— Ch. 1 · The Original Letter —
Darwin among the Machines.
~2 min read · Ch. 1 of 5
On the 13th of June 1863, The Press newspaper in Christchurch published a letter signed Cellarius. Samuel Butler wrote this piece to argue that machines were evolving like living creatures. He claimed mechanical life would eventually replace humans as the dominant species. The text urged immediate destruction of all machinery to save humanity. It called for war against every machine without exception. This radical stance appeared in a local New Zealand paper rather than a scientific journal.
Erewhon Adaptation
Butler expanded his newspaper argument into three chapters of his novel Erewhon. The book appeared anonymously in 1872 and described a society that destroyed most mechanical inventions. A narrator discovers an imaginary book explaining why this revolution occurred. Chapter twenty-three details how machines might reproduce like organisms. Chapter twenty-four explores whether machines can possess consciousness. Chapter twenty-five suggests humans remain necessary for machine maintenance despite potential subservience. The fictional society eliminated all machinery under two hundred seventy-one years old.Satire And Intent
Reviewers initially treated the machine chapters as mockery of Charles Darwin's theories. Butler protested in the second edition preface that he never intended to ridicule evolution. He feared offending Darwin and later explained the true target was Joseph Butler's 1736 work on religion. Herbert Sussman noted Butler may have genuinely explored if living things function as mechanisms. Louis Flaccus described the writing as a mix of humor, satire, and serious speculation. The author remained ambiguous about whether he believed machines could truly evolve.