Mathew Brady

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Mathew Brady once placed an advertisement in a New York newspaper that read, simply, "You cannot tell how soon it may be too late." He was selling portraits to parents of young soldiers heading off to the Civil War. But those words, in hindsight, describe Brady's entire life's work: a race against time to capture faces and moments before they vanished forever.

  Brady was born around 1822 in Warren County, New York, the youngest child of Irish immigrant parents. He started out manufacturing leather cases to hold daguerreotype images. He ended his life in the charity ward of Presbyterian Hospital, penniless, his eyesight gone, his fortune spent on a war that the country would rather forget. In between, he photographed eighteen of the first nineteen American presidents, walked onto battlefields under direct fire, and produced a visual record of the Civil War so vast that it now fills the National Archives and the Library of Congress.

  How does a man who reshaped how an entire nation understood war die broke? And who actually pressed the shutter on most of those famous photographs?

• 2. From Leather Cases to Portraits

  ›

  William Page, a portrait painter in Saratoga, New York, was the first person to redirect Brady's life. Brady met Page at around age sixteen, became his student, and traveled with him first to Albany and then to New York City in 1839. There Brady also studied under Samuel Morse, who had just returned from France after meeting Louis Jacques Daguerre and was pushing the daguerreotype with genuine excitement across America.

  Brady's first role in photography was practical and unglamorous: he made the leather cases that held the fragile daguerreotype plates. But Morse opened a studio and offered classes, and Brady was among the earliest students to enroll. The jump from craftsman to artist took only a few years.

  In 1844, Brady opened his own studio at the corner of Broadway and Fulton Street in New York. Within a year he was exhibiting portraits of Senator Daniel Webster and writer Edgar Allan Poe. By 1849, he had expanded south, opening a studio at 625 Pennsylvania Avenue in Washington, D.C. There he met Juliet Handy, known to everyone as Julia, and married her in 1850.

  His early portraits were daguerreotypes, and they won awards. His 1850 publication, The Gallery of Illustrious Americans, featured portraits of prominent figures, including an image of the elderly Andrew Jackson at the Hermitage. The album did not sell well, but it sharpened the public's awareness of Brady as a serious artist. By 1856, Brady was advertising in the New York Herald, and the ad itself was notable: it used typeface and fonts that stood apart from the rest of the publication, a first in American advertising.

• 3. Documenting the Civil War

  ›

  Lincoln granted Brady permission in 1861 to photograph the war, but with one firm condition: Brady would have to pay for the project himself. Brady agreed, and what followed was one of the most ambitious and costly private documentary projects in American history.

  He hired a team of photographers including Alexander Gardner, James Gardner, Timothy H. O'Sullivan, William Pywell, George N. Barnard, Thomas C. Roche, and seventeen other men. Each was equipped with a traveling darkroom. Brady himself largely stayed in Washington, coordinating assignments and rarely visiting the front. His deteriorating eyesight, which had begun to worsen in the 1850s, was at least one reason he directed rather than shot.

  The exception was Bull Run. Brady got close enough to the action at the First Battle of Bull Run that he nearly got captured. He also came under direct fire at Petersburg and Fredericksburg. He later recalled that impulse simply: "I had to go. A spirit in my feet said 'Go,' and I went."

  The photographic technology of the era imposed a hard constraint. Equipment required subjects to remain still, so actual combat could not be photographed. What Brady's team did capture were the aftermath scenes: encampments, officers' portraits, supply lines, and the dead.

  On the 19th of September, 1862, two days after the Battle of Antietam, the bloodiest single day of combat on American soil with more than twenty-three thousand killed, wounded, or missing, Brady dispatched Alexander Gardner and James Gibson to photograph the carnage. In October 1862, Brady opened the exhibition titled The Dead of Antietam at his New York City gallery. The New York Times published a review. For many Americans, it was the first time they had seen photographs of corpses from a battlefield rather than painted depictions.

