— Ch. 1 · Background And Origins —
Nullification crisis.
~5 min read · Ch. 1 of 7
In 1787, the United States Constitution was written with a tension between state and federal power that would never fully resolve. The Kentucky Resolutions of 1791, drafted by Thomas Jefferson, argued that states could declare federal laws unconstitutional if they violated the compact theory. James Madison wrote the Virginia Resolutions in 1798 to counter this idea, asserting that only a national convention could judge constitutionality. These documents became the intellectual foundation for later disputes over sovereignty. By 1820, the nation had experienced financial panics and debates about internal improvements that kept the issue alive. The War of 1812 saw New England radicals propose constitutional amendments to limit federal power, though moderates ultimately rejected secession or nullification. Historian Richard E. Ellis noted that disagreements about the nature of the Union bubbled silently until they exploded again in the 1830s.
Tariffs And Economic Grievances
The Tariff of 1828, known as the Tariff of Abominations, imposed heavy taxes on raw materials like hemp, flax, molasses, iron, and sail duck. South Carolina's economy suffered as its population declined by 56,000 whites and 30,000 slaves during the 1820s. George McDuffie popularized the Forty Bale theory, claiming manufacturers plundered 40 out of every 100 bales produced. This argument struck a nerve despite being mathematically incorrect. Governor Robert Y. Hayne recruited a brigade of mounted minutemen numbering 2,000 strong. He also organized a volunteer army of 25,000 men who could march on foot to save Charleston. In the North, agents bought over $100,000 worth of arms for potential conflict. The tariff placed an unfair burden on agrarian states that imported most manufactured goods while protecting Northern industries.