Frederick Copleston

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Frederick Charles Copleston was born on the 10th of April 1907 in the parish of Trull, near Taunton in Somerset, and he would go on to write one of the most comprehensive accounts of philosophy ever produced in the English language. His family carried a name old enough to appear in a Somerset rhyme attributed to John Prince, who died in 1723: "Crocker, Cruwys, and Coplestone, When the Conqueror came were at home." That lineage stretched back to the Norman Conquest, and yet the man who inherited it would spend his adult life in the quiet rooms of a Catholic religious order, filling notebooks with the ideas of long-dead thinkers. How did a Somerset boy from an Anglican family, the son of a judge posted to Rangoon in Burma, become the author of a multi-volume History of Philosophy that scholars still reach for today? How did a Jesuit priest end up in a broadcast debate with Bertrand Russell that people would quote for decades? And what drove him, even after official retirement, to keep teaching, keep writing, keep pressing into the questions that philosophy asks?

• 2. From Anglican to Jesuit

  ›

  Reginald Stephen Copleston, Frederick's uncle, served as Anglican bishop of Calcutta, and another uncle, Ernest Copleston, held the Anglican bishopric of Colombo. With that family background, Frederick's conversion at the age of eighteen hit his household hard. He had studied at Marlborough College from 1920 to 1925, and it was sometime during those years or shortly after that he concluded the Roman Catholic Church was, as he put it, "the only one which could reasonably be thought to have developed out of what Christ established." His father opposed the decision but still helped him complete his education at St John's College, Oxford, where he read from 1925 to 1929, graduating with a third in classical moderations and a good second at Greats. After Oxford he entered the seminary at St Mary's College, Oscott, intending to serve the diocese of Clifton, but quickly found that life was not for him. In 1930 he joined the Jesuits instead. He completed his two-year novitiate in Roehampton, then followed the traditional course of priestly studies at the Jesuit house at Heythrop in Oxfordshire, and in 1937 he was ordained there. The following year he travelled to Germany to finish his training, returning to Britain just as the war was about to begin in 1939.

• 3. A History Born From War

  ›

  Copleston had originally been earmarked to complete a doctorate at the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome, but the outbreak of war closed that path. He was sent back instead to Heythrop in Oxfordshire, where only a handful of Jesuits remained, and he began teaching the history of philosophy to whoever was left. Out of that wartime posting grew the work that would define him: A History of Philosophy, whose volumes appeared between 1946 and 1975. The project covers ancient, medieval, and modern thought, and it has been described as "a monumental achievement" that "stays true to the authors it discusses, being very much a work in exposition." The praise points to a quality that runs through all of Copleston's writing: he treated each philosopher he examined on their own terms, trying to represent what was actually being argued before subjecting it to criticism. That commitment to faithful exposition was not inevitable. A less patient writer might have bent every figure in the canon toward a single thesis. Copleston preferred to let the material speak, and it is that restraint that kept readers returning to the History long after its first volumes were shelved.

• 4. The Debates That Made Headlines

  ›

  On a BBC broadcast in 1948, Copleston faced Bertrand Russell to debate the existence of God, and the exchange became one of the most replayed philosophical conversations of the century. Russell was by then one of the best-known philosophers in the English-speaking world, and Copleston brought to the exchange his Thomist training and his habit of careful exposition. The debate hinged in part on Copleston's argument from contingency, the idea that the universe's existence demands an explanation outside itself. The following year, 1949, Copleston turned to a different set of questions in a debate with A. J. Ayer, described in the sources as his friend as well as his intellectual adversary. Their subject was logical positivism and whether religious language could be considered meaningful at all. The exchange was later published in Paul Edwards and Arthur Pap's anthology A Modern Introduction to Philosophy in 1957, alongside a transcript attributed to both men. Where many academics confined their arguments to journals, Copleston took them into the broadcast studio and showed that deep philosophical questions could hold a popular audience.

• 5. Aquinas and the Five Ways

  ›

  Among Copleston's contributions beyond the History, his work on Saint Thomas Aquinas stands out. His book Aquinas appeared in 1955, later reprinted from 1976 under the title Thomas Aquinas. In it he engaged directly with Aquinas's Five Ways, the five arguments for God's existence laid out in the Summa Theologica. Copleston's particular intervention was a distinction between causes in fieri and causes in esse. A cause in fieri brings something into existence and may then fall away; a cause in esse is one that must persist for the effect to continue existing at all. By drawing that line, Copleston argued that Aquinas was not simply proposing a first mover who could retire once the chain of events was set going. He was pointing toward a God whose sustaining presence is required at every moment. That reading clarifies why Aquinas's argument, in Copleston's handling, amounts to something more than a claim about origins. It is a claim about the continuous dependency of everything that exists. The Copleston-Russell debate of 1948 had already put a version of this reasoning before a mass audience; the Aquinas book gave that reasoning its full philosophical scaffolding.

• 6. Later Career and Honours

  ›

  From 1952 to 1968, Copleston spent six months of each year lecturing at Rome's Gregorian University as a visiting professor. When the Jesuit house of studies at Heythrop was relocated to London in 1970 and became Heythrop College, a constituent part of the University of London, Copleston became its principal and taught undergraduate courses. His students, drawn from younger Jesuits, from male and female religious orders, and from lay men and women, responded to what sources describe as his affable manner, dry humour, and unfailing courtesy. That same year, 1970, he was elected a Fellow of the British Academy. In 1972 the University of London gave him a personal professorship, and in 1975 St John's College, Oxford, made him an Honorary Fellow. He officially retired in 1974 but promptly accepted a visiting professorship at the University of Santa Clara in California, which he held from 1974 to 1982. Between 1979 and 1981 he delivered the Gifford Lectures at the University of Aberdeen, published as Religion and the One, a work described as expressing themes more personal than those of the History. Honorary doctorates followed from Santa Clara University, Uppsala University, and the University of St Andrews. In 1993, a year before his death, he was made CBE. Father Frederick Copleston died on the 3rd of February 1994 at St Thomas' Hospital in London, aged 86, with his Memoirs of a Philosopher, published that same year 1993, among his final contributions.