Skip to content
— CH. 1 · THE JANUARY THAW —

Lincoln (film)

~5 min read · Ch. 1 of 6
6 sections
  • In the freezing air of January 1865, President Abraham Lincoln stands in a dimly lit room within the White House. He stares at a map of Virginia while his wife Mary Todd Lincoln paces nearby with visible anxiety. The war is nearing its end, yet Lincoln fears the courts will discard his Emancipation Proclamation once fighting stops. He knows that without a constitutional amendment, freed slaves could be re-enslaved by returning southern states. His political opponents include Radical Republicans who fear the amendment might fail if they wait for new elections. Some advisors suggest waiting until after the spring thaw when military operations resume and peace negotiations begin. Lincoln authorizes Francis Preston Blair to engage Confederate leaders in secret talks despite knowing this angers his allies. The President must balance these dangerous diplomatic efforts against the urgent need to pass the Thirteenth Amendment before Congress votes.

  • DreamWorks Pictures finalized film rights to Team of Rivals in 2001 after Spielberg heard Doris Kearns Goodwin discuss her biography project. John Logan wrote an initial draft focusing on Lincoln's friendship with Frederick Douglass during that early development phase. Playwright Paul Webb later rewrote the script before filming was scheduled to start in January 2006. Spielberg delayed production due to dissatisfaction with Webb's version which covered the entire presidential term rather than specific months. Tony Kushner replaced Webb as screenwriter and found the assignment daunting because he did not understand what made Lincoln great. Kushner noted Lincoln rarely quoted the New Testament even though he was Christian. By late 2008, Kushner joked about writing his 967,000th book about Abraham Lincoln while working on the screenplay. His first draft spanned four months but was rewritten by February 2009 to focus on just two months of political maneuvering. Spielberg arranged a fifty million dollar budget to placate Paramount Pictures who had previously delayed the project over concerns it resembled Amistad. DreamWorks eventually dropped out and Disney acquired distribution rights while Fox agreed to co-finance half the film alongside Participant Media.

  • Spielberg approached Daniel Day-Lewis about playing Lincoln in 2003 but received an immediate rejection from the actor. Liam Neeson was cast as Lincoln in January 2005 after working together on Schindler's List years earlier. Neeson studied Lincoln extensively during preparation for the role before leaving the project in July 2010. He stated that at age fifty-eight he felt too old to portray a man who was only fifty-five or fifty-six during the depicted period. An interview with GQ revealed Neeson experienced a thunderbolt moment during a table read where he realized the part did not suit him. Co-star Sally Field suggested Neeson's decision may have been influenced by the death of his wife Natasha Richardson less than a year prior. Neeson subsequently recommended Day-Lewis to Spielberg after dropping out. Both Neeson and Leonardo DiCaprio spoke to Day-Lewis to convince him to accept the challenging role. The actor finally agreed to take on the part in November 2010 replacing Neeson after months of hesitation.

  • Filming began the 17th of October 2011 and concluded the 19th of December 2011 across multiple locations in Virginia. Production teams scouted Taunton and Dighton Massachusetts in early 2009 before settling on Richmond Fredericksburg and Petersburg. Location manager Colleen Gibbons noted that one thing attracting filmmakers to Petersburg was the rare 180-degree vista of historic structures available there. The Virginia State Capitol building served as both exterior and interior shots for the United States Capitol. Scenes representing Grover's Theatre were filmed at Virginia Repertory Theatre's November Theatre in Richmond. The House of Delegates inside the state capitol was remodeled to fit the House of Representatives chamber set design requirements. Spielberg wanted to honor the two hundredth anniversary of Lincoln's birth by releasing the film in late 2012. The production utilized existing architecture rather than constructing massive new sets throughout the filming process which lasted only six weeks.