• 4. Credit and Its Complications

  ›

  Every image produced in Brady's gallery carried the label "Photo by Brady," whether Brady had taken it or not. Author Roy Meredith, writing about Brady, offered a defense: the selection of what to photograph was itself a creative act, as important as pressing the shutter. Brady, in Meredith's reading, was the director.

  Brady dealt directly only with the most distinguished subjects. Most portrait sessions were run by his assistants. Many images in his collection are now believed to be the work of those assistants, not Brady himself. Brady was criticized during his lifetime for failing to document who had actually taken individual photographs. Whether that omission was deliberate or simply a matter of indifference is not settled.

  The practice of labeling everything "Photo by Brady" regardless of who operated the camera is now considered by some to be a pioneer form of what would later be called a corporate credit line. Brady is also credited with being the father of photojournalism, a recognition that accounts for his role as organizer and publisher of an enormous body of work, even when others pressed the shutter.

  Alexander Gardner, who shot the Antietam photographs and many other significant images, eventually left Brady's employment. Gardner went on to photograph Lincoln's second inauguration and the execution of the conspirators in the Lincoln assassination. The separation meant that some of the most historically significant photographs associated with Brady's operation were made by a man who had departed.

• 5. Bankruptcy and a Broken Promise

  ›

  Brady spent over $100,000 financing the Civil War photography project, a sum equivalent to roughly two million dollars in 2025. He expected the federal government to purchase the plates when the war ended. Congress's Joint Committee on the Library recommended the purchase. The government declined anyway.

  With no buyer and no revenue from a public that had grown weary of the war's imagery, Brady was forced to sell his New York City studio. He filed for bankruptcy. His own glass plate negatives passed in the 1870s to E. & H. T. Anthony & Company of New York, transferred in default of payment for photographic supplies. The plates were described as having been "kicked about from pillar to post" for ten years until a man named John C. Taylor found them in an attic and bought them.

  Congress eventually granted Brady $25,000 in 1875, but it was not enough to clear his debts. His wife Julia died in 1887, deepening a depression that had already taken hold. Brady died on the 15th of January, 1896, in the charity ward of Presbyterian Hospital in New York City. The cause was complications from a streetcar accident. His funeral expenses were covered by veterans of the 7th New York Infantry. He was buried in Congressional Cemetery in Washington, D.C.

  The negatives he had lost to debt found their way across several more owners before Edward Bailey Eaton recognized their importance and set in motion events that produced a landmark 1912 publication: The Photographic History of the Civil War.

• 6. Legacy and Lost Images

  ›

  Brady photographed eighteen of the first nineteen American presidents, from John Quincy Adams through William McKinley. The one exception was William Henry Harrison, the ninth president, who died in office three years before Brady had even started his photographic collection. Brady photographed Abraham Lincoln on many occasions, and those images proved enduringly useful: his Lincoln photographs served as the basis for the portrait on the five-dollar bill, the Lincoln cent, and a model for the National Bank Note Company's engraving on the ninety-cent Lincoln Postage issue of 1869.

  In 1968, Brady became one of the first two Americans inducted into the International Photography Hall of Fame and Museum.

  The fate of the negatives themselves became its own story. Ken Burns, in the final episode of his 1990 documentary series The Civil War, claimed that glass plate negatives were sold to gardeners who used the glass in greenhouses and cold frames, with the sun slowly burning away the images. Civil War photography historian Bob Zeller has disputed this account, calling it likely a myth.

  Zeller raised a separate point that most Civil War photography histories overlook entirely: the majority of these photographs were originally taken in three dimensions, produced as stereoscopic side-by-side images. His book The Civil War in Depth reproduces many of them as they were designed to be seen. A photograph of Brady himself, wearing a straw hat, appears on page twelve of that book as a stereoscopic image. The Brady stand, a heavy specialized end table with a cast iron base and adjustable column used by portrait photographers across the mid-nineteenth century, carries his name, though no proven connection exists between Brady and its invention around 1855.