— Ch. 1 · Defining Experimental Methods —
Experimental archaeology.
~3 min read · Ch. 1 of 6
Robert Ascher published the first paper on experimental archaeology in 1961 within American Anthropologist. This work established a framework for testing archaeological hypotheses through replication rather than speculation. The discipline requires researchers to create copies of historical structures using only historically accurate technologies. Peter Mathieu defined the field as an imitative experiment designed to generate analogies for interpretation. Living history and historical reenactment serve as non-archaeological counterparts that lack this scientific rigor. These hobbyist activities do not concern themselves with generating testable data or validating theories about the past.
Pioneering Research Sites
Butser Ancient Farm opened its gates in Hampshire, UK, during the early 1970s to recreate buildings from local archaeology. Reynolds Peter J led long-term experiments there to test ideas regarding construction, use, and materials. The site now features a working Stone Age farm alongside Bronze Age roundhouses and Iron Age villages. This location helped establish experimental archaeology as a legitimate academic discipline while bringing prehistory into the UK school curriculum. Lejre Land of Legends in Denmark stands as another early example featuring reconstructed buildings from multiple eras including the Viking era. Researchers at these sites continue to run experiments on prehistoric living and technologies today.Notable Reconstructions
Thor Heyerdahl sailed a balsa raft named Kon-Tiki from Peru to Polynesia in 1947 to demonstrate cultural exchange possibilities. Modern researchers have attempted to transport large stones similar to those used in Stonehenge using only technology available at the time. Greek triremes were reconstructed by skilled sailors who successfully tested them at sea based on archaeological plans. Guédelon Castle in Treigny, France, remains an active medieval construction project that employs traditional building methods. Marcus Junkelmann constructed Roman devices and gear for museums before testing them in reenactments involving legionaries crossing the Alps from Verona to Augsburg.