Investiture Controversy
The collapse of the Western Roman Empire left a power vacuum that nobility rushed to fill. Members of the ruling class began performing investiture, the act of appointing bishops and abbots, despite church doctrine reserving this task for clergy alone. Many bishops were themselves sons of noble families who had been given surplus land and titles. When primogeniture ensured only the eldest son inherited the family estate, younger brothers sought positions within the upper church hierarchy. These men often controlled proprietary churches or abbeys built on their own lands. The office of bishop brought substantial wealth and land, creating an important income source through simony, the sale of church offices. Emperors relied heavily on these bishops for secular administration because they lacked hereditary nobility with competing family interests. They justified their authority using the theory of divine right of kings. Before 1059, many papal selections were influenced by European powers, often with a king announcing a choice that church electors would rubber-stamp. Holy Roman Emperors of the Ottonian dynasty believed they should have the power to appoint the pope. Otto the Great, who reigned from 936 to 72, established bishops as princes of the empire who held great privileges. These bishops became feudal lords over large districts of imperial territory. Control of these economic and military units was primary importance for any ruler seeking to maintain imperial authority.
Pope Gregory VII composed the Dictatus papae in 1075, cataloging principles of his Gregorian Reforms though he did not publish it at the time. One clause asserted that the pope held exclusive power to depose an emperor. It declared that the Roman church was founded by God alone, making papal power the sole universal power. A council held in the Lateran Palace from February 24 to 28, 1075 decreed that only the pope could appoint or depose churchmen. The pope objected to bishops being invested with symbols of their office by lay lords to show fealty. Henry IV continued to appoint his own bishops despite this declaration, angering Gregory. He reacted by sending a letter withdrawing imperial support of Gregory as pope. The letter was headed "Henry, king not through usurpation but through the holy ordination of God, to Hildebrand, at present not pope but false monk." It called for the election of a new pope. The letter ends with the words "I, Henry, king by the grace of God, with all of my Bishops, say to you, come down, come down!" This phrase is often quoted with "and to be damned throughout the ages," which is a later addition. The situation grew dire when Henry IV installed his chaplain Tedald, a Milanese priest, as Bishop of Milan while another priest named Atto had already been chosen in Rome by the pope.
In 1076 Pope Gregory VII responded to Henry's defiance by excommunicating him and deposing him as German king. This action released all Christians from their oath of allegiance and caused Henry's subjects to refuse obedience. Henry decided to beg Gregory's pardon, which was granted. In 1077 he traveled to Canossa in northern Italy where the Pope stayed in the castle of Countess Matilda. The pope wore a hair shirt and stood barefoot in the snow as penance for his sins. This event became known as the Road to Canossa. Gregory lifted the excommunication but German aristocrats were unwilling to give up their opportunity. They elected a rival king named Rudolf von Rheinfeld. Three years later Pope Gregory declared support for von Rheinfeld. On the 7th of March 1080, during the Lenten synod, Gregory excommunicated Henry IV again. Henry called a council of bishops at Brixen that proclaimed Gregory illegitimate. Internal revolt against Henry ended that same year when Rudolf von Rheinfeld died. Henry IV named Guibert of Ravenna, whom he had invested as bishop of Ravenna, to be pope under the name Clement III. In October 1080 troops raised by pro-Imperial bishops clashed with pro-papal forces of Countess Matilda in the battle of Volta Mantovana. Pro-Imperial forces won and in March 1081 Henry marched from the Brenner Pass into the March of Verona unopposed.
Henry IV was forced to abdicate on the 31st of December 1105 and succeeded by his son Henry V who had rebelled against him. Henry V made his father renounce the legality of antipopes before dying. Pope Paschal II rebuked Henry V for appointing bishops in Germany. The king crossed the Alps with an army in 1111. The weak pope suggested a compromise known as the abortive Concordat of 1111. German churchmen would surrender their lands and secular offices to the emperor while constituting a purely spiritual church. Henry gained greater control over contested lands but the crowd erupted in anger when concessions were read in St Peter's. Henry took the pope and cardinals hostage until granted investiture rights then returned to Germany crowned emperor. The clergy urged Paschal to rescind this agreement which he did in 1112. Henry V rebelled again and was excommunicated. Riots broke out in Germany and a new Antipope Gregory VIII was appointed by the German king. Nobles loyal to Rome seceded from Henry. The controversy dragged on another ten years until the Concordat of Worms in 1122 ended it. Henry V died without heirs in 1125 three years after the Concordat. He designated his nephew Frederick von Staufen duke of Swabia as successor but churchmen elected Lothair III instead.
