E. Merton Coulter
E. Merton Coulter served as the first president of the Southern Historical Association in 1934. He edited the Georgia Historical Quarterly for fifty years. He was a professor at the University of Georgia for six decades and chaired its History Department for eighteen. The Library of Congress lists fifty books that he wrote or edited. He published more than 125 articles. By the late twentieth century, historians had agreed on a common description for this body of work. They called it "historical apologies justifying Southern secession, defending the Confederate cause, and condemning Reconstruction." What formed such a man, and what his scholarship cost, are the questions ahead.
Coulter was born on the 20th of July 1890 in Catawba, North Carolina. His father, John Ellis Coulter, was a merchant and land speculator in Connelly Springs, a small town in the western Piedmont. The family was moderately wealthy by local standards.
John Ellis Coulter had hoped his son would enter the Lutheran ministry. Ellis chose history instead.
Both of Coulter's grandfathers had served in the Confederate States Army. One died in the Civil War. The other survived as a prisoner of war. During Reconstruction, that surviving grandfather was indicted for violence connected to the Ku Klux Klan. An all-white jury acquitted him.
At the University of North Carolina, Coulter would find his family's experiences refracted through scholarly argument. His mentor there was J. G. de Roulhac Hamilton, a historian whose views on Reconstruction would shape Coulter's work for decades.
J. G. de Roulhac Hamilton was a prominent historian at the University of North Carolina. He emphasized how Southern whites had suffered under Reconstruction. He also argued that freedmen and black Americans lacked the readiness for full political participation. Coulter trained under him and absorbed both arguments.
In 1914, Coulter moved to the University of Wisconsin-Madison for doctoral work. His professors there were also sympathetic to Southern interpretations of the Civil War and Reconstruction. The academic environment he moved through consistently reinforced what his family background had already suggested.
Before arriving at the University of Georgia, Coulter spent a brief period teaching at Marietta College in Ohio. That stay was short. Georgia would become his permanent home. His first book devoted to that state, A Short History of Georgia, appeared in 1933.
Two further editions of A Short History of Georgia followed, in 1947 and 1960. A separate History of Georgia appeared in 1954, written for junior high students. Coulter also wrote what became the standard textbook for Georgia history across multiple decades.
The Civil War and Readjustment in Kentucky, published in 1926, had already extended his reach outside the state. William G. Brownlow: Fighting Parson of the Southern Highlands appeared in 1939. College Life in the Old South went through two editions, in 1928 and 1951. Confederate States of America was published in 1952.
George Walton Williams, James Monroe Smith, Daniel Lee, and Thomas Spalding were among the figures Coulter profiled in dedicated biographies. He also documented the now-vanished towns of Auraria and Petersburg, treating local history as a lens on the state's larger development.
His 1966 volume, The Toombs Oak, the Tree that Owned Itself, showed how local legend could carry genuine historical meaning when examined carefully. The South During Reconstruction, published in 1947, would become the most scrutinized and contested book in his career.
In The South During Reconstruction, Coulter wrote that "The Negroes were fearfully unprepared to occupy positions of rulership." Black officeholding, in his account, was "the most spectacular and exotic development in government in the history of white civilization." He predicted it would be among the longest to be "remembered, shuddered at, and execrated."
Georgia's most prominent Reconstruction black officials, in Coulter's account, were swindlers and "scamps." He suggested that whatever positive qualities those officials possessed had been inherited from white ancestors.
The New Georgia Encyclopedia laid out the pattern plainly. Coulter had "framed his literary corpus to praise the Old South, glorify Confederate heroes, vilify northerners, and denigrate southern blacks." It described him as a leader of a generation who "viewed the South's past with pride and defended its racist policies and practices."
Coulter's "intellectual paradigm" about Reconstruction served, in the mid-twentieth century, as justification for maintaining Jim Crow segregation and opposing civil rights reform.
The historian Eric Foner documented that scholars like Coulter had "faithfully echoed Democratic propaganda of the post-Civil War years." Foner also found Coulter, as late as 1968, still working in that tradition. He described him as "the last wholly antagonistic scholar of the era."
Coulter had absorbed his arguments partly through training under J. G. de Roulhac Hamilton. They were also views widely shared among white Southerners of his generation. The reassessment of Coulter was, in that sense, a reassessment of a tradition rather than one man's idiosyncratic conclusions.
Coulter died in 1981. His 1956 book on Auraria as a Georgia gold-mining town showed a different dimension of his scholarly range. Younger historians would separate that careful local recovery from the arguments about Reconstruction that came to define his reputation.
Continue browsing
Common questions
Who was E. Merton Coulter?
E. Merton Coulter was an American historian born in Catawba, North Carolina on the 20th of July 1890. He spent six decades as a professor at the University of Georgia and served as the first president of the Southern Historical Association in 1934. He died in 1981.
What did E. Merton Coulter argue about Reconstruction?
In The South During Reconstruction (1947), Coulter wrote that "The Negroes were fearfully unprepared to occupy positions of rulership" and described black officeholding as "the most spectacular and exotic development in government in the history of white civilization." By the late twentieth century, historians described his body of work as "historical apologies justifying Southern secession, defending the Confederate cause, and condemning Reconstruction."
Why is E. Merton Coulter considered a controversial historian?
Coulter's scholarship consistently defended the Confederate cause and condemned Reconstruction-era black political participation. Historian Eric Foner described him, as late as 1968, as "the last wholly antagonistic scholar of the era," and documented that his arguments were used in the mid-twentieth century to justify maintaining Jim Crow segregation and opposing civil rights reform.
Where did E. Merton Coulter teach?
Coulter was a professor at the University of Georgia in Athens for six decades, serving as chair of its History Department for eighteen years starting in 1940. Before that appointment, he taught briefly at Marietta College in Ohio.
How many books did E. Merton Coulter write?
The Library of Congress lists fifty books written or edited by E. Merton Coulter, and he published more than 125 articles. His works ranged from Reconstruction history to biographies of Georgia figures and accounts of forgotten Georgia communities such as Auraria and Petersburg.
Who influenced E. Merton Coulter's historical views on the Civil War era?
Coulter's outlook was shaped significantly by his mentor at the University of North Carolina, J. G. de Roulhac Hamilton, who argued that Southern whites had suffered under Reconstruction and that freedmen lacked readiness for suffrage. In 1914, Coulter also studied at the University of Wisconsin-Madison under professors who held similar views.
All sources
2 references cited across the entry