DVD Talk

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  DVD Talk launched in January 1999 out of Beaverton, Oregon, founded by Geoffrey Kleinman at a moment when the DVD format was still finding its footing in American living rooms. The site promised something specific: news and reviews dedicated entirely to home video, with a particular eye on the hidden features buried inside disc menus that fans called Easter eggs. What followed was a community that grew large enough to catch the attention of a major retailer, an industry that leaned on the site to read its own market, and an eventual sale that changed the site's direction entirely. The questions worth asking are how a niche Oregon website carved out real influence, and what happened when that influence met the commercial internet.

• 2. The Amazon Pricing Incident

  ›

  In 2000, forum posts on DVD Talk triggered a concrete corporate retreat from Amazon.com. Users on the site's bulletin board identified and publicized Amazon's practice of dynamic pricing, a system where the same product was shown at different prices to different shoppers. The volume and clarity of the discussion drew enough attention that Amazon ceased the practice. That outcome placed DVD Talk in a category of online communities that demonstrated early web forums could function as consumer watchdog spaces, not merely fan gathering points. The incident made visible the difference between a passive audience and an active one.

• 3. Industry Insiders and Market Gauging

  ›

  At its height, DVD Talk was used by industry insiders to gauge interest in DVD titles. Studios and distributors, trying to read demand before committing to releases, treated the site's discussions as a real signal. Shawn Levy of The Oregonian called the site "worth a visit", and Randy Salas of the Star Tribune recommended it as a resource for DVD information. Those endorsements from journalists at regional newspapers reflected how DVD Talk had moved beyond its core enthusiast base. The site was a place where the opinions of collectors and casual buyers mixed in ways that the industry found genuinely useful.

• 4. The Easter Egg Coverage

  ›

  Alongside news and reviews, DVD Talk built a dedicated section covering hidden DVD features known as Easter eggs. These were bonus clips, jokes, or hidden menus that disc producers embedded for viewers willing to hunt for them. Cataloguing Easter eggs required an active community willing to share discoveries, and the forum structure of DVD Talk made that kind of collaborative documentation possible. The Easter egg coverage gave the site a function that no mainstream film magazine offered, drawing in a specific type of curious, detail-oriented viewer who would then stay for the reviews.

• 5. The 2007 Sale

  ›

  In 2007, DVD Talk was sold to Internet Brands, a company that acquired and operated web properties across multiple categories. Following the sale, the reviews and editorial blog ceased updating, ending the editorial voice that had defined the site since 1999. The bulletin board and forum, which carried the heaviest traffic, remained operational and active after the transition. The split outcome, a dead editorial layer over a living community, is a recognizable pattern in web media acquisitions. The forum's continued activity kept Kleinman's original January 1999 founding experiment alive in at least one form, even as the site's public-facing editorial identity went quiet.