— Ch. 1 · Defining The Paradox —
Moravec's paradox.
~4 min read · Ch. 1 of 5
Hans Moravec wrote in 1988 that it is comparatively easy to make computers exhibit adult level performance on intelligence tests or playing checkers. He noted the difficulty lies in giving them the skills of a one-year-old when it comes to perception and mobility. This observation flipped the expected hierarchy of artificial intelligence challenges. Researchers assumed high-level reasoning was the hardest task to automate. They believed low-level sensorimotor skills like walking would be simple to program. The reality proved the opposite pattern. Skills that appear effortless to humans required millions of years of evolution to develop. Abstract reasoning abilities like mathematics are evolutionarily recent additions to the human brain. Steven Pinker summarized this lesson in 1994 by stating hard problems are easy and easy problems are hard. Allen Newell called the idea a myth in an 1983 chapter on AI history. He argued that automation of higher reasoning functions was not relatively easy compared to animal kingdom functions.
Evolutionary Explanations
All human skills are implemented biologically using machinery designed by natural selection. Natural selection has tended to preserve design improvements over vast periods of time. The older a skill is, the more time nature had to refine its design. Abstract thought developed only very recently in evolutionary history. Consequently, we should not expect its implementation to be particularly efficient. Moravec wrote that the difficulty of reverse-engineering any human skill is roughly proportional to the amount of time that skill has been evolving in animals. The oldest human skills are largely unconscious and so appear to us to be effortless. Recognizing a face takes no conscious effort yet requires complex biological processing. Moving around in space or catching a ball involves intricate coordination systems built over millennia. Mathematics and logic appeared only within historical time with at most a few thousand years of refinement. These newer skills were acquired through cultural evolution rather than deep biological adaptation. We are least aware of what our minds do best according to Marvin Minsky. We are more aware of simple processes that don't work well than of complex ones that work flawlessly.Early AI History