Carlos Castillo Armas

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Carlos Castillo Armas was shot dead on the 26th of July 1957, inside the presidential palace in Guatemala City, by a member of his own guard. He had been walking with his wife when Romeo Vásquez Sánchez approached and fired twice. Castillo Armas died instantly. The man who killed him then fled to another room and, according to reports, took his own life.

  The killing was fast and clean, but the world Castillo Armas had built in three years of power was anything but. He had arrived at the palace not through a ballot box but through a CIA-backed invasion, a force of 480 men, a radio station broadcasting lies from Miami, and a cascade of American pressure that convinced a military to abandon its own president. What followed was a brief, brutal, and deeply consequential regime that reversed land reforms, outlawed unions, arrested tens of thousands, and set in motion a civil war that would kill 200,000 people over the next four decades. How did a lieutenant colonel from a remote Guatemalan garrison end up at the center of one of the Cold War's most consequential coups? And what did the United States actually get for the trouble?

• 2. A Soldier From Escuintla

  ›

  Carlos Castillo Armas was born on the 4th of November 1914, in Santa Lucía Cotzumalguapa in the department of Escuintla. His father was a landowner, but Castillo Armas was born out of wedlock, which made him ineligible to inherit the property. That detail set the terms of his life early: status was something he would have to earn, not receive.

  He graduated from Guatemala's military academy in 1936. One of his classmates there was Jacobo Árbenz, who would later become the president he helped to overthrow. For seven months between October 1945 and April 1946, Castillo Armas trained at Fort Leavenworth in Kansas, where he first came into contact with American intelligence officers. He rose through the ranks under the patronage of Colonel Francisco Javier Arana, a relationship that would define the early arc of his career.

  Árbenz, reflecting on those shared years, later described Castillo Armas as "modest, brave, sincere" and said he had fought with "great bravery" during the October 1944 coup against dictator Federico Ponce Vaides. The two men had stood on the same side of that revolt. Within a decade, they would be on opposite sides of everything.

• 3. Exile and the CIA

  ›

  Arana's failed coup attempt against President Arévalo on the 18th of July 1949 ended in Arana's death and left Castillo Armas stranded. He was at his posting in Mazatenango, Suchitepéquez, and did not even hear of the revolt until four days after it happened. Historians disagree on exactly what followed: some say he was expelled from the country; others say he was imprisoned under dubious charges until December 1949 and turned up in Honduras a month after his release.

  Either way, he landed in exile at precisely the right moment. In November 1950, just days after his final meeting with the CIA, he led a small group of supporters in an assault on Matamoros, the largest fortress in Guatemala City. The attack failed. He was wounded, arrested, and eventually bribed his way out of prison. Among the exile community in Honduras, that escape through a reputed tunnel made him a figure of romance and grit, regardless of whether the tunnel had actually existed.

  A CIA officer who first encountered him in January 1950 described Castillo Armas as "a quiet, soft-spoken officer who did not seem to be given to exaggeration." That quality, combined with his connections to right-wing dictators including Anastasio Somoza García of Nicaragua and Rafael Trujillo of the Dominican Republic, made him useful. The CIA kept him on a retainer of $3,000 a week, framed internally as a way of preventing him from taking premature action.

• 4. Operation PBSuccess

  ›

  Dwight Eisenhower was elected president of the United States in November 1952, and the machinery already in motion under Truman accelerated fast. In August 1953 his administration formally authorized Operation PBSuccess, with a budget of between five and seven million dollars. Secretary of State John Foster Dulles and CIA director Allen Dulles both held ties to the United Fruit Company, the American firm that dominated Guatemala's economy and had already been granted 200,000 hectares of public land under the previous dictator Ubico, along with a full exemption from taxes.

  The CIA considered several candidates to lead the coup. Miguel Ydígoras Fuentes, a conservative who had lost the 1950 election to Árbenz, was rejected partly for his role in the Ubico regime and partly because his European appearance was unlikely to appeal to the majority mestizo population. A coffee planter named Juan Córdova Cerna was a serious contender but was diagnosed with throat cancer in 1954. Historian Nick Cullather described Castillo Armas as "a physically unimposing man with marked mestizo features" -- a description the CIA seems to have treated as an asset. He was also, as they noted, the most dependable from their perspective. His clerical education during exile had even won him the support of Guatemala's archbishop.

  The CIA gave him enough money to recruit roughly 150 mercenaries from Guatemalan exiles and neighboring countries, branding the force the "Army of Liberation." Training camps were established in Nicaragua and Honduras. The preparations were only superficially covert; the CIA deliberately intended Árbenz to learn of them as part of a broader psychological strategy. A radio station called the "Voice of Liberation" began broadcasting on the 1st of May 1954, claiming to transmit from the Guatemalan jungle while actually being produced in Miami, then flown to Central America and broadcast through a mobile transmitter.

• 5. The Invasion and the Collapse

  ›

  On the 18th of June 1954, at 8:20 in the morning, Castillo Armas led his forces over the Guatemalan border. His army of 480 men had been divided into four teams, ranging from 60 to 198 soldiers each. One of those teams, the 60-man group, never made it; Salvadoran police intercepted them before they reached the border. The largest force was assigned to take Puerto Barrios, the major Atlantic harbor. Another was sent against Zacapa, the Guatemalan Army's largest frontier post.

