Flight and expulsion of Germans (1944–1950)

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The flight and expulsion of Germans between 1944 and 1950 stands as the largest forced migration in modern European history. By 1950, roughly 12 million Germans had left or been removed from east-central Europe, resettling in Allied-occupied Germany and Austria. The West German government put the figure even higher, at 14.6 million, when accounting for ethnic Germans who had settled in Nazi-conquered territories during the war and children born to expelled parents. The death toll remains bitterly contested: estimates range from 500,000 at the low end to 2.5 million according to the German government's own figures. How did a catastrophe of this scale come to be planned, executed, and justified? And why did it unfold in three distinct, overlapping waves across a dozen countries over nearly six years?

• 2. A Fractured Map

  ›

  Before World War II, East-Central Europe was not a patchwork of tidy ethnic blocs. Vast mixed areas and hundreds of smaller pockets settled by different groups had existed for centuries, with diverse communities sharing cities and trading routes even when relations were strained. The German Empire had been the first modern European state to propose population transfers as a solution to what it called "nationality conflicts," with plans to remove Poles and Jews from a projected post-World War I "Polish Border Strip" and replace them with Christian ethnic Germans. After the Treaty of Versailles in 1919 redrew the map, millions of ethnic Germans found themselves as national minorities in Poland, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Yugoslavia, and Romania. Nazi ideology then encouraged those communities to demand local autonomy, while the German Ministry of Foreign Affairs quietly funded political movements across the region, including Konrad Henlein's party in Czechoslovakia, the Deutscher Volksverband in Poland, and the Volksbund der Deutschen in Ungarn in Hungary. By 1939, more than half of all Polish Germans lived outside the formerly German territories of Poland, drawn by economic opportunity rather than political allegiance.

• 3. Planning the Transfer

  ›

  The idea of expelling ethnic Germans from annexed territories was raised with the Allied powers as early as 1942, pushed jointly by Winston Churchill and the Polish and Czechoslovak governments-in-exile meeting in London. Not everyone agreed with the approach. Tomasz Arciszewski, the Polish prime minister in exile, supported the annexation of German territory but opposed expulsion outright, preferring instead to naturalize Germans as Polish citizens and assimilate them. Joseph Stalin took the opposite view. He had already ordered Germans from Crimea transported to Central Asia in 1941, and he worked with fellow Communist leaders to plan the removal of all ethnic Germans from east of the Oder and from Soviet occupation zones. The Czechoslovak government-in-exile formally adopted expulsion as policy by 1943, and Edvard Beneš issued a decree on the 19th of May 1945 that labeled ethnic Hungarians and Germans "unreliable for the state," opening the door to confiscations and forced removals. The final terms were not settled until the Potsdam Conference, held between the 17th of July and the 2nd of August 1945, at which the Allied leaders agreed that the transfer should be "effected in an orderly and humane manner."

• 4. Justifications and Motives

  ›

  Allied leaders and the governments they supported cited several distinct motives for the expulsions, though these often blurred together in practice. The most prominent was the desire to create ethnically homogeneous nation-states. Churchill himself pointed to the 1923 population exchange between Greece and Turkey as a precedent, calling it a success in a speech on the German expulsions. Soviet strategic thinking added another layer: Stalin saw the removals as a way to manufacture lasting antagonism between Germany and its eastern neighbors, ensuring those neighbors would turn to the Soviet Union for protection. The assets left behind by expelled Germans in Poland and Czechoslovakia were then used to reward cooperation with the new Communist governments, and support for the Communists proved especially strong in areas where expulsions had been most extensive. Jan Karski, the Polish resistance fighter and courier, had warned President Franklin D. Roosevelt as early as 1943 that Polish reprisals against German civilians were "unavoidable." Karol Swierczewski, commander of the Second Polish Army, told his soldiers to "exact on the Germans what they enacted on us, so they will flee on their own and thank God they saved their lives." In Poland, which had lost six million citizens including nearly its entire Jewish population to Lebensraum and the Holocaust, collective punishment of the German population was widely seen as overdue justice.

• 5. Flight Before the Red Army

  ›

  The first mass movement of people was neither organized nor orderly. Starting in mid-1944, as the Red Army pushed westward, millions of German civilians fled ahead of Soviet forces. Most were aware of reprisals against German civilians; news of atrocities such as the Nemmersdorf massacre had been amplified by Nazi propaganda. Evacuation plans existed on paper, but implementation was repeatedly delayed because Nazi authorities treated any talk of retreat as defeatism, a potentially fatal charge. As a result, millions were still in vulnerable eastern areas when combat overwhelmed them. In the winter of 1944-1945, kilometers-long columns of refugees pushed carts through the snow. Refugee treks caught by the advancing Soviets were targeted by low-flying aircraft, and some people were crushed by tanks. The single largest disaster came in January 1945, when the liner Wilhelm Gustloff, mobilized as part of the Strength Through Joy fleet, was sunk by the Soviet submarine S-13 in the Baltic Sea. About 9,000 civilians and military personnel escaping East Prussia died, making it the largest loss of life in a single ship sinking in recorded history. The German Federal Archive estimated that 100,000 to 120,000 civilians, roughly one percent of the total population, died during the flight and evacuations. Polish historians Witold Sienkiewicz and Grzegorz Hryciuk put the civilian death toll from cold, stress, and bombing at between 600,000 and 1.2 million.