  • Lincoln grossed over two hundred seventy-five million dollars worldwide against a budget of sixty-five million dollars. The film opened in eleven theaters with an average of eighty-five thousand eight hundred forty-six dollars per theater during its limited release. It later expanded to one thousand one hundred seventy-five theaters generating twenty-one million dollars on opening weekend. Rotten Tomatoes reported an approval rating of eighty-nine percent based on two hundred eighty-eight reviews with an average score of eight out of ten. Metacritic gave the film a weighted average score of eighty-seven out of one hundred indicating universal acclaim from critics. Roger Ebert awarded four stars while Glenn Kenny gave five stars praising the performance and direction. A. O. Scott called it a rough and noble democratic masterpiece that examined how difficult it has been for the United States to recognize full humanity for black people. The film received seven Golden Globe nominations including Best Motion Picture Drama and won Best Actor for Daniel Day-Lewis. At the eighty-fifth Academy Awards it received twelve nominations winning Best Production Design and Best Actor for Day-Lewis his third win in that category.

  • Eric Foner claimed the film grossly exaggerates the possibility that slavery might have remained intact by January 1865 if the war ended. Kate Masur dismissed the effort as an opportunity squandered regarding the role of blacks in abolition movements. Harold Holzer served as consultant but observed there is no shortage of small historical bloopers in the movie. He noted it was almost inconceivable any uniformed soldier would memorize a speech that did not achieve national reputation until the twentieth century. Allen Guelzo disagreed with Holzer stating the pains taken for historical authenticity were worth hailing on their own terms. Guelzo later claimed the film was ninety percent accurate given how Hollywood usually handles history. Editor Rhoda Sneller referenced a diary entry from Secretary of the Navy Gideon Welles which conflicts with final scenes showing Lincoln dressed in a nightgown. Welles wrote the giant sufferer lay extended diagonally across the bed having been stripped of clothes. The differences between first-hand accounts and the present Lincoln serve to paint a more concise and dignified image of the president's death despite these discrepancies.

Common questions

When was the Lincoln film released to honor the two hundredth anniversary of Abraham Lincoln's birth?

The Lincoln film was released in late 2012. This timing honored the two hundredth anniversary of Abraham Lincoln's birth.

Who replaced Daniel Day-Lewis as the actor playing President Lincoln before he finally accepted the role in November 2010?

Liam Neeson played President Lincoln from January 2005 until July 2010. He left the project because he felt too old at age fifty-eight to portray a man who was only fifty-five or fifty-six during the depicted period.

Where did filming for the Lincoln movie take place between October and December 2011?

Filming occurred across multiple locations in Virginia including Richmond Fredericksburg and Petersburg. Production teams also scouted Taunton and Dighton Massachusetts in early 2009 before settling on the final sites.

How much money did the Lincoln film earn worldwide against its production budget?

The Lincoln film grossed over two hundred seventy-five million dollars worldwide. It was made with a budget of sixty-five million dollars.

Which historical figure claimed the Lincoln film exaggerated the possibility that slavery might have remained intact by January 1865?

Eric Foner claimed the film grossly exaggerates the possibility that slavery might have remained intact if the war ended. He argued this point regarding the timeline of events in January 1865.

