Naomi Mitchison

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Naomi Mitchison was born in Edinburgh on the 1st of November 1897 and died at Carradale on the 11th of January 1999 at the age of 101. In that century-spanning life she wrote more than 90 books, stood as a parliamentary candidate, smuggled refugees out of fascist Austria, became a tribal mother in Botswana, and once listed her hobby in Who's Who as "burning rubbish." When asked on her 90th birthday whether she had regrets, she replied: "Yes, all the men I never slept with. Imagine!" That answer tells you something about the spirit of the woman. Her most celebrated novel, The Corn King and the Spring Queen, published in 1931, has been called a lost classic by writer Terri Windling. Her most censored work, We Have Been Warned, nearly earned its publishers a government prosecution. How did one writer manage to range so broadly across science fiction, historical fiction, radical politics, African advocacy, and feminist campaigning? And what does it mean that someone so prolific and so consequential is only dimly remembered today?

• 2. A Family of Experiments

  ›

  John Scott Haldane, a physiologist of some renown, was Naomi's father, and the household he ran was not a conventional one. The Haldane family had held feudal claims to Gleneagles since the 13th century, yet the family's defining trait was a compulsion to test things. In 1908, when Naomi was ten years old, she and her brother John began investigating Mendelian genetics in the kitchen, using guinea pigs and later mice. Their findings, published as "Reduplication in Mice" in 1915, turned out to be the first demonstration of genetic linkage in mammals. That brother, J. B. S. Haldane, would go on to become a celebrated biologist in his own right, living from 1892 to 1964. Their paternal uncle, Richard Burdon Haldane, 1st Viscount Haldane, served as Lord Chancellor twice: from 1912 to 1915 under H. H. Asquith, and again in 1924 during Ramsay MacDonald's first Labour government. Against this backdrop of scientific inquiry and political connection, Naomi entered the Oxford Preparatory School in 1904 as its only girl, then qualified for Oxford in 1914. The First World War redirected her: she joined a Voluntary Aid Detachment at St Thomas's Hospital in London in 1915, though her service was curtailed by scarlet fever. The experiments of childhood, it turned out, were only the beginning.

• 3. Daring on the Page

  ›

  The Conquered, Mitchison's first novel, appeared in 1923 and was set in Gaul during the Gallic Wars of Julius Caesar. Her second, Cloud Cuckoo Land, published in 1925, moved to ancient Greece during the Peloponnesian War. By the time she published The Corn King and the Spring Queen in 1931, literary critic Geoffrey Sadler would judge her "unquestionably one of the great historical novelists" based on those early works. That 1931 novel explored sexuality across three societies, including a wholly invented one, in ways that were genuinely daring for the period. Her most controversial book, We Have Been Warned, came out in 1935, growing from a journey to the Soviet Union. Her friend Victor Gollancz, who had commissioned earlier work from her, turned the manuscript down flat, warning that "publication of the book would cause a real outcry." The book was extensively rewritten and still faced censorship. On publication it was condemned across the political spectrum: it alienated readers on the left and horrified those on the right with its treatment of rape, free love, and abortion. Files released from the National Archives in 2005 showed that the British government had considered prosecuting its publishers. That it was published at all was its own small victory. Maxim Lieber served as her literary editor in 1935, the same year the book finally appeared.

• 4. Politics and Personal Risk

  ›

  Mitchison travelled to the Soviet Union in 1932 as part of a Fabian Society group, expressing some misgivings about where that society was heading. Her commitment to anti-fascism took a more concrete form when she went to Austria and smuggled documents and left-wing refugees out of the country, a mission that carried genuine physical risk. She stood as a Labour Party candidate for the Scottish Universities in 1935, at a time when universities could still elect their own Members of Parliament; she was unsuccessful. By the 1940s she had grown disenchanted with the Left, drawn instead toward Scottish Nationalism. She supported the Scottish National Party candidate William Power in the 1940 parliamentary by-election for the Argyllshire constituency. She later joined the Scottish Convention launched by John MacCormick in 1943, serving on its education committee. In March 1949, George Orwell compiled a list for the Information Research Department at the Foreign Office naming people considered to have pro-communist leanings and therefore unsuitable to write for that body; Mitchison's name was on it. Her 1938 book The Moral Basis of Politics, which she had worked on for three years, defended the right of journalist H. N. Brailsford to criticise the Moscow Trials, a stance that was divisive on the British left. Her novel The Blood of the Martyrs, published in 1939, set the persecution of Christians under Nero as a deliberate parallel to the dictatorships of Mussolini and Hitler.

