Phantoms (film)

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Phantoms is a 1998 science fiction horror film with an unusually tangled history behind it. A producer named Joel Soisson read Dean Koontz's 1983 novel of the same name and spent the next ten years chasing the rights. That decade-long pursuit eventually brought the project to Miramax Films and its horror label Dimension Films, where it was produced alongside Japanese company Fuji Creative. The film that finally emerged starred Peter O'Toole, Rose McGowan, Joanna Going, Liev Schreiber, Ben Affleck, Nicky Katt, and Clifton Powell, and it landed in theaters in January 1998. How did a project with that kind of pedigree earn a single star from Roger Ebert? Why did production stretch across two years of reshoots? And what would the film come to mean, years later, when the name Harvey Weinstein became synonymous with abuse in Hollywood?

• 2. From Novel to Screen

  ›

  Dean Koontz wrote the original novel in 1983, and he personally adapted his own book for the screenplay. That direct involvement did not prevent the source material from changing in transit. Koontz's novel contained substantial literary references to the work of H. P. Lovecraft, but those references are largely absent from the finished film. The rights were first purchased by producer Steven Lane, who had previously worked on The Howling series. It was Soisson who took over the pursuit, and his persistence paid off when Dimension Films agreed to produce the picture in conjunction with Fuji Creative. Because of Fuji's involvement, the film's country of origin is sometimes listed as both the United States and Japan.

• 3. A Production Out of Time

  ›

  Principal photography took place on location in Georgetown, Colorado in late 1996. The Hotel de Paris Museum was pressed into service to stand in for both the bakery and the hotel where several key scenes were set. What should have been a clean post-production process stretched into something far messier. Over five separate sets of reshoots followed in 1997, and post-production was originally expected to wrap around mid-1997. Dimension and Miramax announced a theatrical release date of the 24th of October 1997, timed for Halloween. That date slipped to January 1998. By then, Ben Affleck had undergone cosmetic dental work for the film Armageddon, which shot in late 1997. In the reshoots for Phantoms that followed, his noticeably whiter teeth are visible alongside the older footage, a small visible record of the production's fractured timeline. Actress Joanna Going departed for New Zealand during the first half of 1997, spending three months shooting a separate Miramax film called Heaven, while Phantoms remained in post-production without her.

• 4. Harvey Weinstein and Sundance

  ›

  In 2017, Rose McGowan publicly claimed that Miramax boss Harvey Weinstein sexually assaulted her while she was at the Sundance Film Festival in January 1997. She had traveled to Sundance to promote Going All the Way, a non-Miramax film that also starred Ben Affleck. McGowan said that shortly after the assault, she did a photoshoot for Phantoms, and it was there that she told Affleck what had happened. She further claimed that Affleck responded by saying he had already told Weinstein to stop engaging in this behaviour. Affleck did not publicly respond to that allegation. In early 2018, Weinstein's lawyer Ben Brafman released an email that he claimed disproved the allegation, and the matter never reached court.

• 5. Opening Weekend and Critical Fate

  ›

  Phantoms opened theatrically on the 23rd of January 1998 in 1,859 theaters. Its opening weekend gross came to just over three million dollars, and the film's total theatrical earnings reached roughly five and three-quarter million dollars. The critical response was harsh. Roger Ebert awarded the film one star out of four, writing that if only audiences could learn to think more kindly of those who digest them, the movie could have ended happily. Godfrey Cheshire, writing for Variety, offered a more measured take, describing the film as perhaps most enthralling in its early sections, when the enemy is still unspecified and the horror remains purely psychological. Cheshire acknowledged that after the Army arrives and the visual chaos is unleashed, it becomes hard to track the characters or parse what the sound and fury are meant to signify, though he concluded that the film rights itself in time to deliver a satisfying ending.

• 6. Afterlife on Home Video

  ›

  Buena Vista Home Entertainment put Phantoms out on VHS on the 19th of August 1998, and released it on DVD in 1999; that DVD was reissued in 2001. The film's corporate parentage kept shifting. Disney sold off Dimension Films in 2005 and the main Miramax label in 2010. Private equity firm Filmyard Holdings then took over Miramax and the pre-October 2005 Dimension library, sublicensing home video rights for several titles to Echo Bridge Entertainment. Echo Bridge released the film on Blu-ray on the 1st of May 2012. Qatari company beIN Media Group acquired Miramax in March 2016. In April 2020, ViacomCBS, now known as Paramount Skydance, bought a 49% stake in Miramax, with beIN retaining the remaining 51%. That deal handed Paramount Pictures the rights to Miramax's film catalog, and Paramount made Phantoms available on its Paramount+ subscription service and its free streaming platform Pluto TV. Scream Factory eventually acquired sublicensed home video rights and released a collector's edition dual-format 4K UHD and Blu-ray set on the 16th of July 2024. Director Joe Chappelle himself approved the 4K scan taken from the original camera negative.

• 7. Jay, Silent Bob, and Cult Memory

  ›

  Phantoms found an unlikely second life in 2001 when Kevin Smith's Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back referenced it directly. That film was also released through Dimension and Miramax, and it featured Ben Affleck in a small role alongside several other meta-references to the studio and the film industry. The joke landed because Phantoms was recognizable enough to be worth mocking, and that recognition, more than the box office returns or the Ebert review, is what kept the film in circulation. The 4K restoration approved by Chappelle in 2024 suggests that the film still has an audience, one that has found it through streaming, through Scream Factory's collector releases, and through a quote in a Kevin Smith comedy from more than two decades ago.