Gothic architecture

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Gothic architecture took root in a single choir reconstruction at the Abbey of Saint-Denis, near Paris, completed between 1140 and 1144. That relatively modest project drew together for the first time a cluster of structural ideas -- pointed arches, rib vaults, flying buttresses -- and in doing so launched a style that would define European building for the next four centuries. What the builders called it at the time was opus Francigenum, meaning French work. The word Gothic was applied later, and not as a compliment. How did a term meant as an insult become the name for one of the most ambitious architectural traditions ever built? And what drove medieval masons to push walls thinner, windows larger, and vaults higher until the technology itself began to buckle?

  343331

• 2. A Name Born of Contempt

  ›

  Giorgio Vasari, writing in his Lives of the Artists in 1550, called the style the barbarous German style and blamed the Goths -- the people who had sacked Rome -- for inventing it. His argument was circular but effective: because the Goths had destroyed classical antiquity, anything that deviated from classical forms must have originated with them. Italy had by then spent a century building in the Vitruvian vocabulary of ancient columns and symmetry, and from that vantage the pointed arch looked like a symbol of barbarism rather than ingenuity. Francois Rabelais echoed Vasari in the 16th century, referring to Gotz and Ostrogotz as the apparent authors of the style. The polymath Christopher Wren, born in 1632 and appointed Surveyor of the Fabric at Westminster Abbey in 1698, disagreed sharply. He argued that the pointed arch owed its sophistication not to the Goths at all, but to Islamic architecture, which he called the Saracen style, itself rooted in Greek mathematics. Wren mentioned Europe's debt to what he called the Saracens no fewer than twelve times in his writings. He traced the transfer of knowledge to the Crusades, which he dated to the year 1095 in the Kingdom of France, arguing that Christian builders had seen Saracen works there and imitated them on returning west. Most historians have rejected this theory because the earliest Gothic pointed arches in Europe pre-date the First Crusade of 1096-1099, making direct Crusade-era borrowing chronologically impossible. Some scholars have proposed alternative routes: the Muslim conquest of the Iberian Peninsula in the early 8th century, or the influence of Sicily and Spain, could have carried pointed-arch traditions into Europe long before any Crusade set out.

  7891014

• 3. The Structural Revolution

  ›

  Durham Cathedral was the first cathedral to use a rib vault, built between 1093 and 1104. That single innovation changed the physics of building. A Romanesque barrel vault pressed its weight straight down, demanding thick walls and permitting only small openings. A Gothic rib vault directed its thrust diagonally outward to the corners, then downward through slender columns to the floor, leaving the panels between the ribs light and thin. The outward thrust could be caught by buttresses placed outside the walls, and later by flying buttresses -- half-arches that leapt over a side aisle to reach a heavy stone column beyond. The result was that the massive walls of Romanesque buildings were no longer structurally necessary. Walls could be made thinner and taller, and filled with windows. The Abbey church of Saint-Denis showed what this meant in practice. Its builder, the Abbot Suger, described the new ambulatory as a circular ring of chapels by virtue of which the whole church would shine with the wonderful and uninterrupted light of most luminous windows, pervading the interior beauty. He modeled the carved capitals of his columns on ancient Roman examples he had seen in Rome, and installed a circular rose window over the portal on the facade. Both features became standard in Gothic cathedrals that followed. Sens Cathedral, begun between 1135 and 1140 and consecrated in 1160, was the first building constructed entirely in the new Gothic mode. It combined rib vaults, buttresses, and pointed arches systematically, and its strongly vertical three-part elevation -- arcade, triforium, clerestory -- became the template for later Gothic buildings across France and England. One of the builders thought to have worked at Sens, William of Sens, later crossed the Channel and rebuilt the choir of Canterbury Cathedral in the Gothic style between 1175 and 1180, before a fall from scaffolding in 1178 left him badly injured. He returned to France and died there. His English successor, William the Englishman, completed the work.

  2084336187

• 4. The Race for Height

  ›

  Chartres Cathedral set an early benchmark for height at 38 metres, achieved after the Romanesque building there was destroyed by fire in 1194. Its rebuilding drew contributions from King Philip II of France, Pope Celestine III, local merchants, craftsmen, and Richard the Lionheart of England. The builders simplified the elevation used at Notre-Dame, eliminated the tribune galleries, and used flying buttresses to open the walls for stained glass depicting the Virgin Mary and the patron guilds. Reims Cathedral, begun in 1211 and the traditional coronation church of the kings of France, carried two thousand three hundred statues on the front and back of its facade. Amiens Cathedral, built from 1220, reached a height of 42.3 metres at the transept using the newer four-part rib vault, which could span a wider nave than the earlier six-part variety. Beauvais Cathedral, begun in 1225, pushed the vault to 48 metres -- the highest ever attempted. A portion of the choir collapsed in 1284. Panels of experts were convened in Siena and Chartres to assess the stability of their own structures. No cathedral has exceeded the height of the Beauvais choir since. Only the transept and choir at Beauvais were ever completed, and in the 21st century the transept walls required reinforcement with cross-beams.