  Both operations failed in direct military terms. At Zacapa, 122 rebels were routed by a garrison of just 30 loyalist soldiers; only 30 rebels escaped death or capture. At Puerto Barrios, the force was beaten back by policemen and armed dockworkers. Castillo Armas's aircraft, however, dealt the real blow: not in material damage, but in fear. Planes flying over the capital made the invasion seem far larger and more powerful than it was.

  The CIA's Voice of Liberation kept broadcasting reports of rebel troops converging on the city. Historian Piero Gleijeses later wrote that the Guatemalan officer corps would have remained loyal to Árbenz if not for US pressure; they feared that the United States would intervene militarily, and chose not to fight a battle they believed they could not win. On the 27th of June 1954, Árbenz met with the army's chief of staff, Colonel Carlos Enrique Díaz de León, who had already begun plotting with senior officers to force Árbenz out. Árbenz resigned that evening, leaving office at 8 pm and recording a resignation speech broadcast on radio an hour later. Historian Hugo Jiménez concluded that it was Díaz and the Guatemalan army, not Castillo Armas's invasion force, that constituted the critical factor in Árbenz's overthrow.

• 6. Power Through Coercion

  ›

  Castillo Armas did not simply inherit the presidency. He had to outmaneuver a series of juntas, with American ambassador John Peurifoy doing much of the maneuvering on his behalf. Allen Dulles later said Peurifoy's role was to "crack some heads together." The deal was announced at 4:45 am on the 2nd of July 1954. By the 8th of July, after Colonels Dubois and Cruz Salazar resigned per a secret agreement they had signed without their junta leader Monzón's knowledge, Castillo Armas was unanimously elected president of the junta. Dubois and Cruz Salazar were each paid $100,000 for their cooperation. The United States recognized the new government on the 13th of July.

  An election was held in early October 1954 with all political parties barred from participation. Castillo Armas ran as the only candidate and won 99 percent of the vote. The Movimiento de Liberación Nacional, which he led, was the only party allowed to contest the congressional elections held in late 1955. His closest statement of governing philosophy had been a document called the "Plan de Tegucigalpa," issued on the 23rd of December 1953, which criticized the "Sovietization of Guatemala." Beyond that, he had never articulated any particular philosophy, a fact that had worried his CIA handlers.

  What followed was a sweep of repression. He created the National Committee of Defense Against Communism, which over the following years investigated nearly 70,000 people. Decree 59, passed in August 1954, allowed security forces to detain anyone on the committee's blacklist for six months without trial. The eventual list of suspected communists included one in every ten adults in the country. José Bernabé Linares, who had run Ubico's secret police and was notorious for using electric-shock baths and steel skull-caps to torture prisoners, was placed in charge of the security forces. Historians have estimated that approximately 1,000 agricultural workers were killed by Castillo Armas's troops at Finca Jocatán alone, near Tiquisate.

• 7. The Land and the Debt

  ›

  Árbenz's Decree 900 had redistributed uncultivated portions of large land-holdings to agricultural laborers. Castillo Armas reversed it. Of the 529,939 manzanas of land expropriated under Decree 900, his government returned 368,481 manzanas to the original landowners. Thousands of peasants who tried to stay on the land they had received were arrested; landlords used those arrests to evict them. The US embassy itself noted that the reversal represented a "long step backwards."

  The economy spiraled. By April 1955, the government's foreign exchange reserves had fallen from $42 million at the end of 1954 to just $3.4 million. Unemployment had risen to 20,000 by the end of 1954, four times higher than during the latter years of the Árbenz government. In April 1955 the Eisenhower administration approved an aid package of $53 million and began underwriting Guatemalan government debt. Even so, Castillo Armas had asked the US for $260 million in aid as early as September 1954, a sign of how quickly his government had become dependent on external support.

  Corruption was pervasive. In 1955, during a corn famine, Castillo Armas granted corn import licenses to former fighters in exchange for a $25,000 bribe. The imported corn was later found by the United Nations to be unfit for consumption. When a student newspaper published the story, Castillo Armas launched a police crackdown against his critics. On the 25th of June 1956, government forces opened fire on student protesters, killing six people. He responded to the incident by declaring a state of siege and revoking all civil liberties, framing the protests, on the advice of the US ambassador, as a communist plot.

• 8. The Long Shadow

  ›

  Romeo Vásquez Sánchez, the presidential guard who shot Castillo Armas twice in the palace on the 26th of July 1957, was described as holding leftist sympathies. Whether he acted alone or as part of a larger conspiracy was never conclusively established. His death, self-inflicted in a nearby room moments after the shooting, ensured it remained an open question.

  The elections that followed produced a disputed result. The government-aligned candidate Miguel Ortiz Passarelli won a majority, but supporters of Miguel Ydígoras Fuentes rioted, the army annulled the vote, and a second election was held. Ydígoras Fuentes won by a comfortable margin, then declared a state of siege and seized full control.

  Historian Stephen Streeter argued that while the United States achieved certain strategic goals by installing Castillo Armas, it did so by destroying Guatemala's democratic institutions. Nick Cullather wrote that by removing Árbenz, the CIA actually undermined its own stated goal of stable Guatemalan governance. The leftist insurgencies that began in the countryside in 1960, sparked directly by the reversal of the agrarian reforms, grew into the Guatemalan Civil War, a conflict that ran from 1960 to 1996 and resulted in the deaths of 200,000 civilians. Ninety-three percent of atrocities against civilians were committed by the US-backed military. Among the worst episodes was a genocidal scorched-earth campaign against the indigenous Maya population during the 1980s. Historians have traced the anti-communist paranoia that drove that violence back to the coup of 1954.