At the time of Henry IV's death, Henry I of England and the Gregorian papacy were embroiled in a separate controversy over investiture. William the Conqueror had accepted a papal banner and distant blessing of Pope Alexander II upon invasion but successfully rebuffed the pope's assertion that he should come to Rome and pay homage for his fief. In the reign of Henry I exchanges between Westminster and Rome induced Anselm Archbishop of Canterbury to give up mediating and retire to an abbey. Robert of Meulan one of Henry's chief advisors was excommunicated though the threat of excommunicating the king remained unplayed. The papacy needed support of English Henry while German Henry was still unbroken. A projected crusade also required English support. Henry I commissioned the Archbishop of York to collect all relevant traditions of anointed kingship. Historian Norman Cantor noted these treatises are delightful to students of early-medieval political theory but do not typify Anglo-Norman monarchy outlook which substituted administrative bureaucracy for religious ideology. The Concordat of London agreed in 1107 was a forerunner of compromise later taken up in Germany. Henry I gave up right to invest bishops and abbots while reserving custom requiring them swear homage for temporalities directly from his hand after bishop swore feudal vassalage.
On the 23rd of September 1122 near German city of Worms Pope Callixtus II and Holy Roman Emperor Henry V entered agreement now known as Concordat of Worms ending Investiture Controversy. It eliminated lay investiture while allowing secular leaders some room for unofficial but significant influence in appointment process. Election of bishops and abbots in Germany took place in emperor presence or legate's as judge without violence between disputing parties free of bribes. This retained crucial role for emperor choosing great territorial magnates of Empire. Absent dispute canons of cathedral elected bishop while monks chose abbot. Beyond borders of Germany in Burgundy and Italy election handled by church without imperial interference. Emperor renounced right to invest ecclesiastics with ring and crosier symbols of spiritual power guaranteeing election by canons of cathedral or abbey and free consecration. To make up for this another symbol scepter invented handed over by king or his legate. Two ended promising mutual aid when requested and granting one another peace. Concordat confirmed by First Council of Lateran in 1123. By terms of agreement emperor's right to substantial imbursement payment on election denied though reference to feudal homage due emperor guarded.
In long term decline of imperial power divided Germany until 19th century. Similarly in Italy investiture controversy weakened emperor authority strengthening local separatists. While monarchy embroiled in dispute with Church its power declined and localized rights of lordship over peasants increased leading to increased serfdom reducing rights for majority. Local taxes and levies increased while royal coffers declined. Localized rights of justice emerged where courts did not answer to royal authority. German kings still had de facto influence over selection of German bishops though over time princes gained influence among church electors. Bishop-elect invested by Emperor with scepter then later by ecclesial superior with ring and staff. Resolution produced significant improvement in character of men raised to episcopacy. Kings no longer interfered so frequently in elections generally nominating more worthy candidates. Disputes between popes and Holy Roman Emperors continued until northern Italy lost to empire entirely after wars of Guelphs and Ghibellines. Serious divisions from battle over Investiture Controversy fractured large portions of Holy Roman Empire in Germany and Italy. Neither Germany nor Italy formed cohesive nation-state until 19th century. Catastrophic political consequences led to cultural disaster as Germany lost intellectual leadership in western Europe.
Up Next
Continue Browsing
Common questions
What was the Investiture Controversy between 1076 and 1122?
The Investiture Controversy was a medieval dispute between secular rulers and the papacy over the appointment of bishops and abbots. It began when Holy Roman Emperors appointed church officials to maintain imperial authority despite church doctrine reserving this task for clergy alone.
When did Pope Gregory VII excommunicate Henry IV during the Investiture Controversy?
Pope Gregory VII first excommunicated Henry IV in 1076 after the king continued appointing his own bishops. The pope excommunicated Henry IV again on the 7th of March 1080 during the Lenten synod following a council that declared Gregory illegitimate.
Where did Henry IV meet Pope Gregory VII at Canossa in 1077?
Henry IV traveled to Canossa in northern Italy where the Pope stayed in the castle of Countess Matilda. This event became known as the Road to Canossa and involved the pope standing barefoot in the snow as penance for his sins before lifting the excommunication.
How did the Concordat of Worms end the Investiture Controversy in 1122?
The Concordat of Worms ended the conflict on the 23rd of September 1122 near German city of Worms between Pope Callixtus II and Holy Roman Emperor Henry V. It eliminated lay investiture while allowing secular leaders some room for unofficial but significant influence in the appointment process through the granting of a scepter symbolizing temporal power.
Why did the Investiture Controversy lead to long term decline of imperial power in Germany and Italy?
The controversy weakened emperor authority and strengthened local separatists leading to increased serfdom and reduced rights for the majority. Localized rights of justice emerged where courts did not answer to royal authority causing royal coffers to decline and Germany to lose intellectual leadership in western Europe.