• 5. Marriage, Family, Open Life

  ›

  On the 11th of February 1916, Naomi married Gilbert Richard Mitchison, known as Dick, a barrister she described as a close friend of her brother. He had come to the marriage on leave from the Western Front. He later became a Queen's Counsel, then a Labour politician, and on the 5th of October 1964 received a life peerage as Baron Mitchison of Carradale. Naomi, now technically Lady Mitchison, refused to use the title. After some years the couple agreed to an open marriage, conducting their other relationships, as the source notes, with dignity. Naomi's first serious lover was the Oxford classicist Theodore Wade-Gery, whose scholarship fed directly into her historical novels. She fell deeply in love with him, wrote him love poems, and was devastated when he ended the affair in 1928, judging it incompatible with his own marriage. She channelled that grief into the Austrian refugee smuggling mission. Together, Naomi and Dick had seven children. Geoffrey, born in 1918, died of meningitis in 1927. Denis, born in 1919 and a professor of bacteriology, lived until 2018. Murdoch and Avrion were both professors of zoology; their daughter Clemency died shortly after her birth in 1940. The family moved to Carradale House in Kintyre in 1939, and the house became a gathering point for politicians, writers, lords, fishermen, and farmers alike.

• 6. Africa, Advocacy, and Everyday Governance

  ›

  Mitchison's relationship with Botswana was unlike anything else in her biography. She visited Africa frequently and was named a sort of tribal mother, Mmarona, by the baKgatla people. She was also a personal friend of Seretse Khama and served as an advisor to the Bakgatla tribe. That connection ran alongside a parallel life of local governance in Scotland. She served as a councillor for the East Kintyre ward on Argyll County Council from 1945 to 1966. She sat on the Highland Panel from 1947 to 1965 and on the Highlands and Islands Development Consultative Council from 1966 to 1976. She initiated a council scheme under which money was set aside to buy paintings by contemporary Scottish artists and loan them to schools; works by Joan Eardley, Robin Philipson, Anne Redpath, and William MacTaggart were acquired this way. On the 16th of December 1969 she attended a Stop the Seventy Tour rally aimed at halting the apartheid South African rugby and cricket tours of Britain. She had been a founding council member of the North Kensington Women's Welfare Centre in London in 1924, and had been elected a Life Fellow of the Eugenics Society in 1925 before resigning in objection to its politics. Her correspondence with her aunt Elizabeth Haldane, the first female Justice of the Peace in Scotland, continued until Elizabeth's death in 1937; the two women often disagreed about the limits that should be placed on women's lives.

• 7. A Century of Writing

  ›

  James Watson wrote much of The Double Helix while staying with the Mitchisons, and dedicated the book to Naomi. That detail places her at the centre of one of the most famous scientific narratives of the 20th century, though it goes largely unmentioned in accounts of Watson's work. Her friendship with J. R. R. Tolkien was equally unexpected: she was one of the proof readers of The Lord of the Rings. She and a local fisherman named Denis MacIntosh wrote a documentary together in 1949 called Men and Herring, later adapted for BBC Television as a docudrama titled Spindrift. Mitchison often said she was unsure exactly how many books she had written, typically claiming around 70, though the true number exceeded 90. Her 1932 book An Outline for Boys and Girls and Their Parents, commissioned by Victor Gollancz, drew contributors including W. H. Auden, Richard Hughes, Gerald Heard, and Olaf Stapledon. It was praised by the Times Literary Supplement, the New Statesman, and the London Mercury, but attacked by the Archbishop of York for its lack of Christian emphasis and by the conservative writer Arnold Lunn in a lengthy piece in the English Review; that attack contributed to its commercial failure. Dick Mitchison died in 1970, and Naomi outlived him by nearly three decades, remaining active as a writer well into her nineties. She was appointed Commander of the Order of the British Empire in the 1985 New Year Honours. She died at Carradale on the 11th of January 1999 and was cremated at the Clydebank crematorium five days later, on the 16th of January.