All sources

93 references cited across the entry

  1. 1magazineLincoln: ReviewPeter Debruge — November 1, 2012
  2. 2webAFI Catalog: Lincoln (2012)American Film Institute
  3. 4webLincoln (12A)British Board of Film Classification — December 13, 2012
  4. 6webLincoln (2012)Box Office Mojo
  5. 7magazineSteven Spielberg's 'Lincoln' gets its Mary Todd: Sally FieldAnthony Breznican — April 13, 2011
  6. 8magazineParticipant Media Boarding Steven Spielberg's 'Lincoln' (Exclusive)Pamela McClintock — October 12, 2011
  7. 10webLincoln (2012)British Film Institute
  8. 11webDaniel Day-Lewis to Star in Steven Spielberg's LincolnRuss Fischer — November 19, 2010
  9. 13webFox Partnering with DreamWorks on Steven Spielberg's 'Lincoln'Pamela McClintock — DreamWorks Pictures — January 23, 2012
  10. 16newsThe 100 best films of the 21st centuryPeter Bradshaw et al. — September 13, 2019
  11. 17webDaniel Day-Lewis to Star in Steven Spielberg's LincolnFischer, Russ — November 19, 2010
  12. 19webDavid Strathairn Joins DreamWorks' 'Lincoln'Joshua L. Weinstein — June 27, 2011
  13. 21webSteven Spielberg's Lincoln Announces Additional CastingBrian Scott Lipton — TheaterMania.com — November 28, 2011
  14. 22bookTeam of RivalsDoris Kearns Goodwin — Simon & Schuster — 2006
  15. 23newsSpielberg's 'Lincoln' takes RichmondMal Vincent — October 14, 2011
  16. 24newsJeanne Jakle: McGill's profile going higher and higherJeanne Jakle — July 30, 2011
  17. 26magazine'Lincoln': Meet the CastJeff Labrecque — November 28, 2011
  18. 31newsLincoln logs in at DreamWorks: Spielberg, Neeson eye Abe picMichael Fleming — January 11, 2005
  19. 33newsLincoln UpdateJanuary 23, 2003
  20. 34newsThe Director's CutGrover — April 17, 2006
  21. 35newsSpielberg's Lincoln in December?Jeffrey Wells — Hollywood Elsewhere — February 2, 2009
  22. 36newsKushner's (old) testament to LincolnNaomi Pffefferman — October 26, 2007
  23. 37newsLincoln LogsKaren Bovard — November 20, 2008
  24. 39newsSpielberg's Lincoln Survives Assassination AttemptLane Brown — February 24, 2009
  25. 43newsAbraham Lincoln As You've Never Heard Him BeforeCharles McGrath — October 31, 2012
  26. 44newsLiam Neeson Talks LincolnMax Evry — ComingSoon.net — January 24, 2007
  27. 45newsNeeson quits Spielberg's Lincoln biopicSimon Reynolds — July 30, 2010
  28. 46webThe GQ Cover Story: Liam NeesonMichael Hainey — March 27, 2014
  29. 48webThe Hard Luck and Beautiful Life of Liam NeesonTom Chiarella — Hearst Communications — February 15, 2011
  30. 49webDaniel Day-Lewis set for Steven Spielberg's Lincoln filmShoard, Catherine — November 19, 2010
  31. 51newsFilm crews may be back in Silver CityCharles Winokoor — February 7, 2009
  32. 52newsLincoln film to come to Petersburg next monthF.M. Wiggins — November 17, 2011
  33. 58news'Lincoln' Gets Tweaked for Overseas ReleaseAlex Ben Block — January 16, 2013
  34. 59newsA few books tied to Spielberg's 'Lincoln'Jane Henderson — 16 November 2012
  35. 64news'Lincoln' DVDs to Go to All U.S. Middle and High SchoolsRebecca Ford — 11 February 2013
  36. 66newsDisney announces it will donate Lincoln movie to schoolsLiana Solis — 18 February 2013
  37. 68webLincoln (2012)Rotten Tomatoes
  38. 69webLincolnMetacritic
  39. 70webHome
  40. 71webA saintly wheeler-dealerRoger Ebert
  41. 74newsReview: An epic 'Lincoln'Charlie McCollum — 2012-11-07
  42. 75newsA President Engaged in a Great Civil WarA. O. Scott — 8 November 2012
  43. 80webWhat's True and False in Lincoln MovieHarold Holzer — 2012-11-22
  44. 81webIs the Lincoln Movie Historically Accurate?Barry Bradford — November 29, 2012
  45. 82webA Civil War Professor Reviews 'Lincoln'David Frum — 2012-11-27
  46. 84webA Historian Views Spielberg's Lincoln (2012)Nicholas Roland — November 25, 2012
  47. 85webHow True is "Lincoln"?David O. Stewart — History News Network — November 20, 2012
  48. 88webPanel Discussion for the film LINCOLNThis Week in the Civil War — 2013-01-16
  49. 89bookFinal Freedom by Michael VorenbergMichael Vorenberg — May 2001e
  50. 90magazineTony Kushner's Real Source For "Lincoln"?Timothy Noah — 2013-01-10
  51. 91magazineKushner Replies About SourcesTimothy Noah — 2013-01-11