Consumer goods in the Soviet Union

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Consumer goods in the Soviet Union carried an unusual definition of luxury: any good beyond plain bread, cabbage, potatoes, and vodka. A pair of shoes was a luxury. A bar of soap qualified. The nation built itself into one of the world's top three manufacturers of heavy industrial goods. Yet its output of light industrial products and consumer durables lagged badly behind, leaving demand only partially satisfied. How did a state that poured its energy into steel mills and railways justify that shortfall? And how did Soviet citizens learn to want, to obtain, and sometimes to covet the very goods their economy had long classified as secondary?

  23

• 2. Planning Steel Before Shoes

  ›

  Following the October Revolution of 1917, the Soviet economy moved rapidly away from its agricultural roots. The state organized all production into two categories. Group A covered heavy industry: everything that served as an input for making other goods. Group B covered consumer goods, meaning food, clothing, shoes, housing, and products like appliances and fuels that individuals actually used. From the first years of the Stalin era, Group A took top priority. The five-year plans governing the economy from 1928 to 1991 consistently channeled resources toward blast furnaces and machine tools first. The first five-year plan focused almost entirely on industrialization, with consumer output treated as a secondary concern.

  The second five-year plan, introduced in 1933, marked a partial shift. It attempted to redirect some production toward consumer goods alongside the continued industrial push. The Party Congress of February 1934 sharpened that intention, calling for improvement in both quantity and quality of food and other consumer goods. One year later, Stalin stood before the nation and declared: "Life has become more joyous." Stalin's declaration named a goal. What the distribution system could actually offer Soviet shoppers was a different question entirely.

  32

• 3. How Soviet Citizens Shopped

  ›

  By 1933, the closed distribution system served two thirds of Moscow's population and 58 percent of Leningrad's. These stores were not open to the general public. Access was limited to workers registered at a particular enterprise, and the goods distributed were rationed. The system existed to protect workers from the worst effects of chronic shortages while linking access to employment.

  From 1929 onward, three legal alternatives to the closed network existed alongside it. Commercial stores operated outside the rationing system entirely, but their prices ran two to four times higher than in the closed distribution stores. Kolkhoz markets allowed artisans and peasants to sell homemade goods at prices set by demand rather than the state. The third alternative was the Torgsin stores, which ran from 1930 to 1936. These sold scarce goods exclusively in exchange for foreign currency, gold, silver, and other valuables. Their stated purpose was to expand Soviet hard currency reserves to fund industrial imports. Prices were kept deliberately low to encourage citizens to part with family savings and valuables.

  At the end of 1933, Moscow's first department store opened: the Central Department Store. In January 1935, five department stores were operating across the entire USSR. By January 1936, fifteen more had opened, as the abolition of the closed distribution system in 1935 pushed the commercial network to expand rapidly.

  The first five-year plan had shut down all artisan methods of production, including small private factories and workshops. By the mid-1930s, some of that activity was allowed to return. In May 1936, a law legalized individual practice of specific trades. The list included cobbling, cabinetmaking, carpentry, dressmaking, hairdressing, laundering, locksmithing, photography, plumbing, tailoring, and upholstery. Food-related artisanal work remained banned. The Party had given considerable thought to what citizens were permitted to want. And to how they were supposed to feel about wanting it.

  325

• 4. Ideology and Desire

  ›

  Marxist-Leninist ideology held that empowering the proletariat was the state's central mission. For most of the Soviet Union's early years, consumer goods had been associated with the bourgeoisie and were therefore despised. When the state began directing a wider variety of goods toward all citizens, those goods needed a new meaning. Bolsheviks, the state decided, should be cultured and mannered individuals. The government offered guidance on table manners and on developing discerning taste in food and material goods. Knowing how to discuss the quality of goods with comrades was considered an important social skill.

  Official recognition in the Soviet system came with material rewards. The state gave consumer goods to comrades whose work had contributed to building socialism. This practice honored achievement, but it also created a new social hierarchy. A subset of the population received special privileges that the ordinary rationing system did not provide. The very culturalization the state had promoted ended up legitimizing concerns about status and possession that the revolution had once condemned. That tension would sharpen within a few years, as Soviet soldiers encountered a world of goods unlike anything available at home.

  234

• 5. Windows on the West

  ›

  The import of foreign goods during the 1930s was extremely limited. State policy acknowledged the gap directly. An official slogan summed up the position. "There is much to be learned from the example of the advanced capitalist countries in the field of consumer goods," it declared. Small amounts of foreign goods were imported, studied, and then copied. Soviet versions of these goods were distributed through existing consumption channels.

  During the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact period from 1939 to 1941, Soviet citizens had their most direct contact with foreign consumer goods. The occupied borderlands of Finland, the Baltic States, Bessarabia, and Poland held goods considered scarce inside the USSR: watches, bicycles, clothes, and food products. The occupying Red Army was fascinated by the diversity of goods available at low prices. Soldiers bought large quantities to send back to their families. Their purchases inspired Soviet civilians to seek permission to travel to these areas and buy goods to resell on the black market. For many, it was a once-in-a-lifetime chance to acquire things the Soviet economy had never produced in abundance.

  In the summer of 1959, a very different kind of encounter took place at Sokolniki Park in Moscow. The American National Exhibition was sponsored by the American government. It put on display home appliances, fashions, television sets, hi-fi sets, and a model house priced to sell to an average family. Farm equipment, 1959 automobiles, boats, sporting equipment, and a children's playground completed the exhibit. The model house carried a price that any Soviet visitor could see and compare against what an equivalent purchase would cost at home.

  513