  3393616369

• 5. Light Made Architecture

  ›

  Rayonnant Gothic, which emerged in the 13th century, pursued the logical conclusion of everything the flying buttress had made possible: walls that were effectively entirely glass. The royal chapel of Louis IX of France, the Sainte-Chapelle on the Ile de la Cite in the Seine, completed around 1241-1248, is the defining example. Shortly after Saint-Denis, Louis IX also commissioned the rebuilt transepts and enormous rose windows of Notre-Dame de Paris, the north transept in the 1250s and the south transept begun in 1258. The Rayonnant style spread to Metz Cathedral around 1245, to Cologne around 1250, and to the nave of Strasbourg Cathedral around the same decade. Bar-tracery, first used at Reims Cathedral shortly after 1211, was the technical enabler. It replaced solid stone spandrels with moulded stone bars that could frame increasingly complex window patterns. By 1300, curvilinear, reticulated, and flowing tracery types had all developed. In England, a parallel tradition called Decorated Gothic pursued the ornamentation of tracery rather than the maximization of glazed area. Westminster Abbey, begun in 1245, and the cathedrals at Lichfield, Exeter, and Bath Abbey all show this emphasis. The Perpendicular style, unknown on the continent, took a different path: it straightened the curving tracery into orthogonal panels of vertical mullions topped with fan vaulting. It first appeared in the cloisters and chapter-house of Old St Paul's Cathedral in London, attributed to William de Ramsey around 1332, and its most celebrated expression is King's College Chapel, Cambridge, built by Reginald Ely between 1446 and 1461.

  3361631240

• 6. Towers, Spires, and Stone Spectacle

  ›

  Chartres Cathedral illustrates how unpredictable cathedral tower-building could be. The south tower was built in the 12th century in the simpler Early Gothic style, while the north tower was completed later in the Flamboyant style, giving the cathedral two visually mismatched spires. An abandoned second plan would have surrounded the transept and sanctuary with seven towers. At Laon Cathedral, the two western towers contain life-size stone statues of sixteen oxen in their upper arcades, said to honour the animals who hauled the stone during construction. The famous flèche of Notre-Dame de Paris, a slender spire of wood covered with lead originally built in the middle of the 13th century to house five bells, was removed in 1786 during a modernization program, rebuilt in a new design by Eugene Viollet-le-Duc whose figure of St Thomas was reportedly modeled on himself, and destroyed again in the 2019 fire before being restored in the same design. The tower of Salisbury Cathedral, completed in 1320 by William of Farleigh, required exceptional ingenuity because it was built on the pillars of a much earlier structure. Wells Cathedral had an equally pressing problem: the new central tower proved too heavy for the original crossing, and an unusual double arch had to be inserted beneath it. Cologne Cathedral began in the 13th century following Amiens's plan, but was finished only in the 19th century after the original plans were rediscovered in 1817. Ulm Minster's tower followed a similar pattern, begun in 1377, halted in 1543, and not completed until the 19th century.

  9364899295

• 7. Decline, Survival, and Revival

  ›

  The dome of Florence Cathedral, built by Filippo Brunelleschi between 1420 and 1436 and inspired by the Pantheon in Rome, is conventionally cited as one of the first Renaissance landmarks. It also used Gothic technology: its outer skin was supported by a framework of twenty-four ribs. The two traditions did not separate cleanly. Saint-Eustache in Paris, built between 1532 and 1560, was Gothic in structure and scale -- at 105 metres long, 44 metres wide, and 35 metres high it rivalled Notre-Dame -- but acquired Renaissance classical orders of columns as construction continued, producing a hybrid. François I installed Leonardo da Vinci at his Chateau of Chambord in 1516 and introduced a Renaissance long gallery at the Palace of Fontainebleau between 1528 and 1540. In England, under Henry VIII and Elizabeth I, the country stayed largely separate from continental developments. Ireland persisted as an island of Gothic building well into the modern era; Derry Cathedral was completed in 1633, Sligo Cathedral built around 1730, and Down Cathedral constructed between 1790 and 1818. At Oxford, Christopher Wren designed Tom Tower at Christ Church between 1681 and 1682 in a Gothic mode even as he declined to put a Gothic roof on his new St Paul's Cathedral. The Gothic Revival gathered formal momentum with the two western towers of Westminster Abbey, built by Nicholas Hawksmoor between 1722 and 1745. In the 19th century, the Palace of Westminster by Sir Charles Barry with interiors by Augustus Welby Pugin, and George Gilbert Scott's Albert Memorial, brought the revived Gothic into the heart of British civic life. The style eventually reached Hong Kong with the Anglican St John's Cathedral, built at the centre of Victoria City in Central.

  6113363940