• 6. Denmark and the Baltic Route

  ›

  From the Baltic coast, Operation Hannibal evacuated large numbers of Germans by sea. Between the 23rd of January and the 5th of May 1945, up to 250,000 Germans, primarily from East Prussia, Pomerania, and the Baltic states, were evacuated to Nazi-occupied Denmark under an order Hitler issued on the 4th of February 1945. By the time the war ended, the German refugee population in Denmark amounted to five percent of the entire Danish population. One-third of the refugees were children under the age of fifteen. After the surrender, the Germans were interned in several hundred camps across Denmark; the largest, Oksboel Refugee Camp, held 37,000 inmates, guarded by Danish Defence units. In 1945 alone, 13,492 German refugees died in Denmark, among them 7,000 children under five. Kirsten Lylloff, a Danish physician and historian, documented that these deaths were partly caused by denial of medical care: both the Danish Association of Doctors and the Danish Red Cross began refusing treatment to German refugees from March 1945. The situation gradually improved after 60 Danish clergymen published an open letter in defence of the refugees, and Social Democrat Johannes Kjaerbol assumed administration of the camps on the 6th of September 1945. The last refugees left Denmark on the 15th of February 1949. In the Treaty of London, signed on the 26th of February 1953, West Germany agreed to pay Denmark 160 million Danish kroner in compensation, paid between 1953 and 1958.

• 7. Country by Country

  ›

  Czechoslovakia saw some of the largest movements. According to the West German Schieder commission, 4.5 million German civilians were present in Bohemia-Moravia in May 1945, including 1.6 million refugees from Poland. Between 700,000 and 800,000 were affected by irregular expulsions before the Potsdam terms even took effect. Formal transfers under the Potsdam agreements ran from January through October 1946, sending 1.9 million to the American zone and over one million to the Soviet zone. The West German government initially estimated 273,000 expulsion deaths from Czechoslovakia, but a joint German-Czech commission of historians found in 1995 that this figure was overstated; the commission concluded the actual toll was between 15,000 and 30,000. In Hungary, expulsion began on the 22nd of December 1944 by direct order of the Soviet Red Army commander. The first 5,788 expellees left the town of Wudersch on the 19th of January 1946. About 180,000 German-speaking citizens were stripped of their citizenship and possessions and expelled to the western zones of Germany; most settled in Baden-Wurttemberg, Bavaria, and Hesse. A governmental decree of the 25th of March 1950 voided all expulsion orders and allowed those who wished to return to do so. Yugoslavia took a different path: rather than expelling its approximately 200,000 remaining ethnic Germans, it turned ethnic German villages into internment camps. Over 50,000 perished from deliberate starvation and direct killings by guards. The camp system was shut down in March 1948. Romania, uniquely among Eastern Bloc countries, did not expel its ethnic Germans; instead, the Communist regime gave them the status of a national minority in 1948. About 400,000 ethnic Germans remained in Romania, though many began emigrating during the 1980s, with over 160,000 leaving in 1989 alone. By 2002, only around 60,000 ethnic Germans were counted in Romania.

• 8. The Dispute Over Casualties

  ›

  The death toll from the expulsions remains one of the most contested figures in postwar European history. The West German government's official estimate of 2 million deaths, standing since the 1960s, was built on studies whose methodologies have since been questioned. The Schieder commission, which issued five reports between 1954 and 1961, was led by Theodor Schieder, a rehabilitated former Nazi party member who had been involved in drafting the Generalplan Ost to colonize eastern Europe. Several authors of the key 1958 West German statistical study, including Wilfried Krallert, had been Nazi party members; Krallert himself had been an SS officer directly implicated in the plundering of cultural artifacts in eastern Europe. A separate German Federal Archives study commissioned in 1969, completed in 1974, and kept secret until 1989, reached a much lower figure of 600,000 deaths, counting only those caused by violent acts and inhumanities rather than postwar disease or malnutrition. A church search service survey of 16.2 million people, ordered in 1953 and completed in 1964 but also kept secret until 1987, confirmed 473,013 civilian deaths, with nearly 1.9 million additional cases where fate could not be determined. Historian Rudiger Overmans published a critical analysis in 1994 arguing that both the 2-million figure and the intermediate estimates are unreliable, in part because Communist governments in Eastern Europe withheld cooperation, eyewitness accounts were inconsistent, and the figures improperly included military deaths and persons of doubtful German ethnicity. His assessment: more arguments support the lower figures than the higher ones. The German government has continued to cite the 2 million figure, while some scholars in Germany and Poland estimate the actual total at between 500,000 and 600,000.