Mining pool
In November 2010, a service named Slush launched and became the first mining pool in history. Before this moment, individual miners faced an impossible reality where finding a block could take centuries if their processing power was too slow. The difficulty of the network had risen to a point that made solo success statistically improbable for most participants. Ittay Eyal and Emin Gün Sirer later documented how this vulnerability allowed majority control to threaten the system in papers published during the 18th International Conference on Financial Cryptography and Data Security in 2014. Miners needed a way to generate blocks more quickly so they could receive portions of the reward consistently rather than waiting randomly for years. Pooling resources solved this problem by combining processing power over a shared network.
From 2011 through 2013, the operator Deepbit held up to 45% of the total network hashrate at its peak. This dominance shifted when Deepbit failed to support the newer stratum protocol after the introduction of ASIC hardware in 2013. GHash.IO replaced Deepbit as the largest pool during the period between 2013 and 2014. F2Pool launched in May 2013 and eventually overtook GHash IO to become the new leader. Bitmain rose to prominence between 2016 and 2018 with its AntPool operation while controlling smaller pools like BTC.com and ViaBTC. By 2019 and 2020, Poolin emerged alongside F2Pool, each holding about 15% of the network hashrate. Binance launched its own mining pool in 2020 following competitors Huobi and OKex. Luxor also entered the market that same year as a US-based option.
Pay-per-Share offers an instant guaranteed payout to miners for their contribution to the probability of finding a block. Miners withdraw funds immediately from the pool's existing balance without waiting for a round to complete. Each share costs exactly the expected value of every hash attempt made by the worker. Proportional systems differ because miners earn shares until the pool finds a block which marks the end of the mining round. Afterward each user receives a reward calculated by dividing their personal share count against all shares submitted during that round. Slush's system assigns less weight to older shares from the beginning of a block round compared to more recent submissions. Pay-per-last-N-shares calculates rewards based on the last N pool shares instead of all shares for the entire round.
Peer-to-peer mining pools decentralize responsibilities away from a central server to remove single points of failure. Miners work together on a side blockchain called a share chain where they mine at one share block per 30 seconds. Once a share block reaches the network target it gets transmitted and merged onto the main blockchain. A P2Pool requires miners to run full nodes bearing significant hardware expenses and network bandwidth requirements. This architecture eliminates the chance of the pool operator cheating or the server failing completely. Meni Rosenfeld invented the Geometric Method which ensures no advantage exists to mining early versus late in any given round. The method sets parameters so that scores granted for new shares remain constant relative to existing and future shares.
Multipools switch between different altcoins constantly calculating which coin offers maximum profitability at that exact moment. Two key factors drive this algorithm: block time and current price on exchanges. Companies like NiceHash aggregate work from many small miners paying them proportionally by share similar to traditional pools. These entities may operate their own pools but determine assigned work based on customer demand rather than raw market profitability. Multipools automatically exchange mined coins into mainstream currencies like bitcoin to avoid needing multiple wallets. This process increases demand for the intended coin potentially stabilizing its value over time. Some PoC chains such as Chia and Flax emerged after 2014 offering environmentally friendly alternatives requiring minimal energy consumption compared to Proof of Work systems.
Up Next
Continue Browsing
Common questions
When did the first mining pool named Slush launch?
Slush launched in November 2010 and became the first mining pool in history. This event occurred before individual miners faced an impossible reality where finding a block could take centuries if their processing power was too slow.
Which mining pools held the largest network hashrate between 2013 and 2014?
GHash.IO replaced Deepbit as the largest pool during the period between 2013 and 2014. F2Pool launched in May 2013 and eventually overtook GHash IO to become the new leader.
How do mining pools use shares to calculate miner rewards?
Mining pools use these shares to estimate exactly how much work each miner contributed toward finding a block. The probability of finding a block in any single share attempt depends on current block difficulty.
What is the difference between Pay-per-Share and Proportional systems for miners?
Pay-per-Share offers an instant guaranteed payout to miners for their contribution to the probability of finding a block. Proportional systems differ because miners earn shares until the pool finds a block which marks the end of the mining round.
Who invented the Geometric Method used in Peer-to-peer mining pools?
Meni Rosenfeld invented the Geometric Method which ensures no advantage exists to mining early versus late in any given round. The method sets parameters so that scores granted for new shares remain constant relative to existing and future shares.
All sources
13 references cited across the entry
- 1webMajority is not Enough: Bitcoin Mining is VulnerableIttay Eyal
- 2webThe Miner's DilemmaIttay Eyal — Cornell University
- 3journalVisual Analytics of Bitcoin Mining Pool Evolution: On the Road Toward Stability?N. Tovanich et al. — 2020
- 4webHashrate Flows: 2020 from the Crypto Miner's Perspective2020-12-31
- 6webFoundry USA Becomes the Largest Bitcoin Mining Pool2021-10-13
- 7bookMastering Bitcoin. Unlocking Digital CryptocurrenciesAntonopoulos, Andreas M. — O'Reilly Media — 2014
- 8bookUnderstanding bitcoin : cryptography, engineering and economicsFranco Pedro. — John Wiley & Sons — 2015
- 9bookMastering Bitcoin: Programming the Open BlockchainAndreas Antonopoulos — O' Reilly Media — 2017
- 10bookAnalysis of Bitcoin Pooled Mining Reward SystemsMeni Rosenfeld — November 17, 2011
- 11bookMastering Bitcoin: Programming the Open BlockchainAndreas Antonopoulos — O'Reilly Media — 2017
- 12webMempool explorer launches service to expedite unconfirmed bitcoin transactions via five mining poolsAdam Rawlings — 2024-07-29