Skip to content

Questions about Crowding out (economics)

Short answers, pulled from the story.

What is crowding out in economics?

Crowding out in economics describes how increased government involvement in a sector can reduce private-sector activity. The most discussed form involves government deficit spending raising interest rates as the government competes for investable funds, which then reduces private investment.

When does crowding out actually reduce private investment?

Crowding out is most effective when an economy is already at or near full capacity. At full employment, government borrowing competes for scarce resources and can raise interest rates enough to suppress private capital formation. When the economy has excess capacity, as economist Laura D'Andrea Tyson argued in 2012, the crowding-out effect is much weaker or absent.

What did Paul Krugman say about crowding out after the 2008 recession?

Paul Krugman observed that after the 2008 recession, U.S. federal borrowing increased by hundreds of billions of dollars and warnings of crowding out were widespread, yet interest rates actually fell rather than rose. This was consistent with the argument that crowding out does not operate when an economy has large amounts of spare capacity.

How does crowding out occur in health insurance programs like SCHIP?

In health economics, crowding out occurs when expansions to programs like Medicaid or the State Children's Health Insurance Program prompt people already covered by private insurance to switch to the new public program. New Jersey testified to a 14% crowd-out rate in its CHIP program, meaning a portion of enrollees had previously held private coverage.

What is the difference between crowding out and crowding in?

Crowding out occurs when government deficits raise interest rates and displace private investment. Crowding in is the opposite effect: when excess capacity exists in an economy, higher government spending raises demand and income, which then encourages additional private spending rather than displacing it.

How long has the crowding out debate been going on?

The idea behind crowding out has been discussed since at least the 18th century, though the term itself came later. Economic historian Jim Tomlinson, writing in 2010, traced the recurring British debate from post-World War One spending cuts through the interwar period and into the monetarist arguments of the 1970s and 1980s.