada retains the Westminster Confession in its original form while acknowledging the historical period in which it was written. The Church of Scotland holds the Confession as its principal subordinate standard, but with a conscience clause allowing liberty of opinion in points that do not enter into the substance of the faith. The scholar William Robertson Smith was among those whose struggles of conscience shaped that clause's long history. The Free Church of Scotland, by contrast, has no such clause. The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) went further, adopting an entire Book of Confessions that adds ancient creeds such as the Nicene and Apostles' Creed, 16th-century Reformed confessions such as the Heidelberg Catechism, and 20th-century documents including the Theological Declaration of Barmen and the Confession of 1967. The theologian John Gresham Machen, who taught New Testament at Princeton Seminary from 1906 to 1929, argued in his 1923 book Christianity and Liberalism that theological modernism was not a reformed Christianity but a separate religion altogether.

• 5. How the Church Governs Itself

  ›

  A Presbyterian congregation elects ruling elders from its own members. Those elders, along with the teaching elder who serves as pastor, form the local session, which handles discipline, nurture, and mission. The congregation issues a call to a pastor, but that call must be ratified by the local presbytery rather than by the congregation alone.

  Above the session sits the presbytery, composed of teaching and ruling elders drawn from all the constituent congregations in a geographic area. The presbytery sends representatives to a broader assembly, generally called the General Assembly, though some denominations include an intermediate synod. The Church of Scotland abolished its synod in 1993. Bodies such as the Presbyterian Church in America and the Presbyterian Church in Ireland skip the synod step entirely. Since the 20th century, most Presbyterian denominations allow women to serve as teaching or ruling elders.

  Larger congregations often delegate the practical management of buildings, finances, and care for those in need to a separate group of officers, variously called deacons, a Deacon Board, a Diaconate, or a Deacons' Court. The Directory of Public Worship, produced by the Westminster Assembly in the 1640s and eventually enacted as law by the Parliament of Scotland, remains the foundational document for how Presbyterian denominations in Britain organize their services.

• 6. Splits, Reunions, and the Reach of Scots Emigration

  ›

  Scottish Presbyterians did not stay in Scotland. The Acts of Union of 1707 guaranteed the Church of Scotland's Presbyterian form of government, but domestic tensions kept producing splinters. In 1733, a group of ministers left to form the Associate Presbytery. Another group departed in 1761 as the Relief Church. The Disruption of 1843 produced the Free Church of Scotland. Most Scottish Presbyterians were eventually reunited in 1929 through a union of the established Church of Scotland and the United Free Church of Scotland. Scotland now has ten Presbyterian denominations and more than 1,500 congregations.

  Scots and Scots-Irish immigrants carried the tradition outward. In Colonial America, Presbyterianism officially arrived in 1644 with the establishment of Christ's First Presbyterian Church in what is now Hempstead, New York, organized by the Reverend Richard Denton. The first presbytery in Philadelphia was established in 1703, a synod formed by 1717, and by 1789 these bodies had evolved into the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America. Scots settlers brought Presbyterianism to Ulster after the plantation began in 1606; the Presbytery of Ulster was formed in 1642, and by 1659 there were nearly 80 presbyteries in the province. In Ireland, Presbyterianism is today the largest Protestant denomination in Northern Ireland and the second largest Protestant denomination on the island as a whole.

• 7. A Global Communion

  ›

  English Presbyterian missionary James Laidlaw Maxwell established the first Presbyterian church in Tainan, Taiwan, in 1865. His colleague George Leslie Mackay, arriving from the Canadian Presbyterian Mission in 1872, worked in the north of the island until 1901, founded the island's first university and hospital, and created a written script for Taiwanese Minnan. The Presbyterian Church in Taiwan grew rapidly during the decades of Kuomintang martial law from 1949 to 1987, partly because of its public support for democracy and human rights. Former ROC president Lee Teng-hui, who served from 1988 to 2000, was a Presbyterian.

  In South Korea, Presbyterian churches became the largest and most influential Protestant denominations in the country, with close to 20,000 churches affiliated with the two largest denominations alone, and 9 million Presbyterians among the nation's roughly 15 million Protestants. Welsh missionaries brought Presbyterianism to the Indian state of Mizoram in 1897, building their first church in Sohra, also known as Cherrapunji, in 1846. In Vanuatu, approximately one-third of the entire population belongs to the Presbyterian Church in Vanuatu, making it the largest denomination in the country. Scottish missionaries established the church in Africa in the 19th century; today it has a presence in at least 23 African countries, and the Presbyterian Church of East Africa, based in Kenya, counts 4 million members and 500 clergy.